home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- REVIEWSCINEMA, Page 75A Twice-Told Fairy Tale
-
-
- By RICHARD SCHICKEL
-
- TITLE: HOME ALONE 2: LOST IN NEW YORK
- DIRECTOR: Chris Columbus
- WRITER: John Hughes
-
- THE BOTTOM LINE: Surprise -- an uncynical sequel that
- actually deserves its assured success.
-
-
- Act I: an extended, flurried family departs for a holiday
- trip, in the process mislaying its youngest member. Act II: at
- first the kid is frightened to find himself all alone in a big
- scary world, but then he begins to enjoy his freedom. Act III:
- threatened by comical bad guys, he begins to long for the loving
- comfort of Mom, Dad and even his hateful older brother.
- Nevertheless, he copes bravely and funnily with adversity. Coda:
- everyone gets back together, Christmas sentiment asserts itself,
- and they all live happily ever after. Or until the next sequel,
- whichever comes first.
-
- Yes, Home Alone 2 precisely follows the formula that made
- its predecessor the biggest grossing comedy in human history.
- But no, it is not a drag, and it is not a rip-off. Look on it
- as a twice-told fairy tale. And look on its tellers, writer
- John Hughes and director Chris Columbus, as craftsmen who have
- taken the responsibilities of success seriously. They have acted
- not as caretakers of valuable property but as trustees of
- something millions regard as a kind of national treasure,
- pop-culture division.
-
- Hughes and Columbus have kept the faith in two ways. By
- maintaining the overall structure of the first Home Alone, they
- create a comfortable sense of anticipation. In a general way you
- know what's coming, and you know it's not going to be yucky. On
- the other hand, the details of the situations are developed
- vividly and originally. And they are presented with an energy
- and a conviction that sequels usually lack.
-
- The subtitle, Lost in New York, tells much, but not
- everything, about their strategy. They don't just leave little
- Kevin (bold, vulnerable Macaulay Culkin) at home this time. They
- contrive to get him on the wrong airplane and land him in a
- place we all know is a lot more daunting than the average
- suburb. Soon his parents are frantic in Florida while he settles
- himself in the Plaza Hotel and starts ordering room service.
- Soon too, Harry and Marv (Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern), the
- goofily overconfident burglars of the earlier film, are
- maneuvered into place. And a couple of ambiguously creepy hotel
- employees (Tim Curry and Dana Ivey) are added to keep Kevin a
- little busier than usual.
-
- But it is Columbus, a director who can make a routine shot
- of a couple of airplanes taking off artful and full of portent,
- who completes our entrancement. He has -- no kidding -- a
- vision of New York City, a nicely dislocating blend of charm and
- grunge. It's not quite real, not entirely fanciful. It is a
- child's-eye view of the place, full of glamorous shimmer and
- eerie shadows, a haunted Disneyland.
-
- It may be that Kevin's final confrontation with the crooks
- -- this time he booby-traps a brownstone that is undergoing
- renovation -- lacks the bestartling hilarity of his previous
- battle with them. It may be that his bonding with a homeless
- pigeon lady (Brenda Fricker) in Central Park is a touch too
- Christmasy. But it is a good-hearted excess. And that's the
- great thing about Home Alone 2. It is going to make a ton of
- money, but you never feel that's the only reason it was made.
- It respects itself and it respects us, and there's no reason to
- begrudge its success.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-