home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
Text File | 2003-06-11 | 58.1 KB | 1,148 lines |
-
- Volume 1, Number 2 -- private line -- a journal of inquiry into
- the telephone system
-
- Table of Contents
-
- General Information
-
- I. Editorial Page
- II. Update and Corrections
- III. Telco Payphone Basics, Part II
- IV. The Coin First Coin Line
- V. The Dial Tone First Coin Line
- VI. Tip, Ground and Ring Explained
- VII. California Cell Fraud Law
-
- ----------------------------------------------------
-
- 1. General Info on private line: ISSN No. 1077-3487
-
- A. private line is published six times a year by Tom Farley.
- Copyright (c) 1994 It runs 24 to 28 pages. It's done in black and white.
-
- B. Subscriptions: $24 a year for subscriber's in the U.S. $31 to
- Canada or Mexico. $44 overseas. Mailed first class or equivalent.
- (1) Make checks or money orders payable in US funds to private
- line.
- (2) Back issues are five dollars apiece.
- (3) A sample is four dollars.
- (4) The mailing list is not available to anyone but me.
-
- C. Mailing address: 5150 Fair Oaks Blvd. #101-348, Carmichael, CA
- 95608
-
- D. e-mail address: privateline@delphi.com
-
- E. Phone numbers: (916) 488-4231 Voice (916) 978-0810 FAX
-
- F. Submissions: Go for it! Anything semi-technical is strongly
- encouraged. I don't run any personality pieces. I pay with
- subscriptions.
-
- G. Ads: Yes, I'm taking electronic related ads. A full page is
- $75.00, a half page $37.50 and a quarter $18.75. Subscribers get
- free classified ads of 25 words or less.
-
- ------------------------------------------------------------------
-
- The front cover illustration is of an line finder rack for a step
- by step exchange. The photo is from a 1943 Popular Mechanics
- Yearbook. The caption reads, "In an automatic telephone
- exchange many sets of selectors are required, and when a call is
- made a vacant line must be found automatically. This apparatus
- finds one within a few seconds."
-
- ----------------------------------------------------
-
- I. EDITORIAL PAGE
-
- Sing Ho For The Life of A Zine; On Explaining the Unexplainable;
- Vegas Bound
-
- Welcome to the second issue of private line. I hope you enjoy it.
- The first issue was well received and I am encouraged. I am now
- sending samples to magazine wholesalers. I may find a nation wide
- distributor by the October issue. That would lead to more
- readers, more comments and more information. Until private line is
- more reader driven, however, you are stuck with me. And that means
- fundamentals. I finish the discussion of Telco pay phone
- basics in this issue. The mystery of ground start is examined as
- well as the different arrangements of tip, ground and ring.
-
- These explanations are my best attempt to make sense out of
- seemingly nonsensical ideas. They are starting points for a
- conversation to begin. They are not The Last Word. I worry
- terribly, however, about my writing. It seems that I have two poor
- choices. I can provide a precise answer that is too complicated to
- understand or a simple one that is too general to be accurate.
- So, something in the middle is presented instead. People have
- been very forgiving. They appreciate the effort that it takes to
- get a discussion going. I appreciate that consideration.
-
- A local scanning article will be featured in the next issue of
- private line. People always want interesting numbers to call. The
- problem is that such numbers are often of regional interest only.
- I will, therefore, describe some ways that everyone can use to
- search for test numbers, voice mail boxes, governmental telephone
- system numbers and so on. This article will be done with the help
- of an Oakland hacker. It will use numbers from the 415, 510, 707
- and 916 area codes as examples. People in the Bay Area will be
- able to use the numbers given, but people everywhere will be able
- to use the techniques. It will even have some worksheets to help
- you systematically explore a prefix and an area code.
-
- For now, though, it's off to Def Con II in Las Vegas. A
- gathering of the clan is taking place in the burning hot desert.
- It might be a hacker's Woodstock or a recreation of the last
- scene in The Stand. I don't know. But I'm going. I can't afford
- the trip. But I'm going. My car may not make it. But I'm going.
- Next month and next month's finances will have to take care of
- themselves. For all the right and wrong reasons, people are now
- going to Las Vegas. And so am I. I'll tell you what happens.
-
- Thank you,
-
- Tom Farley
- Carmichael, California
-
-
- II. UPDATES AND CORRECTIONS
-
- This update column will be a regular part of private line.
- Material comes from the last year of Telephony.
-
- The local switch
-
- 1. I didn't write much about central office switches in the last
- issue. I thought others had done a better, more complete job so I
- spent time writing about CDO's and remotes. There are, however,
- some new CO switches coming on line.
-
- An article in early 1994 stated that NEC was one of only two
- vendors with a large, ATM based central office switch that is
- ready to be installed. Fujitsu is apparently the other vendor.
- They did not state, however, the names of the switches. NYNEX was
- reported in a later article to be installing Fujitsu's Fetex-150
- broadband switch for a field trial. Broadband does means ATM. Bell
- South is also playing with the Fetex-150. They are going
- into North Carolina and soon to Atlanta. But Telephony doesn't
- state whether the 150 is the switch that was referred to earlier.
- If NEC or Fujitsu does deliver a CO then they may offer some sort
- of coin line service.
-
- As I understand it, ATM or asynchronous transmission is a way to
- handle many kinds of information fairly quickly. Video services,
- in particular, benefit from ATM. The No. 5ESS, by comparison, is
- a time division switch. It handles most data files and voice
- traffic in a faster way than ATM. But it can't handle multi-media
- or video as well. Read more about ATM in the June IEEE Spectrum.
-
- Latest upgrade to the No. 5 , by the way, is apparently the
- 5E9(1), which went to customers in November, 1993. This now
- provides the so-called National ISDN-2 capabilities. NYNEX
- is now able to offer services such as residential voice dialing
- service and its phonesmart caller ID and call trace. Lovely.
-
- As of April 11, 1994, 72% of NYNEX lines were served by digital
- switches. Half of the remaining lines will eventually be served by
- 5ESS's or NT S/DMS SuperNode switches. The company expects its
- network to be 100% digital by 1998. 18% of its lines, therefore,
- are still served by electronic or analog switches. That's fairly
- large considering that NYNEX, the Darth Vader of the baby bells,
- is so well financed. You can tell by this that smaller markets
- will have a far higher percentage of older equipment.
-
- 2. The Remote Switching System
-
- Current practice calls a digital remote switch a module. These
- correspond to the CO switch. For example, when you buy a central
- office switch you get a module to go along with it if you need a
- remote. An example would be the No. 5A Remote Switching Module to
- go along with the No. 5ESS. Remote switching modules are also
- known as RSMs. Siemens Stromberg Carlson also makes a module for
- its central office EWSD switch. This switch and its attendant
- remotes have been installed recently in Puerto Rico. An
- independent Telco named Alltel has also bought an EWSD switch and
- one remote unit to serve rural Eclectic, Alabama. It might be
- interesting to call Eclectic sometime to hear the new switch in
- town, possibly the only one of its kind in America.
-
- I referred to Northern Telecom's DMS-10 as a remote switch and a
- collection of components. Not exactly. The Digital Matrix Switch-
- 10 is primarily a switch for rural use. Any components that go
- with it can be thought of as accessories and not a part of the
- switch itself. I mentioned several times that a low volume of
- calls makes rural service expensive, along with the higher costs
- of building and maintaining the local loop. This low volume
- works against upgrading since revenue is low. A way around the
- problem is by offering a switch like the DMS-10. It may generate
- greater revenue in rural areas by providing services that step by
- step offices can not. Things such as call forwarding and call
- waiting. Still, are there that many people that need call waiting
- in Gabbs, Nevada?
-
- The term Community Dial Office is falling out of favor. CDO's
- refer to older equipment rather than an operating method. Remotes
- and modules, though, are still dependent on a larger switch. Even
- basic terms are being redefined. Pac Bell doesn't refer to central
- offices anymore. They are, instead, a dial tone producing end
- office.
-
- 3. The subscriber loop network
-
- How expensive rural service can be is demonstrated by a US West
- (the old Mountain Bell) field trial. 35 miles from Jackson,
- Wyoming are 40 customers who live near the town of Bondurant. They
- are now being supplied phone service by satellite. Subscriber
- lines terminate at two small satellite earth stations which then
- connects the customer to US West's switching center in Jackson.
- U.S. West wants to see if this is less expensive than installing
- fiber or cable out to these homes, many of which have party line
- service or no service at all. Now, that's expensive.
-
- 4. Coin deposit tones
-
- I doubted last issue that operators listened to tones anymore. I
- speculated that the CO probably listens for the tones instead and
- sends the amount on a data circuit to the TSPS console. Such
- nonsense. An attendee of the last San Francisco 2600 meeting
- gently pointed out the obvious fact that a voice channel exists
- when you are talking with the operator. Of course. Yes, the amount
- of money does totalize on the console but you are talking with the
- operator at the same time. If they hear a bogus tone then they'll
- do something about it. I don't know what I was thinking of when I
- wrote that.
-
- 5. The GTE RTSS phone
-
- This phone interfaced with many other pieces of equipment.
- Somewhere in Kansas wrote in the Summer issue of 2600 that KG and
- KY prefixed machines were discussed in a Scientific American
- article with photos a few years ago. I looked in Carl, Uncover,
- Inspec and Current Contents for it. Nothing. I then looked on the
- shelves. The last index S.A. published was in 1978. Nothing. The
- article probably lies, therefore, between 1979 and about 1988.
- I'll keep looking. AT&T Technology, however, does have an article
- on STU III. This article came out in 1989 in volume four. The page
- numbers are 36 to 40. STU III is apparently a crypto product that
- AT&T makes which can interface with the GTE RTSS. The magazine
- was missing when I went to check it out. And so it goes.
-
- 6. Interesting numbers
-
- The ANAC for parts of 415 has been submitted as 760-7760 and 760-
- 7761. This agrees with the old ANAC list floating about the
- Internet. 924--0036 may be a loop disconnect number for 415. In
- 916, 440-1212 gets you a second dial tone. If you dial additional
- numbers you may get a long distance operator who doesn't identify
- her company when she comes on the line. 484-0001 is a strange one.
- No connection is made. I don't think this is a quiet termination
- test number. I usually hear a connection and then silence with
- those. This one never makes a connection. Some Pac Bell numbers to
- modem into in the 916 are 481-0022 and 484-0022. Possibly 481-
- 0078. The third issue of private line will be about local
- scanning. There will be many, many more numbers.
-
-
- III. TELCO PAYPHONE BASICS, PART 2
-
- The Subscriber Loop Network
-
- 7. We looked at the subscriber loop network briefly in the June
- issue. As you may recall, the network is made up of all those
- elements which constitute the local loop. This includes
- the twisted pairs that run to each phone, the local switch,
- overhead cable, amplifiers, multiplexers and so on. In other
- words, all the elements of switching and transmission. Let's look
- at what I think is the most confusing part of the subscriber loop.
-
- Circuits and the subscriber loop
-
- 8. We know that a circuit is a connection with the central
- office. It carries a call. A circuit exists through the twisted
- pair or in a channel within a wire to the central office. A
- circuit can also be a connection between offices, between
- equipment or within the equipment itself. These circuits may or
- may not carry a conversation. The word circuit is also used to
- describe a particular way that the local loop is arranged. I know
- this sounds confusing. Let's look at three examples of circuits in
- the subscriber loop.
-
- The ringdown circuit
-
- 9. For this example we must turn away from pay phones momentarily
- to consider a semi-public phone. Some supermarkets in Sacramento
- have taxi phones installed near their front entrances. Lifting the
- handset rings the dispatcher at Yellow Cab a few miles away. It
- keeps ringing until it is answered. This is a ringdown circuit. It
- is possible that Yellow Cab ran its own wire years ago from each
- market to their headquarters. But not likely. They would then
- need to power the line, rent space on utility poles for the wires
- and maintain the system. That doesn't make sense. What does
- makes sense is having the Telco engineer a solution. This means a
- relay or circuit board at the central office for the supermarket.
- The twisted pairs providing cab service are routed by the relay to the
- headquarters' number. The Telco can probably program a switch to do
- the same thing today without any hardware.
-
- 10. I've heard that some remote places use ringdown circuits. Like
- isolated ranches. Perhaps. That means, however, that an operator
- would be signaled whenever someone wanted to make a call. Party line
- service would be more likely. Party line service is not the same as
- ringdown. There is no dial with ringdown. An emergency phone on the
- street might use a ringdown circuit. It may even use a dedicated line that
- goes directly to a dispatcher. An elevator phone is another example. It
- also rings until it is answered.
-
- The field exchange circuit
-
- 11. The field exchange circuit or foreign exchange circuit is
- often used by businesses. It provides a local phone number for distant
- customers. Let's say I'm a landscape contractor in Davis, California.
- Half my work comes from Sacramento which is twenty five miles
- away. My Davis number has a 752 prefix. My Sacramento number,
- though, starts with a 371. That's an exchange in West Sacramento
- which is the closest office to the Davis CO. The 371 a free call for most
- Sacramento residents. A local call for long distance. I doubt that Telcos
- use these for pay phones. (1)
-
- Dial long line circuits
-
- 12. A dial long line circuit or DLL is often used by pay phones.
- It enables a coin phone to be placed further from the central office than it
- might otherwise be. Most phones are located within three miles or so of
- the CO or its connecting point. That's about the distance that pay
- phoneproduced signals start to fade. Picking them up beyond that point
- is difficult for the central office. It's a matter of resistance. The
- resistance of the twisted pair increases with length. At about 2.8 miles
- the telephone circuit builds to around 1300 ohms. That's acceptable.
- This figure includes the resistance of the phone, the central office
- equipment and the twisted pair itself. A coin phone at the six or seven
- mile mark might have to signal through as much as 3500 ohms of
- resistance. Amperage falls from about 23 miliamperes to 14
- milliampsor less. All signals from the payphone become weak. A
- dial long line for coin service has special equipment which steps up or
- amplifies these weak signals. It then sends them to the switching
- equipment at the central office. This is called repeated signaling. (2)
- This central office solution may be a cheaper than installing heavier
- gauge cable or multiplexing equipment to reach distant customers.
-
- Signaling
-
- 13. The telephone system uses many kinds of signals. Direct
- current signals, acoustical tones and digital signals are all employed. All
- three kinds may be used to complete or conduct a call. This variety
- makes signaling hard to understand. The central office controls Telco
- pay phones with DC signals. Acoustical tones address a call, signal
- the coins deposited and perform a number of network functions. Digital
- signals are indispensable for long distance working. Let's look at DC
- signals first.
-
- DC signaling in the local loop
-
- 14. The simplest form of DC signaling is performed when you take the
- handset off the switch hook. It's called the off hook signal or the off
- hook condition or more often just off hook. Lifting the handset causes
- the switch hook buttons to rise. These cause contacts in the phone to
- close the circuit with the telephone line. They are normally open. This
- simple act is a signal. It is electrically based. It tells the CO that a phone
- has gone off hook and that a dial tone should be returned. Another
- example is the operator attached signal. It disables a pay phone's key
- pad by changing the polarity of the coin line from a negative charge to a
- positive one.
-
- 15. A rotary dial also produces DC signals. Some refer to this
- process as loop disconnect signaling. A rotary dial disconnects and
- reconnects the current in the telephone line as it speeds in a circle. Five
- interruptions means the number five. But why use DC signals to begin
- with? Why not control a pay phone with tones? Why not digital signals?
- DC signals are used for many reasons:
-
- (a) They're simple. Manipulating a coin line's electrical
- status seems complicated. But it's easy to do. DC signaling depends on
- relays to do the work. These are simple, bulletproof mechanisms that
- work reliably for years;
-
- (b) They're quick. Electricity travels near the speed of
- light in a circuit without resistance. It's not that fast in the local loop.
- But it's quick enough. An electrical signal at 60% of that speed is
- traveling at over 100,000 miles per second. Most pay phones lie within
- three miles or so of a central office or its connecting point. DC signals,
- therefore, act almost instantaneously;
-
- (c) They're cheap. DC signals don't require expensive
- equipment. Tone signaling requires finely tuned oscillators to send tones
- and complex circuits to decode them;
-
- (d) They're resistant to fraud. This is a side benefit of DC
- signaling. It's more difficult to manipulate wires and to generate
- different voltages than it is to produce tones. Never-the-less, such
- manipulation is possible. The direct current initial rate signal is
- simulated by punching a pay phone. Black boxing was an early activity
- in which physical control of the line was. (3)Direct current signals are
- treated further later on in this issue.
-
- Tones in general
-
- 16. DC signals are used unless there is a good reason not to. Or if it is
- impractical. Keypads are an example of the former reason. The simple
- and sturdy method of rotary dialing was replaced by the complicated
- and expensive method of using touch tones. (4) Touch tones are
- produced and processed faster than rotary dial pulses. Switching
- equipment is tied up for less time. Milliseconds are vital to the telephone
- system because of the hundreds of millions of calls a day. They travel
- more efficiently over microwave links and they make end to end
- signaling easier. (5) So, touch tones are replacing DC signaling for
- addressing a call.
-
- 17. Tones are also used where DC signals are impractical. DC signals
- are not very loud by themselves. They might exist as a click for a
- second or perhaps a soft hum. None would make, for example, a good
- dial tone. A pleasant, clearly audible signal is needed. The dial tone, the
- busy signal and ringback (the central office produced sound that
- represents a ringing phone) are examples of network call progress
- tones. These are the common everyday tones that signify the current
- status of the call. Feedback, in other words, for the calling party.
-
- 18. Similarly, an audible coin deposit tone is needed to represent a coin
- when a call is in progress. A DC signal might interfere with the call
- itself since it affects the electrical status of the line. A digital signal
- requires a modem inside the phone. Telcos don't favor that approach. A
- deposit tone or a redbox tone is still a good approach even though it
- interrupts conversation. Let's look briefly at some other signals.
-
- Multi-frequency or MF tones
-
- 19. I covered coin deposit tones in detail last issue. There are also some
- specifics about them later in this issue. ACTS and operators control
- other parts of coin operation through MF tones. Older offices that don't
- receive digital signals for coin control use these. Again, the central
- office controls the payphone with DC signals. The central office is
- controlled in turn by ACTS or an operator. They use acoustical tones or
- digital signals to do this.
-
- 20. Tones by themselves don't do very much. A dial tone or a busy
- signal is rather passive. Tones that actually control equipment are
- different. (6) They are part of a coordinated signaling method or
- system. You can guess that such signaling systems predated digital
- working. That's why many analog offices such as step by step and
- crossbar still use them. MF tones provide automatic number
- identification or ANI for long distance calls from some of these offices.
- ANI is essential for billing. It accompanies a call. ANI is put into a
- digital form at the first properly equipped toll office. Never-the-less,
- ANI exists in an acoustical form until that time. Creative use of MF may
- disrupt or alter ANI. In addition, telephone companies use MF tones
- extensively for internal use. An operator, for example, may address a
- call to another operator using these tones. Access to inward operators,
- therefore, is another possibility with home grown MF.
-
- 21. Most MF tones in current use are founded on an international
- agreement called C5. Tones are called codes. Code six stands for
- the number six, code seven for the number seven and so on. Numbers
- are represented by different frequencies than DTMF. Three special
- control tones are used for different functions. MF signaling depends
- on special receivers just like DTMF signals. MF, though, works
- differently than DTMF. Touch tones are sent at a pace that varies from
- person to person. MF tones are often sent in bursts by a machine. 10
- tones may be sent in a little more than a second. DTMF signaling is
- straightforward. MF, on the other hand, depends on a strict protocol.
- The KP or key pulse code is sent first. It tells the decoder that tones will
- follow. The ST or start code indicates that all digits have been sent. This
- shuts the decoder off. The basic tones are shown on page 29. The
- chart on this page shows how the same frequencies are used for pay
- phone control once a call is in progress. Actual working of C5 is
- beyond the scope of this introduction.(7) If there is enough interest,
- however, I could devote an entire issue to multifrequency tones. A
- good understanding of MF seems essential to traveling the world by
- telephone.
-
- Digital signals
-
- 22. Digital signals help the Telco route a call, trace a call and identify a
- pay phone's location. Among other things. These signals are not
- directly accessible to hackers like MF tones. That's because digital
- signals are produced at the switch and not at the pay phone. Access to
- the switch itself is needed before any modification can begin.(8) In
- addition, digital signals are put on a different channel than the voice path
- on which most hacker signaling takes place. Simply blasting modem
- tones down the line won't to do any good. It is this inaccessibility that
- makes digital signals so frustrating.
-
- Trunks, Circuits and Links
-
- 23. A trunk is a communication channel between switching offices or
- between equipment at a switching office. It may be a single wire but
- only rarely. It is most often a channel within a wire or cable. A trunk is
- distinguished from a line which carries traffic between a customer and
- an office. Trunks tie offices and equipment together. A subscriber line
- and a trunk are both transmission lines. The phrase trunk line is correct
- but redundant. It is always thought of as a trunk first. A line is always
- thought of as carrying traffic to a local switch. A trunk always passes
- traffic
-
- 24. A trunk may use different signals than a line. Most DC signals
- can't be used in trunks, for example, because you can't vary the
- voltage of a particular channel within a trunk. The same current
- powers all of the channels within the cable. Think of a cable TV
- line. It may carry fifty channels of programming but you can't
- vary the voltage on channel 21 and not affect channel 22. The
- cable has to carry about 60 volts to power the entire line.
- Different kinds of signals, therefore, may be used between
- offices than the kinds used between a coin phone its end office.
-
- 25. A trunk forms a circuit. But not all circuits are trunks. A
- trunk usually carries conversations. A circuit usually doesn't.
- For example, a no test trunk is used to tell whether a line is
- busy. It's what the operator uses to break into your call when
- there is an emergency.(9) It may use a circuit or relay to work
- but it has always been considered a trunk. By comparison, the
- Automatic Number Announcement Circuit or ANAC is a circuit
- between switching equipment at the central office. But that
- doesn't make it a trunk. It tells you the phone number you are
- calling from. It does not carry, though, any real voice traffic.
- I wrote about other circuits later. The field exchange circuit
- would appear to be a trunk since it connects two switching
- offices. Perhaps. I think it is best described as a hybrid. It has
- always been called a circuit but it has all the attributes of a
- trunk. You'll find people using the word trunk less and less these
- days.
-
- 26. A link has several meanings. A data link is fairly self-
- descriptive. It can be simple. A private, leased line might carry
- company data from a field office to headquarters. It might
- be complicated. Most of the telephone network uses data links to
- carry control signals and routing information for calls which run
- on trunks. On the other hand, a link is also a collection of
- circuits. The first push-button long distance operator console
- used a complex of four circuits. They were known collectively as a
- position link. You'll also hear about A-links, B-links, off links
- and so on. They are a collection of circuits. Connections by radio
- to a switch are also called links. As in a microwave link.
-
- Common channel signaling
-
- 27. A system that utilizes links, data circuits and trunks
- together is called common channel signaling. CCS is poorly named.
- Signaling and conversations are not placed on a common channel.
- Putting the call on one path and the signals that control the call
- on another is a part of C6 and C7, the signaling system currently
- handles most calls.
-
- 28. C5 controls trunks with tones. These tones are different than
- MF but the principle is the same: controlling equipment from a
- distance with the right signal. C5 carries control codes and
- conversations together. This was standard practice until the
- digital age. C5 requires a tone decoder for each trunk. An analog
- office with 100 trunks needs 100 decoders. They are not cheap. C6
- and C7 doesn't need tones to control trunks. Most common channel
- signaling uses something like a Signal Transfer Point or STPs
- instead. These are routing computers distributed about the
- network. STPs direct each call to a toll office. Hundreds and
- hundreds of multiplexed calls are individually managed through
- these computers.
-
- 29. Routing and other features are enabled by the digitally
- encoded markers that are put on each call. Among other things,
- these headers identify the origin of a call and its destination.
- Data bases can be queried automatically while a call is placed.
- An operator knows that you are calling from a Telco payphone as
- soon as you are connected to them. They may even know that you are
- using an airport pay phone. Automated coin toll service or ACTS,
- the automated operator you get with a 1+call, is also made
- possible by accessing these line information data bases or LIBDs.
- (10)
-
- 30. MF controlled trunks still exist for a great deal of operator
- traffic and perhaps to as many as twenty five per cent of America's
- central offices. (11) Many still use single frequency tones like 2600.
- Such a tone might gain control of the trunk or seize it. Remember,
- though, you are seizing a particular channel in a cable, not the entire
- cable. A sweep generator at one end may be one way to test for a MF
- trunk from a pay phone.(12) These system 5 trunks have to interface
- with system 6 and 7 at some point for long distance calling. Don't think
- that remote signaling is impossible because your area has gone digital
- in the form of 6 and 7. Yes, your call to Ryde, California may be
- split up when sent from your area but both voice and control signals
- must reunited on one path when getting to the analog office. As long as
- you have a voice path to an old crossbar or step by step you may
- be in luck. Here is an example of how convoluted this can be.
-
- 31. Most common channel signaling methods give you a local busy
- signal if a distant phone is busy. Let's say that you dial Gabbs, Nevada.
- CCS races ahead to see if the line is busy before a voice connection is
- set up. If it is busy then the data link is brought down and your
- CO is told to generate a busy signal for you to hear. No need to
- provide a 600 mile path for you to hear a busy signal. The old Bell
- System method was called CCIS or common channel interoffice
- signaling. It used 2400 baud modems to pass information back and
- forth. Specialized modems still send the routing information back and
- forth. Let's say, though, that the central office in Gabbs isn't equipped
- to handle system 6 or 7. Like much of the rural west. What then?
-
- 32. It's my understanding that the nearest properly equipped toll
- office would stand as the interface point. A pay phone call from Gabbs
- to Sacramento might go something like this: the pay phone would
- communicate with the central office using DC signals, the CO might
- communicate with the toll office by tones and the toll office would
- communicate with the network by digital signals. The STP might send
- the voice path from the toll office to Reno and then Sacramento. Or
- maybe to Bakersfield and then back to Sacramento. Depends on the
- traffic on the net. The STP might be in Fresno. Still, a home
- brewed tone should be faithfully reproduced over the network to the
- tone sensitive area you are investigating. To do whatever it may.
-
- References
-
- 1. Might it be possible for the skillful hacker to use such a
- circuit? An older central office that still uses tone signaling for trunks
- might provide a stepping stone for the telephone enthusiast. A call
- placed here might attract less attention than an 800 number. I invite
- comments and speculation.
-
- 2. Schillo, Robert F. "A Circuit That Stretches Coin Telephone
- Service' "Bell Laboratories Record." 51:4 (April 1973) 123
-
- 3. Billsf mentions black boxes in "True Colors" 2600, The Hacker
- Quarterly. 10:3 (Autumn 1993) 11. Black boxing seems impossible
- today but I am open to hearing about how it could done. Still, what
- would be gained if you were successful? A local call? Physical control
- of a Telco pay phone is either complicated or impossible. They are
- usually in public view and subject to surveillance by the Telco. It seems
- that an ordinary subscriber line would be a better choice for reinventing.
- I have read, though, of people using pay phone lines to carry their local
- calls by wiring in part of a cordless phone. You would need to be fairly
- close and willing to be dropped out whenever someone made a call. . .
-
- 4. Touch Tones and DTMF stand for the same thing. They are both
- dual tone multi-frequency signals. The phrase TOUCH TONES was a
- trademark of the Bell System. They did pioneering work on tone
- signaling through Bell Laboratories. Do not confuse them with MF
- tones. Multi-frequency tones are also dual tones but they are mostly
- used for internal Telco use.
-
- 5. Fike, John L. and George E Friend. "Understanding Telephone
- Electronics." 2d ed. Carmel, SAMS 1990
-
- 6. Most tables describe tones in a confusing way. The dial tone,
- for example, is a combination of 350 Hz and 440 Hz. Charts state it like
- this: 350 + 440. You might think that the resultant tone is 790 Hz. Not
- so. Common sense tells us that two low tones put together will not
- produce a higher tone. Yet every table I've seen makes it look like an
- addition problem. I use the ampersand symbol instead. 350 "&" 440.
- Two tones combined. This is not a minor, pedantic point. It goes to the
- definition of what a tone is. A single tone is represented by a single sine
- wave. Two sine waves put together produce a complex sine
- wave. What then is the frequency? The baffling answer is that it
- isn't any particular frequency. That's why tables use two tones to
- describe MF or DTMF signals. I find electroacoustics difficult. What if
- you combine two radio frequencies together? Couldn't you get a
- frequency counter to tell you the result? Why can't that be done with
- audio tones?
-
- 7. Billsf "hitchhikers guide to the phone system" 2600 The Hacker
- Quarterly 9:2 (Summer 1992) 10. Everything written by Billsf is
- fascinating. This article is about international signaling. It emphasizes
- MF tones. see also Billsf "True Colors" 2600 The Hacker Quarterly
- 10:3 (Autumn 1993) 9. More information on the actual working of
- MF signals. NB: All 2600 back issues are for sale. See any copy of
- 2600 for details. Or, call their office at (516) 751-2600. Fax line (516)
- 474-2677.
-
- 8. In "A Guide to The 5ESS" 2600, The Hacker Quarterly, Crisp
- G.RA.S.P details the inner workings of a digital switch and describes
- ways to program it. It is a very impressive and advanced article. I
- understand little of it. Those with a good command of UNIX will fare
- better.
-
- 9. This procedure is called a busy line verification or BLV in the
- trade. A skillful hacker may drop into conversations as well by using the
- right tones. Read more about BLVs in Agent Steal's classic article
- "Central Office Operations" in the Winter, 1990 issue of 2600. It's also
- available through the Legion of Doom's Technical Journal gopher.
-
- 10. The trend is to store more and more information in these data
- bases. This can enable a company maintaining the data base to provide
- additional services but it can also lead to more fights among the
- different Telcos and private carriers over who should get that
- information and who should pay for it. A completely digital network
- might be operating in our lifetime but you can bet that it won't be
- flawlessly implemented because of turf wars. 500 companies provide
- long distance service according to the FCC report referenced
- below; competition is a zoo. Local competition when implemented
- will be like letting open the gates of the zoo. Even with call trace a
- hacker should be able to get some breathing room by going through as
- many companies as possible when placing a call.
-
- 11. "Semiannual Report on Telephone Trends in Telephone Service,"
- May, 1994. Industry Analysis Division, Federal Communications
- Commission. Available on the Pac Bell gopher and I think Bell South's.
- The gophers take out the 34 interesting tables. For them you have to
- modem to the FCC itself, which maintains the world's worst
- bulletin board at (202) 632-1361. Good luck . . .
-
- 12. Such as, perhaps, the one available through the Edlie
- Electronics ('Always Something New') catalog for around seventy
- dollars? The "pocket size" sweep generator perhaps? Model 125B?
- Write for a catalog: 2700 Hempstead Turnpike, Levitown, L.I. NY
- 11756-1143. I'm sure your Telco will love you for it.
-
- IV THE DIAL TONE FIRST COIN LINE
-
- 33. I've made many references to the dial tone first coin line in this two
- part series. I think I have explained it enough by comparison and
- contrast. Dial tone first is the operating method for at least 90% of the
- coin telephones in the United States. One thing I haven't done yet is to
- explain some of the terms on the dial tone first table.
-
- 34. TSPS stands for Traffic Service Position System. It is a grotesque
- phrase the Bell System coined to describe their operator service. Before
- 1965 most operators worked at manual switchboards. A long distance
- board might be called a toll board. The Bell System a push button
- console in 1965 that eliminated the cords and jacks and automated some
- parts of coin telephone service. It was quite an accomplishment. They
- called the new console a traffic service position. That made a little sense
- because you could argue that an operator did indeed work at a position.
- Years later the Bell System improved the console but not the name. It
- was now a system or TSPS. I understand that Northern Telecom or
- Northern Electric makes a similar product called TOPS for our Canadian
- friends. These operators must then work at a traffic operator position
- system? I understand that US West has their own kind of automated
- console for their operators. In any case, all of these consoles have
- dozens and of buttons and lights to control calls. A display tells them
- how much money you should deposit for a certain call and then they can
- watch it ring up or totalize on another display.
-
- 35. Wink or multi wink is an important part of computer signaling
- as well as a method used in the telephone industry. Carefully timed
- pauses turn a signal in a channel off and on. You can tell by the table
- that coin phones may be first signaled with this method. It works great
- for optic fiber trunks since no tones or voltage are required to operate it.
- It is sort of like flashing the switch hook except that each wink must be
- the same. And I doubt you can access this since it is triggered at the
- TSPS position. That may be hundreds of miles from the central office.
-
-
- V. THE COIN FIRST COIN LINE
-
- An introduction
-
- 36. I wrote in the first issue that coin first pay phones was the
- standard operating method from the 1920's. Do any remain? I consider
- coin first a defunct operating system, as dead as panel switching.
- Deploying 911 throughout the country would be hindered by coin first.
- There are some interesting details to coin first but I won't describe
- many because I think it's obsolete.
-
- 37. Coin first phones required a deposit before they would operate,
- although not necessarily a dime. I remember flashing the switch hook
- after putting in a nickel. That got you a few Pacific Bell numbers. The
- grace period was also nice. If you dialed a wrong number you could
- quickly hang up and the pay phone returned your dime. This
- disappeared in the 916 after dial tone first was introduced. That may
- have been related, however, to the installation of newer switches and
- not to a special feature of coin first.
-
- 38. There were some problems. The worst was that you needed a coin
- to call an operator in an emergency. There was no 911 in the early to
- mid 1970's. Call boxes existed but there was no centralized emergency
- service. The operator called the right agency when you dialed 0 for help.
- I remember worrying as a kid about always having change with me.
- Otherwise, you might find yourself in real trouble and really alone.
- Another problem was that you couldn't tell if a pay phone was out of
- order until it took your money. No soothing dial tone to confirm
- operation. They were dead as a rock without a dime.
-
- 39. Some contend that coin first was more susceptible to fraud
- than dial tone first. I'm not so sure. Blue boxing occurred during the era
- of coin first. But coin first did not give rise to blue boxing. Instead,
- single frequency coin deposit tones, non armored handset cable and
- less sophisticated totalizers all contributed to make coin first pay phones
- more susceptible than the current models. Coin first operation is not
- inherently suspect, even if the implementing hardware at the time was.
- Single frequency trunks were not a part of coin
- first but instead were accessed by them.
-
- Ground Start
-
- 40. Memories aside, however, coin first did contribute something
- that's used to this day by every dial tone first Telco pay phone. It's
- called ground start. Ground start did two things with coin first. It
- signaled that 1) the pay phone was off hook and 2) that a coin had been
- deposited. Dial tone first, by comparison, only uses ground start
- to signal an off hook. Coin first assumes a coin has been deposited
- since the phone won't operate without one. Dial tone first provides a
- dial tone to begin with. It needs a related signal called the initial rate test
- to indicate that a coin has been put in. Let's look at the mysterious
- sounding ground start.
-
- 41. We usually think of grounding as a way to keep people and
- equipment safe from electrical shock. The issue of grounding for safety,
- however, is a different matter than using grounding to get a telephone
- connection going. Consider what happens when a normal or a post pay
- coin phone goes off hook. Removing the handset causes the switch
- hook buttons to rise. This closes the tip and ring contacts in the
- phone set. They are normally open. Current flows into the loop from
- the central office. The phone starts consuming power like any other
- electrical appliance. Voltage drops from 48 volts DC to, say, 10 volts
- DC. This current flow is detected by a line relay at the CO. It signals
- other equipment to return a dial tone when a strong enough voltage
- drop is detected. This is loop start. It's named after the twisted pair that
- forms a loop connection with the CO.
-
- 42. Ground start works differently. With coin first, a relay in the
- phone grounded the ring wire when a coin was deposited. Current then
- flowed to the pay phone over the tip wire and into the ground. A dial
- tone followed shortly thereafter. A little later the ground was removed.
- This might not make sense at first. We think of electricity as flowing in
- a loop. We associate circuits with circles. Yet here we have a
- connection in the local loop in a straight line. No return wire to the CO.
- But this is the way that telegraphs worked for decades. A conversation
- can certainly work over one wire. The ground provides the complete
- path that defines an electrical circuit. Electricity flows to a good ground
- as easily as water flows downhill. The local loop uses two wires to
- provides a better sounding call. Not necessarily to provide a complete
- electrical circuit. A loop is more efficient as far as conducting electricity
- but you can talk on one wire if you can tolerate some noise. Certainly
- it is enough to get a connection. But why use this technique for pay
- phones?
-
- 43. Fike and Friend say that "ground start lines are used on loops
- connecting PBX's to the central office, and in other situations (pay
- phones) where it is desirable to detect a line that has been selected for
- use (seizure of the line) instantaneously from either side of the line."(1)
- Unfortunately, they do not say why it is desirable to so seize a line.
-
- 44. I think that coin first used ground start for speed. (NOTE: I'M
- INCORRECT ON THIS POINT -- SEE THE THIRD ISSUE) It's
- about getting a dial tone as quickly as possible. That's why it is still
- used. Ground start ties up equipment less than loop start. I wrote in the
- first issue that the Bell System chose pre pay operation instead of post
- pay because of the time it saved its operators. This decision can be
- traced back to 1906.(2) The simpler post pay was discarded in favor of
- coin first because an operator had to wait for a customer to coins. With
- coin first an initial deposit was already placed by the time an operator
- handled the call. Switching equipment can also be held up. The Bell
- System still worried about this 60 years later when they decided to go to
- dial tone first nationwide. Dial tone first would return them to the kind
- of delays that they feared at the turn of the century. Here's a cry of woe
- from the Record in 1969:
-
- "Making modifications to existing equipment is not the only problem.
- Some additional equipment must also be provided in the central office to
- convert to dial tone first operation. For example, holding time of
- crossbar registers and subscriber senders can increase up to 60 percent
- for each completed coin call with the new service. This is due to the time
- taken by customers to deposit coins after the register or sender is
- attached and furnishing dial tone. Moreover, some calls -- those without
- the correct initial deposit -- will not be completed and will have to be
- redialed. Registers and senders must therefore be added to compensate
- for the increased holding time as the office is converted. Similarly, coin
- calls handled by ESS offices are subject to a 5 to 15 percent increase
- in processing time. This increase plus longer equipment holding time
- will result in a decrease in call handling capacity and require more coin
- control circuits." (3)
-
- 45. Boo hoo. It's obvious that holding time was the most important
- thing to the Bell System. Ground start would continue to be used with
- DTF since it is the fastest way to set up a connection. Why is it faster?
- It uses fewer steps. The central office does not have to power the entire
- loop immediately to provide a dial tone. Let's say the CO is five miles
- from a pay phone. Five miles of tip wire and five miles of ring wire.
- Same 48 volts DC under a pressure of perhaps a hundred milliamps.
- Pay phone goes off hook. CO supplies power on one wire. Current
- runs to ground. Dial tone right behind it. No waiting for the rest of the
- loop to power up. But it can't be that much quicker. It does helps with
- part of the problem. Not much can be done, though, about someone
- fumbling for a coin. Or a telephone company drumming its fingers.
-
- 46. Switches like the 5ESS return a dial tone before we can put
- the handset to our ear. Ground start, though, was developed in the era
- of crossbar, panel and step by step. It might have made a difference
- then. COCOTS certainly aren't bothered with a wait for a dial tone.
- But these milliseconds and microseconds are of concern to the Telco
- since they are the local provider of phone service. Several thousand pay
- phones in a large city could add up to the that the Bell article described.
- A Telco pay phone now requires a good ground to properly function.
- Many signals have been developed which utilize grounding. I explain
- these on page 39.
-
- References
-
- 1. Fike, John L. and George E. Friend. "Understanding Telephone
- Electronics." 2d ed. Carmel, SAMS. 1990 191
-
- 2. Fagen, M.D., ed. "A History of Engineering and Science in The
- Bell System: The Early Years, 1875 -- 1925." New York: Bell
- Telephone Laboratories, 1975. 156
-
- 3. Ruppel, A.E. and G. Spiro 'No Dime Needed' "Bell Laboratories
- Record" October, 1969 293
-
- VI. TIP, GROUND AND RING EXPLAINED
-
- 47. The central office controls Telco pay phones by direct current
- signals. I discussed why in the basic signaling article. We now look at
- how DC signals are produced, some terminology about them and a short
- description of each one.
-
- 48. Changing the electrical status of the telephone line produces
- DC signals. This is done by manipulating the ends, or leads, of the tip
- and ring wires. That, in turn, is done by relays. These simple, remotely
- controlled switches are located in the central office and in the pay
- phone. A coin phone relay can fit on a circuit board. Central office
- relays are much larger. They may be mounted in racks.
-
- 49. Relays work by opening, closing or grounding the tip or ring
- wire to produce a signal. Opening a circuit breaks the connection.
- Closing a wire completes it. Grounding a wire shorts it out. Grounding
- one wire, however, doesn't necessarily short out the entire circuit with
- the central office. Current and conversations can still flow over the
- remaining wire.
-
- 50. Depending on the signal needed, tip or ring may be opened,
- closed or grounded at either the central office or at the pay phone. There
- are nine ways to manipulate tip, ground and ring. Just a few are used
- for signaling. But we'll look at all of them for comparison. Here's the
- list:
-
- 1. Tip open and ring open.
- 2. Tip open and ring closed.
- 3. Tip open and ring grounded.
- 4. Tip closed and ring open.
- 5. Tip closed and ring closed.
- 6. Tip closed and ring grounded.
- 7. Tip grounded and ring open.
- 8. Tip grounded and ring closed.
- 9. Tip grounded and ring grounded.
-
- 1.) Tip open and ring open. On hook. The circuit is open because the
- handset is on the switch hook. This tells the central office that a
- particular phone isn't being used.
-
- 2.) Tip open and ring closed. -48V DC. Coin first idle. The normal
- polarity of the now defunct coin first line.
-
- 3.) Tip open and ring ground. A dead line or an open circuit. No
- current flows. Not used for coin line signaling. Automatic testing
- equipment may remove the coin line from service. (1)
-
- 4.) Tip closed and ring open. This common DC signal has many
- variations:
-
- (a) The initial rate test signal. -48V DC. An important part
- of dial tone first operation. Tells the CO that a coin has been put in.
- Depositing a valid coin trips two pay phone relays. One adds a thousand
- ohms of resistance to the circuit with the central office. The other
- grounds the circuit itself.(2) Thus, a coin deposit is represented
- by a grounded circuit with, supposedly, a certain amount of
- resistance.(3) The CO, possibly tone, opens the ring lead on its own
- end. Detecting the coin ground over the tip wire causes a central office
- relay to close the ring side again. The initial rate signal, therefore, is the
- action of opening the ring wire to detect the ground. I do not
- know why it is necessary to disconnect the ring side and not the tip.
-
- (b) The stuck coin test signal. +48V DC. Positive current is applied
- if a coin relay ground persists. That was described above. If successful,
- the coin will fall into the coin box, resetting the relay and thus removing
- the ground. The line returns to normal. Automatic equipment may take
- the line out of service if the ground persists.
-
- (c) The coin return signal. -130V DC. The coin relay directs
- coins to the coin return hopper. Why 130 volts? Later crossbar switches
- used this voltage. Bell Labs may have used it for coin line signaling
- since many central offices could produce it.
-
- (d) The coin collect signal. +130V DC. The coin relay senses
- the change from negative to positive current. This directs coins to the
- coin box. Why doesn't the stuck coin test signal use the same higher
- voltage? They both use positive current. I don't know. This is difficult
- to reconcile since the same relay, I think, is being used in both cases.
-
- 5.) Tip closed and ring closed. Off hook. Normal operation and dial
- tone.
-
- 6.) Tip closed and ring grounded. Reverse battery. -48V DC. Prompted
- by the called party going off hook. The first issue discussed reverse
- battery in detail. This signal may trip a pay phone relay which shorts out
- the DTMF key pad.
-
- 7.) Tip ground and ring open. A dead line. No path for electricity to
- flow.
-
- 8.) Tip ground and ring closed. Current flows on the ring side but
- the tip side is shorted out. There are a number of variations:
-
- (a) Post pay idle? -48V DC. Normal polarity of the post pay line,
- according to Reeve, before a call is connected. I'm not sure anymore.
- Few post pay phones should utilize a grounded circuit.
-
- (b) Dial tone first idle. -48V DC. Normal condition of the
- line until a valid coin is deposited or a free call is placed.
-
- (c) The operator attached signal. +48 V DC. ACTS or the
- operator applies positive voltage to the line. This puts the pay phone into
- the toll mode. Coin deposits are then totaled automatically by ACTS or
- they show up on the operator's console.
-
- (d) The operator released signal in dial tone first. -48 V DC. ACTS
- or the operator removes positive voltage from the line; restores normal
- negative voltage after a call. Pay phone goes back to local mode and the
- totalizer resets itself to zero.
-
- (e) +48V DC. The key pad inhibit signal. A coin first signal, similar
- to the operator attached signal. Disables key pad, perhaps, and resets the
- pay phone totalizer.
-
- 9.) Tip grounded and ring grounded. Dead line.
-
- References . . . .
-
- (1) Martin, John T. "Chilton's Guide to Telephone Installation
- and Repair." Radnor. Chilton Book Company. 1985 140
-
- (2) Detailed in Reeve, Whitman D. "Subscriber Loop Signaling and
- Transmission Handbook: Analog." New York: Institute of Electrical and
- Electronics Engineers. IEEE Press. 1992 221
-
- (3) Why such a complicated process? Preventing fraud, perhaps?
- Adding resistance to the initial rate signal may prevent someone from
- merely grounding the circuit to get a dial tone. Yet, there are many
- stories of punching pay phones with a pin or nail to simulate the initial
- rate test.* NYNEX, in fact, claims millions in damage from
- punching.** That's why so many transmitters are now sealed. We may
- conclude then that 1) grounding alone works, despite the resistance
- that's theoretically required or 2) that the human body itself provides
- the needed resistance, when the punch is held.
-
- * Micro Surgeon/West Coast Phreaks. "Punching Payphones". 2600,
- The Hacker Quarterly. 6:3 (Autumn, 1989) 37
-
- ** Zorpette, Glenn. "New pay phones hit the street". IEEE Spectrum
- May, 1990. 30
-
- NB: This issue contains three informative tone tables. Send me a
- #10 S.A.S.E if you would a like a copy of them.
-
- --------------------
- VI. CALIFORNIA CELL FRAUD LAW: PENAL CODE SECTION
- 502.8
-
- We looked at California Penal Code Section 502.7 in the June
- issue. It covers conventional toll fraud and theft of phone service by
- credit card fraud. Cell fraud occupies its own code section. This law
- imposes much higher fines than Section 502.7. Here is the complete
- text of the bill along with my comments.
-
- "Section 502.8 Use, possession or manufacture of telecommunication
- devices with intent to avoid payment; punishment
-
- (a) Any person who uses a telecommunications device is guilty of a
- misdemeanor."
-
- The penalty for avoiding a charge by using a telecommunication device.
- That device is broadly defined by subsection (f) below. Cell phones are
- included. It might also include a wireless radio system (SMR or
- equivalent) or possibly a personal communicator. A misdemeanor
- means that you serve less than a year in county jail. This subsection is
- for the first offense.
-
- "(b) Any person found guilty of violating subdivision (a), who has
- previously been convicted of the same offense, shall be guilty of a
- felony, punishable by imprisonment in state prison, a fine of fifty
- thousand dollars ($50,000), or both."
-
- For those twice convicted of violating Section 502.8. State prison.
- And fifty thousand dollars! You'll be broke already from legal fees. But
- talk to a lawyer. Your wages might be attached after serving a term,
- forcing you to flee to someplace remote and primitive. Like Arkansas?
-
- "(c) Any person who possesses a telecommunications device with
- intent to sell or offer to sell to another, intending to avoid the payment of
- any lawful charge for service to the device, is guilty of a misdemeanor
- punishable by one year in a county jail or imprisonment in state prison
- or a fine of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or both."
-
- The fine for selling said communication device. Targets the individual.
- Oddly, there is no specific ban on selling plans for such a beast. Talk to
- a lawyer, though, before going into the publishing business in
- California.
-
- "(d) Any person who possesses 10 or more telecommunications
- devices with intent to sell or offer to sell to another, intending to avoid
- payment of any lawful charge for service to the device, is guilty of a
- felony, punishable by imprisonment in state prison or a fine of up to
- fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or both."
-
- Targets the dealer. Having 10 sets off the dogs.
-
- "(e) Any person who manufactures 10 or more telecommunications
- devices and intends to sell or offer to sell to another, intending to avoid
- payment of any lawful charge for service to the device, is guilty of a
- felony, punishable by imprisonment in state prison or a fine of up to
- fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or both."
-
- Targets the manufacturer. For comparison, let's consider some
- other crimes. Your attack dog, Dial Tone, savages a mailman. You get a
- jail term, perhaps, just like the hacker. But your fine is only a thousand
- dollars. (C.P.C. Section 399.5) Or, you molest a child. Another
- thousand dollar fine. (C.P.C. Section 647.6) Abandon your kids?
- Sure, it's just a couple thousand. (C.P.C. 270). So, Joe Hacker rides
- the bus for years after his prison term while Lester the Molester drives
- his Cadillac to the school yard.
-
- "(f) For purposes of this section a telecommunications device is any
- type of instrument, device, machine or equipment that is designed for or
- capable of transmitting or receiving wireless communications within the
- radio spectrum allocated to cellular radio telephony."
-
- Defines a telecommunications device. Bans transmitters and receivers.
- Ridiculous on its face, except to Mr. DA Man. Makes scanners and even
- frequency counters illegal. And although the police won't be conducting
- raids to round up scanners, they could seize them as contraband if so
- inclined. There is no reasonable expectation of privacy over the air,
- anyway. Or on a land line. Cordless phone calls are fair game. Cell calls
- aren't.
-
- This whole section was muscled in by the cellular industry. Instead of
- making it more difficult to listen, the industry chose to make receivers
- illegal. But it is legal to listen to Air Force 1, embassy traffic or the
- Secret Service if you can find the right frequencies. Motorola and
- others produce many kinds of secure systems for the military and the
- police. Such technology, however, would raise the price of a cell phone
- above consumer acceptance. Or so they thought. I see that they are now
- pitching the more expensive digital cell phones, in part, for greater
- privacy.
-
- The larger issue is about profits and the control of technology. A
- possible fine of fifty thousand dollars is a terrible threat. An imposed
- fine of that amount is a merciless punishment. Monetary penalties for
- violent crimes are ridiculously low and penalties for hacking are
- extraordinarily high. I can be fined $10,000 for selling a pirated phone.
- But if I molest a kid then my fine cannot exceed a thousand dollars.
- Punishment should fit the crime. It doesn't.
-
- Tom Farley --- privateline@delphi.com
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-