|
Microsoft® Internet Explorer 4.0 vs. Netscape Communicator Competitive Guide
This document provides an informative framework for organizations and individuals to compare Microsoft« Internet Explorer 4.0 and Netscape Communicator for the Windows« 95 and Windows NT« 4.0 operating systems. This document should be read in conjunction with the Microsoft Internet Explorer 4.0 for Windows 95 and Windows NT 4.0 White Paper, which discusses in more detail many of the features mentioned here.
MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, IN THIS DOCUMENT.
Executive Summary
Microsoft and Netscape are both planning to release their respective next-generation Internet client suites in mid-1997. While both products promise to offer users advances in technology and enhanced features, the two product strategies differ in vision and scope. Microsoft has a much broader vision for Internet Explorer 4.0, and our product offering is more comprehensive than Netscape's.
Internet Explorer 4.0 expands on Internet Explorer 3.0's innovations to achieve Microsoft's vision: complete integration of the Internet and the PC. This evolutionary product integrates the browser into the operating system, creating a single way to find, use, and work with all the information that users need, whether it's on their personal computer, a shared local network, or the World Wide Web. At the same time, Internet Explorer 4.0 is an open, standards-based, integrated suite of Internet software that includes the most advanced browser, communication and collaboration, and Webcasting solutions for end users, IT managers, and developers. An additional and important distinction between Microsoft's offering and Netscape's is that Internet Explorer 4.0 has been designed to solve the needs of both home users and business users.
Netscape Communicator and Netcaster offer a more limited vision and product offering than Internet Explorer 4.0. Their positioning is more akin to a set of middleware applications for business users to solve groupware needs, ignoring home user needs. Netcaster does not offer any integration with the underlying OS that Internet Explorer 4.0 does to create a truly integrated Web and native PC experience, plus Netcaster's information delivery model relies on proprietary protocols and does not support the proposed Channel Definition Format (CDF) standard. Communicator lacks the level of advancement that Internet Explorer 4.0 delivers in Web technology (such as site subscriptions, Dynamic HTML, and an object model for Web pages) and user enhancements (such as autocomplete URLs or search bar). And Communicator includes more proprietary standards (e.g., vCalendar), proprietary extensions (e.g., Collabra), and HTML tags (e.g., Layer).
Internet Explorer 4.0 brings incredible advances to browsing technology, allows for scaleable/open communication and collaboration, and enables the content of any Web site to be delivered directly to users' desktops. These advances make it easier for people to communicate with others, find relevant and personalized information, and create compelling Web content. The end result is a dramatically easier and more personalized way for users to get the most out of the Internet, enjoying a more entertaining and productive Web experience. Microsoft's broad vision for Internet Explorer 4.0's comprehensive suite of Internet applications includes the following benefits:
- The Best Browser for end users and organizations, as well as a next-generation development platform for content developers.
- Complete Communication and Collaboration, providing HTML-rich, Internet standards-based applications that deliver audio/video/data conferencing, messaging, Web broadcasting, and discussion groups.
- Webcasting of Sites and Channels, providing a rich and open authoring and publishing capability for sending and receiving information through either Web sites, channels, e-mail messages, or software components.
- True Web Integration, which makes Internet access a seamless part of your operating system, and therefore your PC.
- Complete Administrative Features for businesses, so corporations have the best client for improved corporate communication, easy deployment and administration, and reduced total cost of ownership.
With Communicator and Netcaster, Netscape is focusing primarily on intranets and business users. Unfortunately, they leave out the entire home and small business markets, while only partially solving the needs of business users. Microsoft sees two distinct market segments in terms of collaboration: basic collaboration and full collaboration. For basic collaboration—such as e-mail, application sharing, and chatting—Internet Explorer 4.0 is the premium, best-of-breed client. The other portion of the market, which needs high-end collaboration solutions, should compare Communicator's limited offerings with the more complete solutions found in Microsoft Exchange and Outlook products, or in IBM's Lotus Notes. Microsoft's solution is designed to offer a scaleable set of communication and collaboration clients that allow users to select which is most appropriate for them. For the user who needs basic collaboration, Microsoft believes that Internet Explorer 4.0 offers a much better solution than Communicator, while also providing the opportunity to scale up to a more powerful solution when required.
Netscape defines integration as a suite of applications that reside in one monolithic program, which operates on top of the native operating system. Netscape has chosen to provide a one-size-fits-all set of communication applications that all Communicator users are forced to install, regardless of their needs. For example, if you have already standardized on an e-mail system and you install Communicator, you will now have two e-mail clients installed on every system. Additionally, your production e-mail client will not integrate into Communicator. Microsoft understands that the investments organizations and users have made in e-mail clients cannot be taken lightly, and therefore has designed Internet Explorer 4.0 to be open and to interoperate fully with any e-mail client.
Netscape had originally planned to include an overlying shell on top of the underlying operating system with Constellation. They have removed that functionality from Netcaster. This is a wise move, considering a new "shell"—or layer—on top of the existing operating system would have required substantial investments in training and support. Microsoft understands that organizations and users have already made investments in training, and certainly want to take advantage of that investment. Instead of adding another layer on top of the OS, Internet Explorer 4.0 extends Windows to naturally take advantage of Web tasks. Microsoft is committed to bringing Internet Explorer 4.0's advances in the browser, content delivery, and communications to the Windows 3.1, Macintosh, and Unix platforms.
Netscape has also removed its originally planned roaming user support from Netcaster. Microsoft believes that the more important near-term issue is to provide powerful and easy-to-use central administration capabilities for corporate MIS, so that they can effectively control costs while improving overall productivity. And of course, Internet Explorer 4.0 takes advantage of the capabilities that already exist in the Windows 95 and Windows NT operating systems, running on Windows NT-based server networks, to enable roaming user- and multiple user-support.
Finally, Internet Explorer 4.0 enables a business model that allows content developers and corporations to use their abilities in a way that truly adds to their business objectives with a wealth of development tools for developing effective, powerful implementations of channels and Web sites that use Internet Explorer 4.0.
The following table provides a comparison of the features and capabilities of Microsoft Internet Explorer 4.0 and Netscape Communicator and Netcaster.
Best Browser Features |
Ease-of-Use & Personalization |
IE 4.0 Browser |
Netscape Navigator |
AutoComplete Address Bar |
Yes |
No |
Integrated Search Bar |
Yes |
No |
Suite Integration with easy suite switching |
Yes |
Partial |
Smart Favorites with auto web site checking |
Yes |
No |
Drag and drop to favorites toolbar or menu |
Yes |
Yes |
Reorder links using drag and drop in menu |
Yes |
No |
Thumbnail view of Favorite sites |
Yes |
No |
Offline browsing |
Yes |
Unknown |
Navigation History with Back/Next buttons |
Yes |
Yes |
Reorder and Combine Toolbars |
Yes |
Reorder |
Use Mail/News client of choice |
Yes |
No |
Full-screen browser and Kiosk modes |
Yes
|
Yes (NYI) |
User-friendly Error, alert & status messages |
Yes |
No |
International Language Support |
25-30 (final) |
11 (final) |
Dynamic HTML |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
True Dynamic HTML Styles |
Yes |
No |
CSS Absolute Positioning with Z-order |
Yes |
Yes |
Dynamic Content (HTML Object Model) |
Yes |
No |
Multimedia & Animation |
Yes |
No |
Data Binding & Awareness |
Yes |
No |
HTML 3.2 & Compatibility |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
HTML 3.2 Support |
Yes |
Yes |
W3C HTML OBJECT tag |
Yes |
Yes (NYI) |
Enhanced Frames (borderless, inline, floating) |
Yes |
Borderless |
Cascading Style Sheets (CSS1) |
Yes (core + advanced) |
Partial (core only) |
File upload |
Yes |
Yes |
Server push |
Yes |
Yes |
Automatic Proxy Configuration |
Yes |
Yes |
HTTP 1.1 support |
Partial |
Unknown |
Downloadable Web fonts (True Type Std) |
Yes |
No (non-std Bitstream) |
Unicode International character support |
Yes |
Yes |
Rich Forms |
Yes |
Unknown |
Interactivity |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
Full ActiveX support |
Yes |
No |
ActiveX Control Viewer |
Yes |
No |
Java Bean Support |
Yes |
No |
ActiveX Script Debugger |
Yes |
No |
Auto-Install and signing of plug-ins |
Yes |
Yes |
COM/DCOM Support |
Yes |
No |
CORBA/IIOP Support |
No |
Yes |
Installable JIT architecture |
Yes |
No |
Java |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
Improved AWT |
Yes |
Partial |
Advanced Class Libraries |
Yes (AFC) |
Yes (IFC) |
JDK 1.1 cross-platform support |
Yes |
Yes (NYI) |
Java Beans support |
Yes |
Unknown |
Automatic & bi-directional integration of ActiveX components and Java Beans |
Yes |
No |
Dynamic HTML Object Model exposed to Java |
Yes |
No |
Multimedia class libraries with DirectX support |
Yes |
No |
Auto-install of Java class libraries |
Yes |
Unknown |
Just-in-Time Compiler |
Yes |
Yes |
Scripting |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
Scripting of Java Applets |
JavaScript & VBScript |
JavaScript only |
Support for native document formats (such as Word.doc or Excel.xls) within the browser |
Yes |
Yes (NYI) |
VBScript Support |
Yes |
No |
JavaScript-compatible scripting |
Yes |
Yes |
Integration of objects and scripts |
Yes |
Partial |
Full event model for all tags & all scriptable |
Yes |
No |
Scripting of Plug-ins |
No |
Yes |
Multimedia |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
Multimedia Controls |
Yes |
No |
Interactive Music Control |
Yes |
No |
Progressive Playback of Video/Audio files |
Yes |
Yes |
In-line (streamed) sound support |
Yes |
Yes |
Video Streaming support |
Yes |
Yes |
Native QuickTime video playback |
Yes |
No |
Native MPEG video/audio playback |
Yes |
No |
3D Animation & VRML 2.0 |
Yes |
Yes |
Performance |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
Native Shell Integration |
Yes |
No |
Fast Java VM/JIT |
Yes |
Yes (NYI) |
Fast Cache |
Yes |
Unknown |
Direct CD-ROM support |
Yes |
Yes |
Partial download support |
Yes |
No |
Security |
IE 4.0 |
Navigator |
SSL 2.0/3.0 support, PCT 1.0 support |
Yes |
No PCT |
Client & Server authentication |
Yes |
Yes |
Code signing for Navigator Plug-ins, ActiveX |
Yes |
No |
Code Signing for Java Applets |
Yes |
Yes |
Support for Java applet "sandboxing" |
Yes |
Yes |
Capabilities-based Java security |
Yes |
Yes |
PICS ratings |
Yes |
No |
Wallet |
Yes |
No |
Personal Information Exchange (PFX) |
Yes |
Unknown |
Smart Card Authentication and applications |
Yes |
Limited |
Cryptographic API |
Yes |
No |
Complete Communication and Collaboration |
Mail |
Outlook Express |
Netscape Messenger |
SMTP/POP3, NNTP, IMAP4, LDAP, MIME, S/MIME, MIME HTML standard support |
Yes |
Yes |
Can view & compose full HTML messages |
Yes |
Yes |
Multiple mail servers |
Yes |
Unknown |
Offline Mail and News support |
Yes |
Yes |
Rich Mail filtering |
Yes |
Partial |
Search Messages on server and locally |
Local |
NYI |
Auto Add to Address Book |
Yes |
Unknown |
LDAP Lookup |
Yes |
Yes |
Automatic name resolution/auto-lookup from personal address book and LDAP servers |
Yes |
No |
Auto-complete from Personal Address book |
No |
Yes |
3-pane view |
Yes |
No |
Customizable Toolbar |
Yes |
No |
Stationery Templates |
Yes |
No |
vCard Support |
Yes |
Yes |
Secure password authentication using SASL |
Yes |
No |
Send encrypted and/or signed mail |
Yes |
Yes |
Newsgroups & Discussions |
Outlook Express |
Netscape Collabra |
Customizable Toolbar |
Yes |
No |
HTML View & Compose |
Yes |
Yes |
Multiple news servers |
Yes |
Yes |
Threaded Message views |
Yes |
Yes |
Watch Response Threads to my Messages |
Yes |
No |
Create internal discussion groups |
Yes |
Yes |
Secure discussions with SSL 3.0 |
Yes |
Yes |
Live Conferencing |
Microsoft NetMeeting |
Netscape Conference |
Standards-based conferencing |
T.120,H.323 |
H.323 only |
True Application sharing |
Yes |
No |
Audio Conferencing |
Multipoint enabled |
Point-to-Point only |
Video Conferencing (H.323, H.263, H.261) |
Yes |
No |
Data Conferencing (T.120 Multipoint) |
Yes |
No |
LDAP Directory Lookup |
Yes |
No |
Collaborative Whiteboard |
Multipoint |
Point-to-Point |
Multipoint File Transfer (T.127 standard) |
Yes |
No |
Chat |
Multipoint |
Point-to-Point |
Live & On-Demand Broadcasting |
Microsoft NetShow |
Netscape Media Player |
Streaming Video playback |
Yes |
Yes |
Streaming Illustrated audio (images synchronized with audio tracks) |
Yes |
Yes |
Streaming audio |
Yes |
Yes |
Live Audio IP Multicast |
Yes |
Yes |
Video IP Multicast |
Yes |
No |
File IP Multicast |
Yes |
No |
Rich scheduling capabilities |
Yes |
No |
HTML Authoring & Publishing |
Microsoft FrontPad |
Netscape Composer |
General Features |
Page Wizard and Templates |
Yes |
Yes |
WYSIWYG editing |
Yes |
Yes |
Table editing & creation |
Yes |
Yes |
Import and convert images |
Yes (Office 97) |
Yes |
Style pages |
Yes |
Yes |
Web Technology Tools |
Netscape Plug-Ins |
Yes |
Yes |
Java applets |
Yes |
Yes |
JavaScript |
Yes |
Yes |
Active X Controls |
Yes |
No |
VB Script |
Yes |
No |
Publishing Tools |
Web Publishing Wizard |
Yes |
No |
Web server |
Yes |
No |
Information Delivery |
Premium Channels |
IE 4.0 |
Netscape Constellation |
Exclusive Premium Channels |
Yes |
Unknown |
Channel content type supported: Any HTML, Dynamic HTML, applets, ActiveX controls |
Yes |
Unknown |
Pluggable Custom Content Delivery Protocols |
Yes |
Unknown |
Offline Channel viewing |
Yes |
Yes |
Mini channels (tickers, company phone directories, stock quotes, etc.) |
Yes |
Yes |
Subscriptions |
IE 4.0 |
Netscape |
Web Content Receive Options |
In locally cached web pages |
Yes |
Unknown |
In Desktop Web component, channels, tickers |
Yes |
Yes |
In Taskbars |
Yes |
No |
In Mail |
Yes |
InBox Direct Only |
Notification Options |
Email, Taskbar icon, Favorite tooltips |
Yes |
No |
On the Desktop |
Yes |
Yes |
Indication on Favorite icons |
Yes |
Yes |
Subscription Status Folder |
Yes |
Unknown |
Offline Reading |
IE 4.0 |
Netscape Constellation |
Integrated offline support for Web sites, channels, mail, news |
Yes |
No |
Download Favorite Web sites |
Yes |
Yes |
Support site passwords |
Yes |
Unknown |
Control how many pages deep you want |
Yes |
Unknown |
Customized Download Schedule |
Yes |
Unknown |
True Web Integration Features: Integrate the Web and your PC |
Single Explorer |
IE 4.0 |
Netscape Constellation |
Single click navigation & icon launching on Web, PC, and LAN |
Yes |
No |
Single window for navigating local & Web |
Yes |
No |
Unified toolbar adjusts for file vs. Web browsing |
Yes |
No |
Combined Web and local favorites, available everywhere |
Yes |
No |
HTML viewing of file systems |
Yes |
No |
Native File Management |
Yes |
No |
HTML-based Help |
Yes |
Yes |
Start Menu & Taskbar |
IE 4.0 |
Netscape Constellation |
Start Menu Options (Selector Bar for Constellation) |
Launch Web icons |
Yes |
Yes |
Contains your Favorite Web sites |
Yes |
Unknown |
Contains History List |
Yes |
No |
Drag and drop customization of all items (applications, favorites, etc.) |
Yes |
Unknown |
Taskbar and Toolbars |
Allows creation of multiple toolbars for launching files, applications, Web tasks |
Yes |
Yes |
Switch natively between applications |
Yes |
No |
Can contain optional URL address, favorite links, tickers, or desktop shortcuts |
Yes |
No |
Can contain file shortcuts, or search forms |
Yes |
No |
Toolbars can float, dock, or merge anywhere |
Yes |
No |
Active Desktop |
IE 4.0 |
Netscape Constellation |
Web Components on the Native Desktop |
Yes |
No |
Put any HTML content onto the desktop |
Yes |
Unknown |
Add data from Web via button-click, drag and drop |
Yes |
Unknown |
Channel Bar |
Yes |
Yes |
Screen Saver |
Yes |
Unknown |
Create custom desktops and manage them |
Yes |
Yes |
Automatically update content via Web |
Yes |
Yes |
Offline caching |
Yes |
Yes |
Rearrange/resize desktop components |
Yes |
Unknown |
Show pre-existing content from native desktop |
Yes |
No |
Complete Administrative Features |
Central Administration |
IE4.0 Admin Kit |
Netscape Admin Kit & AutoAdmin |
Easy, single-step wizard-based set up |
Yes |
No |
Pre-configuration of desktop and browser |
Yes |
Yes |
All options can be configured & "locked down" |
Yes |
Yes |
Hands-free setup in corporate deployment |
Yes |
Yes |
Automatic migration of existing configurations |
Yes |
No |
Automatic Proxy Configuration |
Yes |
Yes |
Set up and control; update user profiles |
Yes (Win32) |
Yes |
Multiple user profiles sharing same PC |
Yes |
Yes |
Features that are not implemented in the Internet Explorer 4.0 Platform Preview release but are planned for the next Internet Explorer 4.0 release are called out with a (next release). Features that are planned for the final product, but which probably will not make it into the next release, are called out as planned. Features that Netscape has said will be in Communicator, but which are not yet implemented, are marked with an NYI.
The information contained in this document represents the current view of Microsoft Corporation on the issues discussed as of the date of publication. Because Microsoft must respond to changing market conditions, this document should not be interpreted to be a commitment on the part of Microsoft, and Microsoft cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information presented after the date of publication.
This document is for informational purposes only. MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, IN THIS DOCUMENT. Other product and company names herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners. Netscape data is based on information found on Netscape's Web site as of 3/20/97, or inferred from Netscape Communicator Preview Release 2.
©1997 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Microsoft, Windows, and Windows NT are registered trademarks and ActiveX and Outlook are trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. Java is a trademark of Sun Microsystems, Inc. Other product and company names mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.
©1997 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Legal Notices.
Last Updated: Thursday, April 24, 1997
|