> A B-3, is well....a... B-3 ! I really don't see much of a difference > in the "sound" dept.
John Medeski sounds completely different tone wise than any other B-3
player I've ever heard. He tweeks with the sounds so much more than any
one else, and his style is so definitive.
> Could you actually pass a blindfold test of organ riffs
> alternating between Medeski and Horvitz ?
Absolutely.
> Primitive and lame ? What does
> lame mean in this context ?
I mean it's more funny sounding than cool sounding.
> BTW, the Zony Mash cd (IMO) is far more
> interesting than the latest MM&W effort. Seems like MM&W have reached > a pinnacle of creativity and need to diversify. I'd say they've > stagnated !
I agree that 'Shack-Man' isn't as good as the rest of 'em but it jams
harder than Zony Mash especially live. those songs off the new album I
think are decent on the CD but live they are awesome! I don't know
about them having stagnated, I think this is where they want to go and I
think you'll find the next CD to be very different from 'Shack-Man'.
> Has John Medeski (whom i
> like very much btw..) set the new standard by which to compare?
I think definitely he has. His unique approach to keyboards and effects
backed up by unbelievable chops makes him a completely new and one of if
not the most important keyboardists around. He plays the B-3 like no
one else ever has and does and his explorations into other keyboards
make you say "wait are there TWO guitars in this band?" Not to mention
his u\amazing piano playing. listen to 'Notes From The Underground' or
the Andre Jaume/John Medeski duets album 'Team Games' or Dougie Bowne's
'One Way Elevator' to get a flavor of this.
For that
> matter what do you think of Jimmy Smith or John Patton ? to name but a few
> ...
I think they're great especially Richard "Groove" Holmes. He busts it up
soulwise but on the creatively groundbreaking side, they're lacking, but
I don't think they were ever trying to do this. They were playing what
they loved, felt and moved them and their audience.
I don't think Zony Mash is a bad album by any respects. I just don't
particularly like Horvitz's Hammond playing that much. I think the
album is fun and sometimes funny and it will remain in my CD collection
and be played sort of often. I don't think that it's spectacular.