home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- Path: senator-bedfellow.mit.edu!dreaderd!not-for-mail
- Message-ID: <AudioFAQ/part8_1082200966@rtfm.mit.edu>
- Supersedes: <AudioFAQ/part8_1079601013@rtfm.mit.edu>
- Expires: 31 May 2004 11:22:46 GMT
- References: <AudioFAQ/part7_1082200966@rtfm.mit.edu>
- X-Last-Updated: 2002/08/30
- Newsgroups: rec.audio.tech,rec.audio.opinion,rec.audio.misc,rec.audio.marketplace,rec.answers,news.answers
- Subject: FAQ: rec.audio.* Wire 2/99 (part 8 of 13)
- Followup-To: poster
- Reply-To: neidorff@ti.com
- Approved: news-answers-request@mit.edu
- From: neidorff@ti.com
- Organization: Texas Instruments Corp.
- Summary: Answers to common questions about audio equipment, selecting,
- buying, set-up, tuning, use, repair, developments, and philosophy.
- Originator: faqserv@penguin-lust.MIT.EDU
- Date: 17 Apr 2004 11:27:33 GMT
- Lines: 367
- NNTP-Posting-Host: penguin-lust.mit.edu
- X-Trace: 1082201253 senator-bedfellow.mit.edu 576 18.181.0.29
- Xref: senator-bedfellow.mit.edu rec.audio.tech:181981 rec.audio.opinion:656782 rec.audio.misc:88793 rec.audio.marketplace:487245 rec.answers:86581 news.answers:269874
-
- Archive-name: AudioFAQ/part8
- Last-modified: 2000/4/12
- Version: 2.15
-
- 15.0 Wire
- More than any other topic, speaker cables and equipment
- interconnects seem to use up rec.audio.* bandwidth echoing
- the same theoretical arguments, testimonials, and opinions.
- Controversy can be stimulating, educational, and also amusing.
- Please try to keep postings aimed at one of those three goals,
- and avoid the insults and emotion. Also, try to avoid
- echoing a common position or principle, as described below.
-
- 15.1 Do speaker cables matter?
- To avoid confusion and repetition, here is some terminology,
- thanks to Steve Lampen of Belden Wire & Cable Co.
-
- A wire is a single conductor made up of one or more conducting
- elements, but all configured (as in a stranded design) to act
- as a single conductor. Mostly, this is coated or covered by
- plastic, rubber, enamel or similar insulators.
-
- Groups of wires are called cables. So zip cord is a cable,
- because it contains more than one insulated conducting
- element. Coaxial cable is also cable.
-
- Cables can introduce noise into the signal, act as a filter
- (and thus change the frequency response of the system),
- attenuate the signal (change the amplitude), and provide
- nonlinearities from oxidized or otherwise poor connections.
- Nonlinearities can distort the signal which add harmonics.
- Nonlinearities can also rectify or demodulate higher frequency
- signals into audible signals.
-
- It is quite scientifically conceivable that some cables do
- cause a difference in sound, because of the differences in DC
- resistance, interconductor capacitance, and connector attachment
- alone. The effects of exotic conductor weaving and materials
- are not so well established. In general, these effects (once
- we eliminate DC resistance), seem to be small. However, if your
- system is at least fairly good, then some folks have observed
- (although not in an experimental, double-blind sense)
- significant differences in system performance with different
- cables. The effects are said to be quite system specific; the
- only real guideline is to try them and see which ones seem to
- sound better in your system.
-
- Roughly speaking, the price ranges for speaker cables is low
- (under $1/ft), medium (under $6-8/ft), and high (up to $100/ft
- and more). Try to arrange it so you can trial such cables; at
- several hundred dollars per set, experiments can be expensive.
-
- In any system or experiment, it is essential that the
- differences between cables be separated from the
- differences between connectors.
-
- You should have an EXTREMELY solid connection between cable and
- speaker. Speakers operate at very low impedances, so that bad
- connections will create significant artifacts or signal losses
- at any power level. For example, if the connection has a linear
- resistance of just 1 ohm, the speaker damping factor may be
- changed, and the bass may suffer. If the connection contains
- imperfect metal oxides, then a slightly rectifying junction will
- block the signal, producing compression, distortion, and other
- non-linear effects.
-
- There are many magazine articles on cables with various
- perspectives which are worth reading, including:
- "Speaker Cables: Testing for Audibility"
- Fred E. Davis
- Audio, July 1993, pgs. 34-43
-
- 15.2 What speaker cables are available and how good are they?
- There is a wide range of speaker wire available, ranging from
- 30ga zip cord (~$.10/ft) to exotic wires costing over $300/ft.
- The material used ranges from copper to oxygen-free copper
- (OFC) to silver. (There are a bunch of others as well.)
-
- Oxygen-free copper is probably NOT any different from common
- copper in sound. If you hear a difference between two cables,
- it is not a difference between oxygen-free and common copper.
-
- Resistance may be significant for speaker cables. The higher
- the resistance, the more the cable will affect the sound, all
- else equal. The resistance characteristic of metals is called
- resistivity. The resistivity of copper is 1.7 microohm-cm.
- Silver is very slightly lower, 1.6. Gold is a bit higher, 2.4.
-
- Silver and gold are different from copper in other ways than
- resistivity. Gold does not oxidize in normal environments,
- so gold contacts will not need periodic cleaning and will not
- create rectifying junctions. Silver will oxidize, but the
- oxide of silver is conductive, so oxidized silver will still
- make good contact. Copper oxide is a bad conductor. Oxidized
- copper contacts may insulate, may conduct, or may rectify.
- Copper is a bad material for cable terminals, but this may or
- may not mean anything for the conductor itself.
-
- 15.3 What can I use for budget speaker cables?
- First, a few words on terminology. Wire is sized by AWG or BS
- gauge number. Larger numbers represent smaller wire. AWG 40
- (also called 40 gauge) is as fine as human hair. AWG 12 is 2mm
- or .081" diameter. If you reduce the AWG number by 3 (such as
- from 29 to 26) then the wire cross-sectional area increases by
- a factor of 2 and the series resistance drops by a factor of 2.
-
- Some wire is classified as solid, because it contains one
- strand per conductor. Other wire is called stranded, because
- it consists of many strands per conductor. Stranded wire is
- far more flexible than solid wire. Most wire is made from
- drawn copper. Some wire is sold that is claimed to be made
- with a process that produces oxygen-free copper. Oxygen-free
- copper has a different metallurgical structure than common
- copper and may or may not conduct current better.
-
- Some critical listeners have reported excellent sound from large
- diameter solid copper wire, such as home wiring "Romex 12-2".
- At least one expert has said that common 18-gauge solid copper
- hook-up wire sold by Radio Shack also works very well. Also
- recommended on a budget is Sound King wire, a 12 gauge oxygen
- free copper stranded cable. This is available from MCM
- Electronics for $.39/ft.
-
- Scientifically, thinner wire has more resistance than fatter
- wire, so fatter wire will have less resistance-related effects.
- Resistance effects can be eliminated by using at least 12
- gauge wire, particularly for long runs. Of course, shorter
- runs are always preferred, because they come much closer to
- the ideal zero-length wire, with no resistance, no
- capacitance, no inductance, and no change in signal.
-
- 15.4 What can I use for budget speaker connectors?
- The worst connectors are push-down, or spring terminals. Screw
- terminals with solid copper wire are much better. Gold-plated
- binding posts and gold spade lugs are inexpensive by audiophile
- standards and are extremely stable. Binding posts with spade
- lugs can be tightened to get a very good mechanical joint, and
- may offer the lowest electrical resistance of any connector.
-
- Gold plated banana plugs and jacks are very good speaker
- terminals. Good ones are more expensive than gold spade lugs,
- however, they also provide a bigger area of contact, and are
- more convenient when you must frequently reconfigure the system.
- Banana plugs should be periodically monitored for corrosion and
- loss of spring tension. Monster offers a banana-plug connector
- with an expanding center pin that forms an even better
- connection than common gold banana plugs. At approximately $25
- per pair, the Monster banana plugs aren't a budget connector.
-
- All else equal, connectors with gold surfaces are better than
- connectors with any other surface. This is for two reasons.
- First, gold is extremely inert, meaning that unless gold is
- exposed to very harsh chemicals or harsh vapors, it will not
- corrode or oxidize. It will remain a pure, low-resistance
- conductor. Second, gold is quite soft, so that if a
- gold-plated connector is squeezed between two metal
- surfaces, it will deform slightly to fill scratches and
- voids, giving a very broad, low-resistance contact area.
-
- Corrosion of connectors is often a problem. Gold-plated
- terminals and connectors somewhat avoid this problem;
- problems with other connectors can be mitigated by
- unplugging and replugging the connector on a regular basis,
- cleaning the contact areas with a pencil eraser, or by
- using a contact enhancer such as Cramolin or Tweek. When
- you use a contact enhancer, be very sure to follow the
- directions, and avoid spreading enhancer about your equipment.
-
- 15.5 What about interconnects, such as the cable between tuner and amp?
- Line-level interconnects conduct smaller signals than speaker
- cables; the typical signal ranges from -2V to +2V (the CD
- output standard) with currents in the microamps (the
- corresponding values for speaker cables attached to a largish
- power amp might be -70V to +70V and currents of many amps).
- Line-level interconnects can be divided into single-ended (or
- unbalanced), and balanced interconnects. Home audio is almost
- always single-ended interconnects.
-
- Single-ended interconnects almost always use a form of the
- RCA connector (or phono plug). RCA plugs form fair to poor
- connections that degrade with time as corrosion works into the
- metal-metal contact and as the spring tension of the connectors
- relax. Gold-plating reduces the effect of corrosion and locking
- RCA connectors solve most of the mechanical problems. However,
- these premium phono connectors are rare and expensive. For
- example, a gold-plated Vampire locking RCA plug costs
- approximately $23/pair. If RCA connectors weren't a de facto
- standard, we'd recommend against them.
-
- Unbalanced interconnect wires vary in geometry, material and
- price. Cheaper wires have a single conductor (normally
- stranded) and a shield and cost $.20-$2/ft. Medium (complexity
- and price) wires have two conductors (often arranged as a
- twisted pair) surrounded by a shield and cost from about
- $3-$20/ft. Exotic wires have all sorts of geometries and
- materials (such as stranded silver conductors, or ribbon cable
- braided around a core, or in one extreme case, a tube filled
- with mercury!). Prices may be as high as $200-$300/ft.
-
- Balanced interconnects have three conductors: two for the signal
- one for ground, and additionally a shield. The standard
- connector for balanced cable is the ITT/Cannon XLR connector,
- which is quite good mechanically (they lock). Equivalent
- connectors are also available from Switchcraft, Neutrik, and
- other vendors. If you have to run cables longer than 12 feet or
- 4 meters, the greater noise immunity of balanced interconnects
- is often a good idea. For this reason, balanced connectors are
- standard equipment in professional installations such as
- studios, public address systems, and broadcast stations. There
- is not much variation in balanced cables. The three brands
- mentioned above are known to be rugged, high quality and
- moderately priced. Slightly weaker imported connectors are
- available, but they aren't dramatically cheaper. Better
- connectors are also easier to assemble and have a more durable
- cord strain-relief.
-
- For most systems, the most important aspect of a cable are
- the mechanical reliability of the connectors; in particular,
- the joint between connector and wire, and the joint between
- connector and socket. Typically, interconnect cables are
- short. It is worth getting just the right length; cables
- often come in .5 meter increments. With quite good systems,
- some people observe differences in sound between various
- interconnects. This is quite system-specific and the same
- advice as given above applies: try several brands. Most
- good dealers will loan interconnects for home evaluation.
-
- In cables where the shield does not carry the signal or ground,
- the shield is normally only connected to ground at one end.
- In systems where there are significant differences between
- ground levels on various components, it may make a difference
- which way such cables are connected. Typically, the end where
- the shield is grounded should be at the source of the signal.
- Often, such cable has arrows on it pointing in the direction of
- the signal flow. In any case, try both orientations.
-
- There are many objective reasons why cables might cause
- differences in sound by interacting with the drivers in the
- signal sources as well as by providing non-linear effects in the
- RCA connector. Most of these effects are again related to
- interconductor capacitance and resistance, and the quality of
- the shielding provided by the "shield" conductor. In balanced
- cables the quality of the "twisted pair" inside the shield is
- also important. One might note that a shield protects from only
- capacitively coupled interference, and not from any magnetic
- field interference. The twisted pair in a balanced line provide
- some magnetic rejection, as does steel conduit. However, steel
- conduit has other characteristics which make it undesirable for
- audio in general.
-
- 15.6 What about Phono Interconnects:
- Phono interconnects are part of the link between a cartridge on
- a turntable and a preamp (or head amp or receiver). They are a
- special case of line-level interconnects because the signal is
- much lower, typically 1 to 50 millivolts. They are also
- intended to operate into a higher impedance, typically 47K ohms,
- and form part of the capacitive load for the cartridge.
-
- The low signal levels mean that the shielding of the cable, and
- the presence of a separate drain/shield are more important, as
- is a good ground. A separate solid ground should come along
- with the cable as a separate lead co-routed with the cable.
-
- In addition, the low signal levels make a good solid connection
- to and through the connectors MUCH more important, because of
- the greater sensitivity to low-level nonlinearities.
-
- Wire capacitance is often ignored in line-level interconnects;
- however, in a phono interconnect, it may constitute half of the
- total capacitive load of the cartridge. Obviously, then, two
- cables with significantly different capacitances should sound
- differently. In this sense, the "right" cable for one cartridge
- may be too low or high in capacitance for another cartridge.
-
- For low-impedance cartridges (most moving coil cartridges),
- the wire must have low resistance to prevent cartridge unloading
- and frequency-dependent signal loss. In addition, as the
- signal levels are quite low, shielding is important.
-
- Unfortunately, copper shields do not block stray magnetic
- fields, so in the case of phono cables, careful routing may be
- even more effective at reducing hum than special wire.
-
- 15.7 Is there really a difference in digital interconnects?
- There are now three kinds of digital interconnects that connect
- transports to D/A converters: coax, plastic fiber (Toslink) and
- glass fiber (AT&T ST). In theory, these should sound EXACTLY
- the same (bits are bits). However, this assumes good circuit
- design (in particular, the clock recovery circuits of the DAC,
- and careful consideration of electronic noise) which may be
- compromised because of cost considerations or ignorance. Note:
- different signaling schemes are used on plastic and glass fiber.
-
- In any case, some people claim to hear a difference;
- of those who do, most seem to prefer the glass fiber.
- However, the technology of fast digital data transmission
- in consumer electronics is evolving very quickly now.
- Any specific recommendation should be treated with
- suspicion until the industry matures.
-
- 15.8 Can I make very good interconnects myself?
- Yes. You will need to be the judge of whether or not they
- are as good as $100 interconnects, but it is easy to make
- interconnects that are better than the $2.00 set which comes
- with new equipment.
-
- There are two necessary ingredients: two-conductor shielded
- cable and RCA connectors. There is a lot of debate over what
- is the best cable, but in general, the lower the capacitance
- per foot, the better. Choice of insulation is harder. There
- may be an advantage to polypropylene or teflon over polyester
- or rubber, but even that is debatable. If you are buying wire
- from an electronics distributor, some have successfully used
- Belden 1192A microphone cable. It is rubber insulated, so very
- flexible. Another recommended cable is Belden 8451. This is
- a polypropylene cable with foil shield. Finally, consider
- Belden 89182. This is foamed teflon insulated, so very low
- capacitance, and foil shielded. If you plan to make a long
- cable, this low capacitance cable may be the best choice.
-
- There is also a variety of RCA connectors available. A
- good connector would be gold plated and machined to tight
- tolerances. A poorer connector will not fit as well, will
- make poorer contact as the connecting surface oxides, and
- will lose its springiness with use.
-
- When wiring the cable to the connector, use one wire for
- signal, (the tip of the RCA connector) and one wire for
- ground (the shell or outer conductor of the RCA connector).
-
- Some cables use a foil shield which is difficult to solder.
- These cables typically have a drain wire parallel to the foil
- which can be used for soldering. Others use a braided shield.
-
- Regardless of which type of wire you have, connect the shield
- or the shield drain wire to ground on only ONE SIDE. This will
- stop noise picked up by the shield from causing ground noise.
-
- It can be a touchy job soldering RCA connectors. Before
- you use your new cables, check with an ohmmeter or
- a continuity tester to make sure that you have not
- accidentally sorted the signal and ground leads together,
- either with a stray drop of solder or a loose wire strand.
-
- 15.9 Is there a standard for wiring balanced XLR-3 cables?
- Yes. Connect pin 1 to ground/green, pin 2 to white, and
- pin 3 to black. Herb Hamilton suggests that you remember
- "George Washington Bridge" and then use the first letter
- of each word (GWB) to help you remember Green=1, White=2,
- and Black=3. This same wiring convention works for
- balanced line level signals and balanced microphone cables.
-
- COPYRIGHT NOTICE
- The information contained here is collectively copyrighted by the
- authors. The right to reproduce this is hereby given, provided it is
- copied intact, with the text of sections 1 through 8, inclusive.
- However, the authors explicitly prohibit selling this document, any
- of its parts, or any document which contains parts of this document.
-
- --
- Bob Neidorff; Texas Instruments | Internet: neidorff@ti.com
- 50 Phillippe Cote St. | Voice : (US) 603-222-8541
- Manchester, NH 03101 USA
-
- Note: Texas Instruments has openings for Analog and Mixed
- Signal Design Engineers in Manchester, New Hampshire. If
- interested, please send resume in confidence to address above.
-