home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- Newsgroups: misc.activism.progressive
- Path: sparky!uunet!zaphod.mps.ohio-state.edu!wupost!mont!pencil.cs.missouri.edu!daemon
- From: harelb@math.cornell.edu (Harel Barzilai)
- Subject: "A Democratic Party That Isn't" (Op-Ed)
- Message-ID: <1992Jul22.041932.11457@mont.cs.missouri.edu>
- Followup-To: alt.activism.d
- Originator: daemon@pencil.cs.missouri.edu
- Sender: news@mont.cs.missouri.edu
- Nntp-Posting-Host: pencil.cs.missouri.edu
- Organization: ?
- Date: Wed, 22 Jul 1992 04:19:32 GMT
- Approved: map@pencil.cs.missouri.edu
- Lines: 155
-
- "What it lacked was any sense of participative democracy. [...]
- DNC Chair Ron Brown told an ABC Nightline audience in December
- that he hoped to eliminate half of the candidate field after the
- first primary in New Hampshire, and to have only one candidate
- left after Super Tuesday, March 10
-
- "But before Ron Brown and the DNC congratulate themselves on their
- success, I suggest that they pause to consider the consequences of
- their actions."
-
- *********************************
- A DEMOCRATIC PARTY THAT ISN'T
- by Stephen C. Smith
- *********************************
-
- The Democratic National Convention, a week-long info-mercial for
- Bill Clinton, was a TV extravaganza rivaled in glitz and glamour only
- by an Academy Awards broadcast. It was Made-For-TV politics.
- Democratic Relief.
-
- What it lacked was any sense of participative democracy. If it
- should lead to Bill Clinton's election this November, it portends the
- probability that future Democratic presidential candidate selections
- will follow the same strategy of exclusion.
-
- This scripted event culminated a carefully managed and narrowly
- focused presidential candidate selection process mapped out last fall
- by the Democratic National Committee. DNC Chair Ron Brown told an ABC
- Nightline audience in December that he hoped to eliminate half of the
- candidate field after the first primary in New Hampshire, and to have
- only one candidate left after Super Tuesday, March 10. This
- strategy's intent was to select one candidate quickly, who the DNC's
- spin doctors would transform into a mythic warrior who would vanquish
- George Bush in November.
-
- This scenario, however, purposely excluded most of the registered
- Democrats in this country from having a meaningful say in choosing
- their party's nominee. Among the many states left with no significant
- voice in the primaries were California, New York, Illinois, Michigan,
- Ohio, Pennsylvania and New Jersey. These represented seven of the
- nine largest Democratic delegate states, and one-third of all
- Democratic delegates. Overall, about two-thirds of the delegates were
- to be selected after Super Tuesday.
-
- The cynical brilliance of Ron Brown's plan was that it would
- create the illusion of "momentum" for his candidate. With most of the
- candidates out of the race, the one leading a winnowed field couldn't
- help picking up a greater percentage of the delegates.
-
- Ron Brown's plan worked almost to perfection. Bill Clinton, who
- once chaired the party's centrist Democratic Leadership Council, was
- the only "insider" candidate enjoying early substantive support within
- the DNC. Sure enough, despite early questions about his integrity and
- fidelity, Clinton outlasted his lesser known and lesser connected
- rivals to emerge as the front-runner after Super Tuesday. If Jerry
- Brown hadn't stubbornly refused to withdraw from the campaign, Ron
- Brown's plan would have been executed flawlessly.
-
- Clinton exploited the weeks before the convention to rehabilitate
- his image. He began with an appearance on Arsenio Hall, where he
- donned sunglasses and played the saxophone. Next was a nationally
- televised town hall meeting, bypassing the media to deliver his
- message directly to the voters. And while George Bush and Ross Perot
- spat at one another, Clinton sensibly stood quietly on the sidelines.
- Bush and Perot sank in the polls; Clinton rose.
-
- Clinton's rehabilitation was completed by the prime-time variety
- show masquerading as a political convention, carried by virtually
- every media outlet. As Ohio announced its delegates' support for
- Clinton --clinching his nomination -- the networks cut to mini-cams
- showing the Clinton family in Macy's, as if they were out shopping
- during all of this. The Clintons exited Macy's into the street, where
- on cue hundreds of supporters waved "CLINTON" signs. The Clintons
- rode in a stretch limo (not unlike the President's) to Madison Square
- Garden, where a camera followed them through the inner corridors
- towards the convention floor. The camera dramatically swung forward
- to show Clinton's perspective, a door swinging open to the floor,
- where thousands of well-rehearsed delegates cheered madly. A
- spotlight -- in fact, a star -- shone where Clinton was to emerge.
-
- An entrance worthy of Bruce Springsteen.
-
- An ABC News Poll showed that Clinton left the convention with an
- 29- point lead in the polls over Bush. Ross Perot dropped out of the
- race, citing his inability to win "now that the Democratic Party has
- revitalized itself." The prime-time spectacle even KO'd the blustery
- billionaire.
-
- But before Ron Brown and the DNC congratulate themselves on their
- success, I suggest that they pause to consider the consequences of
- their actions.
-
- If not for Perot's political ineptitude, a nationwide independent
- campaign could have very well foiled the DNC's plan. Millions of
- voters turned to Perot not out of any admiration or deep conviction in
- his beliefs, but simply because he was another choice. Many of those
- voters were registered Democrats who felt they had been denied a
- substantive choice within their own party.
-
- The DNC also distanced itself from its traditional heritage as
- the bastion of progressive liberal change. Its faulty assumption was
- that the dreaded "L-word" would never sell to a majority of voters.
- Apparently, it never occurred to the DNC that the reason liberal
- candidates have failed in recent campaigns was that they lacked the
- political stature, strategic competence or personal integrity to
- appeal to the electorate, not necessarily a popular message.
-
- To bury the "L-word," the DNC sought to impede progressive
- liberal candidates. Larry Agran lacked the national stature of Jerry
- Brown, so he was quickly dismissed by the media and could not appeal
- over the DNC to the voters. But Brown, ever the political chameleon,
- embraced his newly found outsider status to run against the monied
- interests that control not only the DNC but most of D.C. politics. As
- the other candidates dropped out, Brown almost wrecked the DNC's
- strategy, but lacked both the financial resources and any deep
- personal resonance with the voters to overtake Clinton.
-
- Still, Brown insisted that, as the candidate with the
- second-highest number of delegates, he be allowed to address the
- convention. Once again, Ron Brown tried to silence him. Jerry
- addressed the convention only by forcing the issue -- collecting the
- signatures required under party rules to place his name in nomination.
-
- Should Bill Clinton win in November, I fear that this
- exclusionary process will set the standard for future Democratic
- primaries. A moribund party cannot be resurrected simply by painting
- rouge on the corpse. Candidates have always enjoyed a temporary surge
- in the polls after a convention.
-
- If Clinton sincerely wants to salvage the Democratic Party,
- instead of trying to silence dissenting voices he should have insisted
- that Jerry Brown and Larry Agran address the convention. It would
- have demonstrated to alienated voters that Clinton is indeed a man
- capable of broad support. Instead, he uses against the liberal wing
- of his own party the same politics of division practiced by the GOP in
- 1988.
-
- Right now, the Democratic Party isn't very democratic. Already
- there are signs that the Republicans will exploit this handicap. Fred
- Malek, Bush-Quayle campaign manager, said on NBC's Meet the Press that
- the GOP's convention, unlike the Democrats', will be "a party of
- inclusion."
-
- Bill Clinton says he wants change. The question is, a change to
- what?
-
-
- * * * * *
-
-
- Stephen C. Smith is a political consultant. He served as the
- Issues Director for the Agran for President campaign.
-
- ##################################################################
- From: Agran for President <75300.3112@CompuServe.COM>
-