home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT1708>
- <title>
- Aug. 05, 1991: Hard Times for the Hard-Liners
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- Aug. 05, 1991 Was It Worth It?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- WORLD, Page 41
- SOVIET UNION
- Hard Times for the Hard-Liners
- </hdr><body>
- <p>For Alexei Sergeyev and other devout communists, Gorbachev's
- reforms spell the end of the party
- </p>
- <p>By John Kohan/Moscow
- </p>
- <p> While Mikhail Gorbachev blasted "communist fundamentalists"
- from his Kremlin pulpit last week, one of his main targets,
- Alexei Sergeyev, sat silently in the audience of Central
- Committee members, nursing a few grievances of his own. As the
- founder of the hard-line Communist Initiative movement, Sergeyev
- concluded that what Gorbachev said about "breaking out of the
- circle of dogmatic concepts" confirmed his worst suspicions. "In
- the past, Gorbachev has always disguised his true views," said
- Sergeyev. "This time, he was almost honest. His speech left me
- in no doubt that he is not a communist. If you were to change a
- few words in his program, Margaret Thatcher or George Bush could
- endorse it."
- </p>
- <p> What particularly incensed Sergeyev and other supporters
- of traditional Marxist-Leninist doctrine was a draft charter
- that Gorbachev presented to the plenum of the party leadership--the first complete restatement of basic principles in 30
- years. In Sergeyev's view, Gorbachev's document was too "social
- democratic," a derogatory term among hard-liners. What he meant
- was that Gorbachev wanted to abandon basic communist principles.
- Instead, he has advocated a democratic, parliamentary-style
- party and a mixed economy. "If the Gorbachev line should
- triumph," warned Sergeyev, "there will no longer be a Communist
- Party--not even in name."
- </p>
- <p> The plenum was not marked this time by bitter personal
- attacks against Gorbachev. His opponents, said Sergeyev, a
- professor of political economics at Moscow's Academy of Labor
- and Social Relations, were trying to stage "a revolt on their
- knees." There were angry outcries in the hall during the closed
- sessions, he said, but when the time came to vote, Gorbachev
- always won. The General Secretary had trumped his critics by
- embracing their call for a special congress before the end of
- the year, thus deflecting their attempts to force an immediate
- schism in the party or a change of leadership.
- </p>
- <p> There was a time when Gorbachev would not have dared to
- move so brazenly against the hard-liners. Now he evidently
- believes that time is running out for them. Party hard-liners
- have been defeated in almost every major election that has been
- held during the past two years. While communist rule goes
- unchallenged in the conservative Central Asian republics, the
- party is virtually a marginal opposition group in Georgia,
- Armenia and the Baltic republics. Rank-and-file members across
- the country are deserting the fold in droves. Some 4 million
- have left the party during the past 18 months, reducing total
- membership to 15 million.
- </p>
- <p> Sergeyev fears that if Gorbachev's policies do not finish
- off the communists, the party's most prominent dropout, Boris
- Yeltsin, will. In one of his first acts as president of the
- Russian Federation, Yeltsin banished all party organizations
- from the workplace and from state institutions. His decree was
- aimed like an ax at the very roots of communist power: the dense
- tangle of party cells in factories and businesses that have
- functioned alongside state agencies as a shadow system of
- administration. This party bureaucracy has been a major brake
- on radical economic reforms.
- </p>
- <p> The Central Committee passed a resolution last week
- condemning the Yeltsin decree. Gorbachev also claimed that he
- would oppose any moves against local party cells by "all
- constitutional means." But hard-liners like Sergeyev suspect the
- President will betray them. They contend that Gorbachev wants
- the issue to be decided by the Committee for Constitutional
- Compliance, which rules on the constitutionality of laws, rather
- than veto the decree himself and risk alienating Yeltsin. No
- matter what the Kremlin does, the Russians are bound to go ahead
- with plans to kick party functionaries out of factories.
- </p>
- <p> The struggle between hard-liners and radicals has
- splintered the party into rival factions. They range from the
- Bolshevik Platform of neo-Stalinist gadfly Nina Andreyeva to the
- radical Communists for Democracy group led by Russian vice
- president Alexander Rutskoi. Sergeyev contends that his
- Communist Initiative movement alone counts at least 3.5 million
- sympathizers. Other alternatives are emerging on the fringes of
- the party. With the tacit approval of Gorbachev, former Foreign
- Minister Eduard Shevardnadze set up a Democratic Reform Movement
- earlier this month to further perestroika. Last week Alexander
- Yakovlev, a key architect of Gorbachev's changes, quit the
- government, presumably to devote his energies to the fledgling
- movement. Meanwhile, 12 prominent hard-liners called for the
- creation of a "popular patriotic movement" of their own for "the
- salvation of the motherland."
- </p>
- <p> The question is not whether there will be a party schism
- but when. More is at stake than just ideology. Property worth
- billions of rubles, ranging from printing plants and party
- office buildings to Black Sea health spas and a luxury Moscow
- hotel, is held by the Communist Party. No one wants to be the
- first to leave the party and risk losing claim to a lucrative
- chunk of the property settlement when the divorce is completed.
- </p>
- <p> Faced with the latest plenum setback, Sergeyev vowed to
- oppose what Gorbachev is doing to the party "by every possible
- means--within the law." He admitted that there would be "tough
- times" ahead for hard-liners. Gorbachev declared last week that
- the party would only be "strengthened" if those who opposed his
- new program resigned, but Sergeyev has his own ideas. "The
- social democrats and liberals--and that includes Gorbachev--should get out," says Sergeyev. "Let them create their own new
- party. True communists have no reason to leave."
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-