home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- REVIEWS, Page 72MUSICFascinating Friction
-
-
- By JAY COCKS
-
- PERFORMER: 10,000 MANIACS
- ALBUM: Our Time in Eden
- LABEL: Electra
-
- THE BOTTOM LINE: Sandblasted lyricism and a new rhythmic
- restlessness carry this band to its best album yet.
-
-
- Careful: you are about to be disoriented. Consider, first,
- the music of 10,000 Maniacs, which is spectral and delicate
- without a moment of fragility. Then think about the lyrics,
- which insinuate themselves into the subconscious like a waking
- dream. And finally, ponder lead singer, key writer and prime
- mover Natalie Merchant, whose earthbound strength sets up a
- fascinating friction with the impregnable magic of the music.
- She's a private writer in a public forum, taking flight into her
- own memories and fancies. She's -- here's the tough part -- like
- Willa Cather at a microphone, summoning memories of the open
- plains and the parched spirit.
-
- You can hear the prairie spaces and the melancholy of
- divided lives that were Cather's true territory in Maniacs songs
- like Stockton Gala Days and Gold Rush Brides. "Who were the
- homestead wives?" the latter asks. "The land was free, yet it
- cost their lives . . . In letters mailed back home her Eastern
- sisters they would moan as they would read accounts of madness,
- childbirth, loneliness and grief." The words are printed like
- this in the album notes, as if they were bits of homespun prose
- from some cosmic farmer's almanac; but Merchant sings them with
- dreamy, insistent fervor, like a reverie from O Pioneers! Or
- maybe Wisconsin Death Trip.
-
- Producer Paul Fox has given the band a more solid rhythmic
- foundation for this outing. Previously, Merchant and the other
- Maniacs could be so evanescent that they threatened to disappear
- in their own vapor trail. Here they sound sturdier, even when
- a string quartet floats through Merchant's wrenching Jezebel.
-
- For all the smooth fury of Our Time in Eden, the spirit of
- the group -- its distinctive combination of stylistic
- orneriness and sandblasted lyricism -- remains undiminished.
- 10,000 Maniacs has always been hard to classify. That's an
- integral part of the band's charm, and so is the obvious pride
- with which its members nourish their idiosyncrasy. Still, they
- have enjoyed a heartening commercial success, which should
- increase nicely with Our Time in Eden. It sounds like their best
- album yet. But for a group that exists so safely away from
- trends, it's the afterlife of the music that counts; not the
- initial impact but the resonance. By that measure, 10,000
- Maniacs still has a lot of distance to cover, and lots of time.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-