To be given to the person whose ability merits a far greater push than the
person receives. There may be many such people, but the winner of this award
should have the most ability with least push.
Previous Winners:
1990: Terry Taylor
1991: Cactus Jack
1992: Owen Hart
1993: Chris Benoit
1994: 1-2-3 Kid
1995: Barry Horowitz
1996: Owen Hart
1997: Chris Benoit
**1998**: Chris Benoit
467 first place votes
444 second place votes
424 third place votes
82 42 20 576 Chris Benoit
48 33 33 405 D'Lo Brown
35 28 17 293 Al Snow
33 29 17 286 Chris Jericho
36 19 17 271 Mankind
15 19 15 162 Kidman
21 10 13 161 Brian Christopher
13 12 12 125 Booker T.
12 9 18 123 Disco Inferno
11 10 17 119 Owen Hart
13 8 11 111 Jerry Lynn
13 9 9 110 Chavo Guerrero Jr.
11 10 10 105 Dick Togo
6 11 18 99 Edge
5 15 12 94 Fit Finlay
6 15 9 93 X-Pac
10 6 11 90 Billy Gunn
6 13 9 87 Lenny Lane
5 11 9 76 Kanyon
6 8 10 74 Psychosis
5 10 7 69 La Parka
2 5 11 47 Jeff Jarrett
3 6 6 45 Wrath
3 5 6 42 Norman Smiley
4 3 3 35 Scorpio
5 2 1 33 Kaz Hayashi
2 6 2 32 Taka Michinoku
4 1 4 31 Raven
2 5 2 29 Silver King
2 3 5 29 Justin Credible
4 2 1 28 Bob Holly
2 4 2 26 Bradshaw
2 2 5 26 Brad Armstrong
2 3 3 25 Eddie Guerrero
1 2 6 23 Vader
3 1 1 20 Kane
1 4 1 19 Lance Storm
1 2 4 19 Jesse James
1 3 2 18 Gangrel
1 3 2 18 Chris Daniels
1 2 3 17 Val Venis
2 2 0 16 Alex Wright
1 3 1 16 Perry Saturn
1 2 2 15 Steve Blackman
1 1 3 14 Marc Mero
0 4 1 14 Ultimo Dragon
0 2 4 14 Hunter Hearst Helmsley
2 1 0 13 Juventud Guerrera
2 1 0 13 Godfather
1 2 1 13 Johnny Swinger
1 2 1 13 Goldberg
1 2 0 11 Tomoko Kuzumi
1 2 0 11 Bart Gunn
0 2 2 10 Jerry Flynn
1 1 0 8 Mark Cantebury
1 1 0 8 Ken Shamrock
1 1 0 8 Kaoru
1 1 0 8 Dan Severn
0 2 1 8 Dean Malenko
1 0 1 7 Jet Jaguar
1 0 1 7 Hollywood Hogan
1 0 1 7 Hacksaw Jim Duggan
1 0 1 7 Buff Bagwell
0 1 2 7 Mark Henry
0 2 0 6 Scott Norton
0 0 3 6 Sick Boy
1 0 0 5 Sable
1 0 0 5 Reese
1 0 0 5 Kenta Kobashi
1 0 0 5 Horace the Psychopath
1 0 0 5 Chyna
1 0 0 5 Cat (Ernest Miller)
0 1 1 5 Nova
0 1 1 5 Goldust
0 1 1 5 Chris Chetti
0 0 2 4 Sting
0 0 2 4 Rob Van Dam
0 0 2 4 Mens Teoh
0 1 0 3 Tomoko Watanabe
0 1 0 3 Stephen Regal
0 1 0 3 Scott Steiner
0 1 0 3 Rock
0 1 0 3 Maunekea Mossman
0 1 0 3 Masato Yakushiji
0 1 0 3 Manukea Mossman
0 1 0 3 Kendell Windham
0 1 0 3 Jeff Hardy
0 1 0 3 Golga
0 1 0 3 D-Von Dudley
0 1 0 3 Bill Goldberg
0 1 0 3 Barry Horowitz
0 1 0 3 2 Cold Scorpio
0 0 1 2 Ulf Hermann
0 0 1 2 Tokyo Magnum
0 0 1 2 Tiger Ali Singh
0 0 1 2 Super Nova
0 0 1 2 Spike Dudley
0 0 1 2 Shane Douglas
0 0 1 2 Scotty Zappa
0 0 1 2 Scott Hall
0 0 1 2 Satoshi Kojima
0 0 1 2 Mikey Whipwreck
0 0 1 2 Mike Quakenbush
0 0 1 2 Mike Awesome
0 0 1 2 Miguel Perez Jr.
0 0 1 2 Kurrgan
0 0 1 2 Kenny Kaos
0 0 1 2 Jesus Castillo
0 0 1 2 Hiromi Yagi
0 0 1 2 Giant
0 0 1 2 Darren Drozdov
0 0 1 2 Charly Manson
0 0 1 2 Blue Meanie
0 0 1 2 Blood (PWA)
0 0 1 2 Axl Rotten
0 0 1 2 Arkangel de la Muerte
0 0 1 2 Adam Peace (Mid-Am Wrestling)
REJECTED - not individuals
0 3 1 Hardy Boyz
1 1 0 Too Much
1 0 1 Kaientai
1 0 0 All of Kaientai except Taka Michinoku
0 0 1 Dudley Boys
SHAWN MULLIN: Brian Christopher is a very fine worker and a guy who while
having almost no spotlight still draws good heat in every match that he has.
The WWF seriously has to take advantage of that, and they haven't.
ANDY JUDGE: In Arn Anderson's autobiography, he mentions wrestlers who "move
like Brad Armstrong". I knew what he meant.
SVEN MASCARENHAS: Kidman, not Jericho, is WCW's hottest young property, and
should be signed long-term right now. Wrath may well be the best super-heavy in
the sport, and Fallen Angel is a ***** match waiting to happen.
MARK SIMMS: Where the heck is Marc Mero???
A MAN CALLED ART: Look out for Chavo and Pepe in 99! Unless WCW messes it all
up.
CHRIS DILLON: I don't think many people realise just how good Brian Christopher
is, and how good he could be. Masato Yakushiji is an amazing young wrestler,
and although he hasn't done much over the last 12 months, he still deserves to
be all over the sheets - and isn't. Hopefully NJPW will pick him up and
cultivate his talent. Mike Awesome is also very underrated - for such a big guy
he has amazing agility and given the right opponent can produce a really
watchable match.
VINCE MORALES: Jerry Lynn is a great wrestler with untapped potential. ECW
doesnt even know how to use him!
GEORGE CARTER: Mankind the most underrated wrestler of all-time. Then Lenny
Lane and Brad Armstrong are the others that fill out this ballot. Three
entertaining wrestlers without pushes.
CURTIS DESJARDINS: Just look at the way Vince has used Kaientai. Not once has
he utilized their capabilities. Free the Michinoku Four! And if only All Japan
would OPEN THEIR EYES and give Mossman a little room to shine. Time to move out
of the 70's boys. And poor Yagi is overshadowed in Arsion by Aja, Tiger Dream,
and Yoshida. Hopefully next year will be her year (a rekindling of her JWP feud
with Candy? Hint. Hint.)
JAMES FABIANO: Kaz Hayashi deserves better than jobbing to Ernest Friggin'
Miller and Sonny F*cking Onoo. Disco not only has a great gimmick and a funny
finisher, but he is also a decent worker (well, as long as he stays away from
much smaller luchadors and Public Enemy :-)). And X-Pac, after coming back
from injury and WCW and getting his work back up to par, deserves more credit.
STEPHEN TISZENKEL: I know Brian Christopher is never going to get a push, but
so what? He's really good! He's a throwback to '80s heels, too -- find someone
else you can say that about amid all the WWF Attitude. He deserves an IC run,
at least.
B. SZPAKOWICZ: Again, far too many possibilities. Benoit, Jericho and Kidman
are my votes, and they're pretty much self-explanatory too. These guys should
be on their way to main-eventing, not languishing in the low card. At least
Jericho seems to be getting a heavy push... Until I see him get a *good*
showing in against Goldberg though, he stays on the list. Oh, and a World's
Title would be cool too, though it's probably too much to ask for.
OTTO "HACK-MAN" HEUER: There were just to many people to vote for Most
Underrated Wrestler and too few slots. I wanted to recognize such
under-pushed workers as Psychosis, LaParka, Chavo, Jericho, Disco, Edge, Fit,
Jerry Flynn, Jerry Lynn, Kidman, Sean Waltman, Prime Time (PWA), Darrin Davis
(PWA), Mikey Whipwreck, Spike Dudley, and all the WCW luchas in general, but
the three that stood out above and beyond the rest were Chris Benoit, Lenny
Lane, and Blood (PWA).
TOMMY-O: Kidman only gets knocked to 2 because he got a title. "Jerry's
kid" is a fine wrestler and deserves a push.
MIKE CHAPMAN: At least Taka did get a title.
JEFF BELL: If used properly, Chavo can join, or even pass his uncle Eddy in
terms of all around talent
JON WHITE: I voted for great wrestlers like Benoit, Dragon, and Owen Hart
because we don't understand how great these guys really are.
TOM ROBSON: Chavo rarely gets mentioned among the top cruiserweights in WCW,
but he really is outstanding. His series of matches with his uncle Eddy this
summer were classics, and he developed into one of the most interesting
characters in WCW this summer. Of course they quickly buried him, but still he
was fun to watch and never gets enough credit. D-Von has some good skills that
don't often get recognized because of the kinds of matches that he is in.
Lynn truly is "Dynamic" but is almost always forgotten by fans.
SUPERFAN SAM: Is anyone more misused than Chris Benoit? One would think Terry
Taylor would have some sympathy for a great worker who isn't pushed.
BRAVO SIERRA: Kaos (and his partner) are not that bad. A better gimmick would
serve him well in the eyes of the public.
RYAN GRANT: I might just be marking for the gimick, but I think the Inferno is
woefully unappreciated by the "smart" fans. Johnny Swinger is overlooked by
everyone, but he's pretty darned good IMO. A lot of the fans appreciate Jerry
Lynn for what he is--sadly, the companies don't seem to.
K. CANZANELLA: Jerry Lynn is so underrated by peECW. The crowd chants his name,
pops like mad when he goes to the ring, and yet he still is in stupid fueds
over Tammy Lynn Sytch/Bytch. He should be the ECW TV champ. He's going to be
great if he can ever get out of there. DIck Togo and Kaz Hayashi, both former
K*DXers, put over people that shouldn't be in the ring, just because American
Wrestling promoters suck. At least Kaz has a future in his fed. Hey Dick Togo-
Time to sell Dwayne Gill's lariat!
JEREMY SORIA: I *have* to pick exactly three?
MICHAEL NAIMARK: In terms of booking, no wrestler has a wider gap between
in-ring skill and promotional push than Chris Benoit. Benoit is so good in the
ring that he will continue to be underrated until he is given main-event
status, something that no other wrestler in North America can claim.
SHANE ANDERSON: Lynn maybe the most underrated wrestler EVER; Lane is about a
1/2 step from breaking out; Pearce is the best indy worker in the Midwest
SEAN SHANNON: Even after the WWF finally got Al Snow off on the right foot, they still haven't reached anywhere near his full potential. The reaction to Snow as Lance Storm's mystery tag team partner at Living Dangerously showed that Snow could be the next main eventer in the industry. I still think the WWF could do that with Snow, if they'd just get him decent opponents, lay out the bucks for "Breathe" and buy about a million styrofoam heads. Second and third, respectively, are Owen Hart and Chris Benoit, everyone's perennial favourites in this category. The WWF seemed to be on the right track with Owen up until WrestleMania, but then he died due to lack of a solid push. Benoit ... well, hopefully he'll jump to the WWF this next year and the WWF will make sure he'll never be mentioned in this category again.
JASON LANGIN: PSICOSIS!!!!! - Come on he's the man!!
MDB: Until Benoit is wrestling for the world title, he'll be undervalued.
Finlay deserved a real reign as TV champ and should still be a title contender.
LaParka should get wins *some* of the time.
RICK SCAIA: The Big Two have been doing a better (though far from perfect) job
of showcasing their talented workers. I really think the most under-utilized
guy in the business is now Jerry Lynn (in ECW). The guy is amazing, and could
single-handedly DOUBLE the credibility of either of the Big Two's lightweight
divisions. In at #2 is Al Snow, who really does deserve better than the
kitsch-y JOB Squad. And for shits and giggles, I'm giving the #3 slot to the
Dudley Boys, who have in the past year developed into a team that deserves MUCH
more respect for their ringwork than they get. Probably because they are
cheap-heat-getting asshole heels.
TOM CRUZ: Will someone please find a way for Steve Blackman to get over? The
guy has real skills and he's quick as all hell (he showed it in the Brawl for
All). Maybe all he needs is a good finisher, since that front kick of his is
kinda weak. Chavo Jr. has tons of skills, as well as a killer finisher in the
Tornado DDT. D'Lo got two Euro title reigns, but I think he should get more
airtime. He's a great interview, a good mat wrestler, and an aerial fiend. Give
him airtime!
DEAN RASMUSSEN: KAORU once again was the quiet heart and soul of GAEA as she
had the cool as hell feud with Yamada to the great forced tagteam with Yamada
to the ruined-by-Sasaki's Sweetlovin'-feud with Hokuto/Ozaki, to the great
matches with Satomura and Kato. KAORU rules. Fit Finlay carried some of the
shittiest wrestlers ALIVE to watchable matches, had GREAT matches with good
workers and people STILL don't realize how great he is. Go figure. Arkangel
de la Muerte is the best luchadore that NOBODY ever mentions when talking about
great luchadores. What's he got to do?
37a. Battle Station BABY! Big Japan, IWA Restart and the best indie in the
world BATTL-mutha frickin-ARTS! Battle Station picks up the ball where Champ
Forum left it! WOO-HOO! Now THAT'S Must See TV! WCW Monday Nitro produced
HUGE quantities of good to really, really good wrestling between the
wheelbarrows of total shit and I filled up many a tape with highly watchable
actual wrestling at levels and amounts that I couldn't dream of seeing four
years ago. Michinoku Pro Lucha is as schizophrenic as Nitro because MP was so
listless this year, but it ALWAYS delivered the good in the second hour with
the CMLL in Japan and the Super SWANKY Toryu-Mon stuff.
I. C. MICHAEL: 1st:X-Pac - Like many a great worker before him (Liger, Owen
Hart, etc.) Waltman has successfully adapted his style to cope with injury. As
a bonus he also sells like a champ. 2nd:Disco Inferno - One of WCW's most
consistently entertaining midcarders, DI is unfortunately stuck in the mid-mid
card 4 life. 3rd:Chavo Guerrero Jr. - Don't let all that crap with Pepe fool
you, Chavo is a solid worker and deserves a C or TV title run.
GARETH THOMAS: Not quite sure why Vince hasn't pushed Brian Christopher? Very
strange, he seems to have all the qualities one would need in the WWF. Manukea
Mossman is an AJ'er that doesn't get a lot of credit despite being very good in
most departments, and was pushed aside as Misawa's partner to make way for
Ogawa this year. Satoshi Kojima is one of the best heavyweight workers in New
Japan, I'm hoping he gets a big push next year, ahead of Sasaki, Tenzan etc.
HEATM: I'm not sure what this category means. If it means most underrated by a
fed, Chris Benoit wins by a landslide. I'll take it to mean the wrestler who
goes unnoticed by anyone despite being able to wrestle well. No one thinks
Disco Inferno is cool, but I like him a lot. He sells moves well, he's crisp
on the execution, and he works the crowd just as well as anyone else. Also,
Mark Cantebury (Henry Godwinn) is actually a pretty good brawler. Kanyon is a
terrific wrestler just now getting the credit he deserves.