home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
-
- Computer underground Digest Wed Aug 16, 1995 Volume 7 : Issue 68
- ISSN 1004-042X
-
- Editors: Jim Thomas and Gordon Meyer (TK0JUT2@MVS.CSO.NIU.EDU
- Archivist: Brendan Kehoe
- Shadow Master: Stanton McCandlish
- Field Agent Extraordinaire: David Smith
- Shadow-Archivists: Dan Carosone / Paul Southworth
- Ralph Sims / Jyrki Kuoppala
- Ian Dickinson
-
- CONTENTS, #7.68 (Wed, Aug 16, 1995)
-
- File 1--BCFE Heroes and Villains 1994/1995
- File 2--Cu Digest Header Info (unchanged since 19 Apr, 1995)
-
- CuD ADMINISTRATIVE, EDITORIAL, AND SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION APPEARS IN
- THE CONCLUDING FILE AT THE END OF EACH ISSUE.
-
- ---------------------------------------------------------------------
-
- Date: Sat, 5 Aug 1995 10:09:46 -0500 (CDT)
- From: David Smith <bladex@BGA.COM>
- File 1--BCFE Heroes and Villains 1994/1995
-
- ---------- Forwarded message ----------
-
-
- BCFE NAMES 1994/1995
- HEROES AND VILLAINS
-
- The Boston Coalition for Freedom of Expression, in commemoration of
- the fifth anniversary of the August 1, 1990 Boston opening of Robert
- Mapplethorpe: The Perfect Moment, has compiled its fifth annual list
- of heroes and villains.
-
- The list includes those individuals, organizations, businesses and
- institutions that had the strongest positive and negative effects on
- free expression, the arts, and First Amendment rights in the past
- year. Although our focus is on Massachusetts, we include both
- institutions and individuals whose primary impact has been of local
- importance, and those whose influence is national in scope. Because of
- the surfeit of villains this year, we have expanded our Villains list
- from ten entries to twenty - and find it difficult not to expand it
- further than that. Entries are presented in no particular order.
-
- Lifetime achievement awards are also accorded one individual and one
- institution in each category. Previous lifetime citations for heroism
- have gone to Alan Dershowitz and the American Civil Liberties Union
- (1990-'91); Peggy Charren and the American Library
- Association(1991-'92); Harvey Silverglate and People for the American
- Way (1992-'93); and Don Edwards and the National Coalition Against
- Censorship (1993-'94). Lifetime villains include Senator Jesse Helms
- and the Heritage Foundation (1990-'91); Catharine MacKinnon and the
- American Family Association (1991-'92); Oliver North and the Christian
- Coalition (1992-'93); and Beverly LaHaye and Focus on the Family
- (1993-'94).
-
- The BCFE, an affiliate of the National Campaign for Freedom of
- Expression, is an alliance of artists, arts administrators, writers,
- teachers, and citizens concerned about censorship and the arts. We are
- a project of Mobius, an artist-run center for experimental art in all
- media. The opinions of the BCFE, however, do not necessarily reflect
- those of the NCFE or of Mobius's staff, board, or member artists.
-
- Table of Contents
-
- Villains
-
- Lifetime Achievement Awards
- 1. Paul Weyrich
- 2. Cincinnati
-
- The Top 20 for 1994-1995
- 1. The 104th Congress
- 2. Newt Gingrich
- 3. James Exon
- 4. Larry Pressler
- 5. Diane Feinstein and Trent Lott
- 6. John Kerry
- 7. Ed Markey
- 8. Peter Blute
- 9. DeLores Tucker and William Bennett
- 10. Martin Rimm
- 11. The Carnegie Mellon Administration
- 12. America Online
- 13. Church of Scientology
- 14. Ralph Reed
- 15. Christian Action Network
- 16. Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights
- 17. The New NEA Four
- 18. The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
- 19. William Walsh
- 20. The Boston Press
-
- Dishonorable Mentions
-
- Heroes
-
- Lifetime Achievement Awards
- 1. Leanne Katz
- 2. Rock Out Censorship
-
- The Top 10 for 1994-1995
- 1. Patrick Leahy and Jim Jeffords
- 2. Newt Gingrich
- 3. Nina Crowley
- 4. Hans Evers
- 5. The Bradford College Class of '95
- 6. Yvonne Nicoletti
- 7. The Anti-Censorship Activists at Carnegie Mellon
- 8. Mike Godwin
- 9. Joycelyn Elders
- 10. Nadine Strossen
-
- Honorable Mentions
-
- Posthumous Heroes
-
- Heroes and Villains 1995
-
- Villains
-
- Lifetime Achievement Awards
-
- Right-wing power broker Paul Weyrich. In second place on its list of
- the Top 10 Censored News Stories of 1995, Project Censored cites
- the news blackout on Weyrich's Council for National Policy (CNP).
- A secretive, closed-door strategy-formulating organization whose
- membership is a Who's Who of the far right, the CNP played a
- decisive role in creating the conservative Republican anschluss of
- November 1994. An admirer of Father Coughlin, the Thirties
- pro-fascist radio demagogue, the ardently authoritarian Weyrich
- has operated at the heart of reactionary politics for over two
- decades. With the help of handouts from beer magnate Joseph Coors,
- he has founded or cofounded an impressive list of right-wing
- organizations, including the Moral Majority, the Heritage
- Foundation, and the Committee for the Survival of a Free Congress
- (CSFC). His agenda has been to influence the electoral process
- through fundraising campaigns, grassroots mobilization, propaganda
- blitzes, and promotion of conservative candidates. Out of the CSFC
- grew the Free Congress Foundation, which has branched out into
- lobbying for conservative judicial appointments, communications
- schemes like "National Empowerment Television," and efforts to
- defeat gay rights initiatives. He has described the New Right as
- "radicals who want to change the existing power structure" rather
- than conservatives in any traditional sense. Weyrich was one of
- the first to articulate the idea that the United States is
- engulfed in a cultural civil war. "It may not be with bullets, and
- it may not be with rockets and missiles, but it is a war,
- nonetheless. It is a war of ideology, it's a war of ideas, it's a
- war about our way of life. And it has to be fought with the same
- intensity, I think, and dedication as you would fight a shooting
- war." It is becoming increasingly clear that to dismiss this
- statement is to be fatally deluded.
-
-
- Cincinnati. In 1842, Charles Dickens wrote: "Cincinnati is a beautiful
- city; cheerful, thriving, and animated." He was particularly
- impressed by the Ohio community's support for free public
- education, though he had doubts regarding its quality. English
- entrepreneur Frances Trollope, who preceded Dickens in Cincinnati
- by 14 years and spent much more time there, could have told him
- that Cincinnati education was a fairly Spartan enterprise. In Mrs.
- Trollope's day, this frontier town on the banks of the Ohio was a
- cultural backwater mainly noted for the size of its pig
- population. Trollope, who complained that her Cincinnati neighbors
- held the fine arts in contempt and considered Shakespeare
- "obscene," may herself be held accountable for inventing the
- shopping mall. That she invented it in Cincinnati seems completely
- fitting. A longtime inspiration to the enemies of art, culture,
- scholarship, tolerance, taste, and intelligence, Cincinnati, aka
- Orthodoxy-on-the-Ohio, deserves recognition for the proud
- persistence of its Philistine tradition. For three decades,
- Cincinnati was home to the pacesetting Citizens for Decent
- Literature, led by Charles H. Keating of Lincoln Savings and Loan
- fame, one of the sleaziest politicians of our time. The list of
- censorship imbroglios in recent years is long and sad. Highlights
- include the prosecution of Dennis Barrie and the Contemporary Art
- Center for "pandering obscenity" via the work of Robert
- Mapplethorpe; a heavy-handed effort to shut down the city's only
- gay bookstore by having its video rental copy of Pasolini's film
- Salo adjudicated obscene; library bans on a range of material
- including Playboy and the Advocate; and raids on the homes of
- computer users suspected of downloading pornography. While some
- perfectly good people choose to live in Cincinnati for reasons
- best known to themselves, the city itself is less a municipality
- than it is a state of mind made up of six parts Cincinnati for
- Family Values and four parts Marge Schott. This mindset is
- spreading; beware.
-
- The Top Twenty for 1994-1995
- (in no particular order)
-
- The 104th Congress. Winner of the 1995 Orwell Memorial "Ignorance Is
- Strength" Award. This legion of the ethically challenged came
- swooping down on Washington last winter with a deafening messianic
- mean-spirited roar that all but drowned out the voices of those
- few members who retain the faculty of reason. Its mission is to
- stomp the poor, blight the environment, roll back civil rights,
- erode separation of church and state, and make America a sprawling
- tawdry playground for the crass, the mean and the greedy. Its
- contempt for the Bill of Rights is manifest, especially with
- regard to the First Amendment. Its support for constitutional
- amendments to criminalize flag desecration and reintroduce school
- prayer, its enthusiasm for censorship of cyberspace and
- telecommunications media, its hostility to both high and popular
- culture, and its endless grandstanding over pornography, real and
- imagined, all certify that the 104th Congress is the most
- egregious collection of pro-censorship moral crusaders to hit
- Capitol Hill in over forty years.
-
-
- Congressman Newt Gingrich (R.-Georgia), Speaker of the House of
- Representatives. The race to be crowned Most Repellent Politician
- of Our Time is too close to call, but this Machiavellian sociopath
- may have an edge. Beneficiary of a wealthy propaganda-spewing
- ethically dysfunctional personal empire, chief perpetrator of the
- Contract with America, Gingrich has supported efforts to abridge
- the First Amendment through constitutional additions on flag
- desecration and school prayer, has applied an almost preternatural
- insensitivity to efforts to stifle minority voices, has advocated
- zero-funding of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, and has
- given aid and comfort to every Congressional effort to kill all
- government support for art and scholarship. William Butler Yeats
- said that the millenium would usher in the Age of the Rough Beast;
- it might well be a Newt.
-
-
- Senator J. James Exon. Now that Jesse Helms devotes his wit, charm,
- and intellect to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, which he
- now chairs, his role as the Senate's self-appointed guardian of
- public morals has been assumed by this 74-year-old Nebraska
- Democrat. A longtime supporter of Jesse's attacks on the arts,
- Exon broke new ground by leading the charge to clean up electronic
- communications. Outraged by the news that some people talk about
- sex via computer networks, he sponsored the Communications Decency
- Act (originally S.314), which imposes fines up to $100,000 and
- prison sentences up to two years for electronic "indecency."
- Attached to the Senate's omnibus telecommunications package,
- Exon's bill passed the Senate 84-16, and may well become law. The
- fact that sexually explicit material is only available to those
- who actively seek it out matters not to Exon who, like all
- censors, enjoys minding other people's business. Railing against
- "porn-users' advocates" like the ACLU and the Electronic Frontier
- Foundation, Exon basks in the support of the theocratic right.
-
-
- Senator Larry Pressler. Chairman of the Senate Commerce, Science and
- Transportation Committee, this South Dakota Republican's
- McCarthyite assaults on the Corporation for Public Broadcasting
- reveal the moral vacuity of a politician who never stops
- campaigning - and addressing his campaign pitch to the lowest
- common denominator. Pressler's most offensive stunt in recent
- months was to demand that all affiliates of National Public Radio
- fill out a 16-page questionnaire, prepared with input from the
- far-right Family Research Council, about the sex, ethnicity,
- religious backgrounds, political affiliations, and employment
- histories of all employees. Special attention was paid to whether
- any NPR employees had worked for Pacifica Radio, which has
- challenged broadcast content restrictions. "[The questionnaire is]
- aimed at only one thing, and that's intimidation," the late Arthur
- Kropp of People for the American Way told the New York Times.
- "It's politics at its nastiest... a witch hunt." The questionnaire
- was finally withdrawn, but not before Pressler's ideological
- fact-finding mission had cost taxpayers $92,000. As Pressler's
- South Dakota Democratic counterpart once said, "A Senate seat is a
- terrible thing to waste."
-
-
- Senators Diane Feinstein (D.-California) and Trent Lott
- (R.-Mississippi). "Liberal" Democrat Feinstein and redneck
- Republican Lott, both avid supporters of the Senate's Counter
- Terrorism bill (S.735) and its roving wiretap provisions, teamed
- up to make that dubious piece of legislation even more repressive
- with an amendment banning distribution of information about
- explosive materials and devices by any means. (Goodbye Anarchist
- Cookbook.) The comedy team of Feinstein and Lott has also
- collaborated on efforts to combat smut on cable tv, and are among
- the sponsors of the Flag Desecration Amendment - which, if
- ratified, will mean that the United States neither has nor
- believes in freedom of speech.
-
-
- Senator John F. Kerry (R.-Massachusetts). One of an increasing number
- of Democrats who seek to get votes by proving that they can be
- Republicans just like everybody else, Kerry has been drifting to
- the right in ways that show dwindling concern for First Amendment
- principles. His worst offense may be his support of James Exon's
- Communications Decency Act, which he voted for twice: in
- committee, and then on the floor of the Senate. An opponent of the
- 1989 Flag Amendment, he has equivocated in stating his position
- regarding that measure's current incarnation, and may even vote
- for it. Not, in any case, to be trusted.
-
-
- Congressman Ed Markey (D.-Mass.). Doggedly persisting in his efforts
- to censor television, Markey is the chief architect of the
- Parental Choice in Television Act, H.R.2030. The bill, which may
- well become law, would force purchasers of television sets to pay
- for a violence-censoring device (the so-called V-chip), whether
- they want one or not. More problematic is a provision that calls
- for an official federal Television Rating Code, should the
- broadcast industry fail to adopt a satisfactory rating system
- "voluntarily." (Such a rating system, which would not distinguish
- Eisenstein's Potemkin from Miami Vice, would be at least as much a
- censorship tool as the MPAA's film rating system; the chill is
- already being felt.) It is worth noting that the left-leaning Mr.
- Markey's Congressional district is a hotbed of right-wing
- activity, and that he has been steadily pressured by Morality in
- Media to help wage its holy war against the secular humanist
- airwaves.
-
-
- C. DeLores Tucker, head of the National Political Caucus of Black
- Women, and William Bennett, disastrous Education Secretary under
- Reagan, bumbling drug czar under Bush, presently co-director of
- Empower America, a reactionary right public policy lobby, and the
- "John M. Olin Distinguished Fellow in Cultural Policy" at the
- egregious Heritage Foundation. Even stranger bedfellows than Diane
- Feinstein and Trent Lott, this odd couple has recently found
- common ground in the will to censor popular culture. Joining
- forces in press conferences, public appearances, and a series of
- public service announcements decrying rap music and Time Warner,
- Tucker and Bennett deny promoting censorship while avidly
- supporting censorious ratings systems, broader definitions of
- pornography, and narrower definitions of permissible speech. Using
- rhetoric that combines the sanctimoniousness of Jerry Falwell with
- the sophistry of Catharine MacKinnon, Tucker has testified before
- Congress that "Because this pornographic smut is in the hands of
- our children, it coerces, influences, encourages and motivates our
- youth to commit violent behavior." She believes that much rap
- music is not entitled to constitutional protection and should be
- sold in adult bookstores if at all. Bennett, smug, self-righteous
- editor of the Book of Virtues, has recently demanded abolition of
- the National Endowment for the Humanities, which he once chaired,
- because of its failure to live up to his right-wing standards of
- political correctness.
-
-
- Martin Rimm. Recipient of our first annual Milo Minderbinder Award for
- Outstanding Pro-Censorship Achievement by a Self-Promoting
- Charlatan. As an undergraduate at Pittsburgh's Carnegie Mellon
- University, Rimm conducted a "research" project on sexually
- explicit material on computer networks. With the aid of anti-porn
- activist Deen Kaplan, Rimm sold the study to the student editors
- of the Georgetown Law Review, with the stipulation that potential
- critics would not see pre-publication copies. Rimm then panicked
- the Carnegie Mellon administration into censoring electronic
- access on campus, talked Time into doing a lurid cover story, and
- wangled an appearance on Nightline. On publication, the study
- immediately revealed itself as methodologically worthless.
- Information soon came to light suggesting that Rimm had (1) pried
- information from operators of adult bulletin boards by claiming
- they could use his study to increase their profits; (2)
- simultaneously tried to sell his software to the Department of
- Justice to help them prosecute those same people; (3) used
- unethical means to obtain computer usage data on Carnegie Mellon
- students, faculty and staff; (4) misrepresented his position at
- Carnegie Mellon; (5) plagiarized parts of his report from a
- Canadian study whose conclusions were almost diametrically opposed
- to his. These charges, now under investigation, have resulted in
- Rimm being disinvited to testify at anti-porn hearings on July 24.
- But the damage has been done. Rimm's results, which distort and
- grossly exaggerate both the availability and the nature of sexual
- material on the Internet, will be repeated by pro-censorship
- zealots in and out of Congress until they become "facts."
-
-
- America Online (AOL) and its ambitious President and CEO, Stephen M.
- Case. In the words of James Egelhof, who maintains one of a
- growing number of anti-AOL sites on the Internet, "AOL provides
- the worst Internet service in the country, and charges massively
- for it. AOL's profits depend on pacifying its user base and
- quelling dissent and debate, so it enforces a heavily restrictive
- user agreement against its customers.... AOL's online areas are
- far from the free-speech havens Internet users have come to expect
- on Usenet and IRC [Interactive Relay Chat]. In fact, AOL, bent on
- presenting itself as a `family service,' makes sure that nothing
- controversial or offensive ever can reach its members. AOL staff,
- armed with a lengthy list of prohibited subjects and words, police
- the message boards and chat rooms for violations. These untrained
- staffers have the power to delete any message, stop any chat, and
- cancel any member's account." Among the many forbidden words
- included in AOL's "Vulgarity Guidelines" are penis, vagina,
- defecation, urination, transsexual, transvestite, sadomasochism,
- and submissive. In addition, Case and his AOL watchdogs have been
- recording information about what their subscribers download, and
- sharing it with the Justice Department. AOL, of course, has not
- explained who uploaded the material in the first place or how it
- is so easy for them to track the relevant downloads. Sounds like
- entrapment to us.
-
-
- The Church of Scientology. Perhaps modeling their behavior on that of
- America Online, the keepers of the flame of L. Ron Hubbard have
- forged cancellations of Internet messages they don't like, tried
- to remove an entire Usenet discussion group devoted to critical
- examination of Scientology, threatened operators of anonymous
- remailing services in order to discourage anonymous criticism of
- Scientology, instigated a raid on an anonymous remailing service
- in Finland, and sought to intimidate Scientology critic Dennis
- Ehrlich, his Internet access provider, and Netcom by suing them on
- extremely dubious grounds of copyright violation.
-
-
- Ralph Reed, Executive Director of the Christian Coalition. Recipient
- of our 1993 institutional Lifetime Achievement Award for Villainy,
- the Christian Coalition has not been content to rest on its
- laurels. This relentlessly obnoxious outfit has, in fact, gone
- forth and multiplied, spreading nationwide like a plague of kudzu.
- Although some credit for this success is due Pat Robertson, from
- whose failed 1988 presidential campaign the Christian Coalition
- slithered forth, the real driving force and leading strategist
- behind this crypto-fascist movement has been Mr. Reed. With
- diligence and fierce efficiency, testing the outer limits of
- 501(c)(3) nonprofit status all the way, Reed has quietly set about
- dismantling the Bill of Rights. A measure of his success is the
- seriousness with which his Contract with American Families, a
- legislation package from Hades that pursues a program of
- theocratic social engineering, has been received on Capitol Hill.
- (One of its demands, the elimination of the arts and humanities
- endowments, is now nearing fulfillment.) Reed, who has the aura of
- a choirboy who slips behind the rectory to strangle cats, is one
- of the most sinister figures ever to gain power on the Christian
- Right.
-
- Sex Is...
-
- , which indirectly benefited from NEA funding.
-
-
-
- The Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights. A right-wing
- authoritarian movement that overlaps with Operation Rescue and militant
- charismatic factions, the Catholic League has enjoyed increasing success in
- misrepresenting itself as a mainstream Catholic organization. Ten years ago,
- the Catholic League gained notoriety by mobilizing against Jean-Luc Godard's
- Hail Mary; in 1995, it got even more mileage out a patently offensive
- disinformation campaign against the movie Priest, accompanied by a boycott of
- Walt Disney Enterprises, whose subsidiary Miramax released the film. The
- Catholic League's obsessively homophobic Massachusetts chapter tried to
- prevent the film, which deals with a gay priest in working-class Liverpool,
- from opening at the Dedham Community Theater, and did succeed in shortening
- its run. In other recent exploits, the Catholic League has been active in the
- fight against condom distribution and safer sex information, and mobilized
- against Boston's Institute of Contemporary Art for supporting World AIDS Day
- posters and shrines depicting the Blessed Virgin Rubber Goddess ("Immaculate
- Protection"), a project by Provincetown artist Jay Critchley and Boston
- artist/activists Lydia Eccles and Wendy Hamer.
-
-
-
- The NEA Administrative Four. People like these caused arts advocates who had
- fought long and hard in defense of the NEA to give up and abandon ship. (1)
- Jane Alexander, the arts endowment's Chairman, made our Heroes List last
- year, then disgraced herself within a matter of days by permitting the
- politically motivated defunding of photographers Merry Alpern, Barbara
- DeGenevieve, and Andres Serrano - and then claiming that the quality of the
- artists' work was at issue. Since then, she has presided over more
- politically inspired vetoes of NEA panel-approved grants than her two
- Bush-era predecessors combined, while playing the role of Great Lady of the
- Arts and getting away with it. (2) Cherie "Get with the Program" Simon, the
- NEA's head of press relations, who speaks for the Endowment when Jane
- Alexander isn't being let out. Simon's abrasive, condescending style, barely
- masking her contempt for artists, has helped erode the NEA's grassroots
- support. (3) National Arts Council Member George White, President of the
- O'Neill Theater Center, led the charge against Alpern, DeGenevieve, and
- Serrano, claiming that to fund them would contravene the "clear instructions
- of Congress." White's attitude toward Serrano, an artist now being punished
- for his much-misunderstood 1987 work "Piss Christ," has helped make
- blacklisting at the NEA a respectable enterprise. (3) National Arts Council
- Member Barbara Grossman, who teaches in the Drama Department at Tufts
- University, may have set the standards of doublethink and cognitive
- diminution that the Council, the governing board of the NEA, now lives by.
- Last August, in the apparently rehearsed deliberations that ended in the
- defunding of Alpern, DeGenevieve and Serrano, Grossman read the 1992
- Democratic Party statement on freedom of expression, then said brightly, "We
- cannot be blind to political reality.... I would never, ever limit an
- artist's ability to create what he or she needs to create... but I think that
- given the volatile times in which we live, we cannot be blind to the reality
- of funding, either." Since this sort of Orwellian moral sellout predictably
- did nothing to change the reality of funding at the NEA - i.e., there very
- likely soon won't be any funding - it might at least have given us a lift if
- someone there had stood up and shown some integrity.
-
-
-
- The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court. Continuing a tradition, the high
- court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts has in the past year placed
- political correctness before sound Constitutional principles on at least two
- important occasions. In Bowman v. Heller and Hurley v. Irish-American Gay,
- Lesbian and Bisexual Group of Boston, the SJC made well-meaning and popular
- decisions that unfortunately contravened well-established First Amendment
- law. In Bowman, a suit by a candidate for union office against a political
- enemy who had made crude and distasteful flyers lampooning her and
- distributed them privately to five allies, the court ruled that Heller's
- "intentional infliction of emotional distress" entitled Bowman to damages.
- This contradicts the 198? U.S. Supreme Court decision Falwell v. Hustler,
- which affirmed the constitutionality of satire; its implications are
- particularly disturbing for writers and artists. In Hurley, the court ruled
- that the virulently homophobic Allied War Veterans who run Boston's St.
- Patrick's Day Parade had to accept the presence of a gay contingent in their
- annual celebration of bigotry. Having ruled in the Desilets case that
- landlords can refuse to rent to tenants if they disapprove of the tenants'
- lifestyles, the SJC seems to believe that members of sexual-minorities should
- be allowed to march in St. Patrick's Day parades but not be allowed to rent
- apartments. The Hurley decision has recently been overturned by the U.S.
- Supreme Court, where, if there is any justice, the Bowman case will soon be
- headed.
-
-
-
- Former Cambridge (Mass.) City Councilor William Walsh. Still clinging to his
- City Council seat while awaiting sentencing on 41 bank fraud convictions,
- Walsh appointed himself municipal arbiter of decency last October and
- embarked on a one-man vigilante raid against an art exhibit sponsored by the
- Cambridge Cultural Council. The target of Walsh's righteous wrath, which he
- called "nothing but raw sex," was Identidem, an exhibit of works by artist
- Hans Evers. A sampling of pieces from a two-year project on masculine
- identity, the show included phallic imagery, but no depictions of sexual
- activity. (The presence of masking and posted disclaimers should have been
- sufficient to warn those potentially offended by a few allusions to male
- anatomy.) Ripping two latex dildos out of their settings and absconding with
- them, Walsh demanded that the show be shut down, that the Cambridge Cultural
- Council be investigated, and that Hans Evers be prosecuted for obscenity. He
- also alerted right-wing media thugs like Cro-Magnon radio talk show host
- Howie Carr, and launched a smear campaign against Evers, his supporters, and
- the Cultural Council. Evers responded by pressing charges against Walsh for
- malicious destruction of property. Although Walsh was acquitted by jurors who
- were never instructed in the serious First Amendment implications of a public
- official acting as self-appointed censor, the BCFE finds Walsh - a longtime
- enemy of the arts, free expression, and civilized society -thoroughly and
- irredeemably guilty.
-
-
-
- The Boston press. Five years ago, when artists organized the BCFE in response
- to attacks on the NEA and cultural institutions, Boston had a number of
- reliable arts reporters. These journalists were of varying degrees of
- intelligence, talent, sophistication and perspicacity, and not all of them
- wrote for papers whose agendas encompassed any serious arts coverage.
- Nevertheless, we could at one time be sure that if anything significantly
- affecting the arts happened locally or nationally, someone in Boston would
- report it. Such is no longer the case. The best arts journalists in Boston
- have left town, gone on leaves of absence, stopped working altogether, or
- moved to publications where their strengths are wasted, underused, and
- practically unrecognized. Because local editors -including most arts editors
- - tend to have little respect for, interest in, or knowledge of the lives and
- issues of working artists, and are ill-informed about grave issues facing the
- arts today, arts reportage is now mostly the domain of the young, the
- starstruck, and the inept. (The conventional wisdom seems to be that one
- doesn't need to know a damned thing in order to cover the arts.) Events of
- crucial importance to the thousands of cultural workers in the Boston area go
- unreported here, leaving an informational void for which every publication in
- Boston must be held accountable. The worst offenders have been (1) the Boston
- Globe, where Arts Editor Mary Jane Wilkinson (recently promoted to Managing
- Editor for Features) has thrown the full weight of her provinicial arrogance
- into an apparent effort to make sure the arts supporters of New England
- remain as clueless as she is; (2) the Boston Phoenix, which suffered a brain
- drain with the departures of Mark Jurkowitz, Maureen Dezell, Ric Kahn, Liz
- Galst and others, and now appears to be assembled by and for supremely
- oblivious toxic yuppies; (3) the Boston Herald, which now prints less of
- cultural interest than the Daily Racing Form. Until this situation improves,
- artists interested in keeping informed should rely on the Washington Post,
- the Village Voice, trade publications, the Internet, and smoke signals.
-
- Dishonorable Mentions
-
- Congressman Joseph Kennedy (D.-Mass.), who proves that not all Kennedys
- support the arts and have three-digit IQs, for supporting the Flag Amendment
- and other idiocies; Senators Charles Grassley (R.-Iowa) and Dan Coats
- (R.-Indiana), for boorish attempts to regulate content in cyberspace; Senator
- Nancy Kassebaum (R.-Kansas), for punitive moves against the NEA for funding
- Highways, the Santa Monica facility where performance artist Tim Miller is
- based ("I think most people would not call the solo performances of Tim
- Miller art"); roving wingnut Barry Crimmins for his delusional testimony in
- recent cyberporn hearings; Herald-critic-cum-dance-administrator Iris Fanger,
- for doltishly censoring a piece by choreographer Lynn Shapiro out of this
- summer's Faculty Performance Dance Series at Harvard; the MBTA Police (the
- Boston subway gestapo), for heavyhanded attempts to stop orderly protests
- against the Commuter Channel, and for roughing up artist Stephen Frederick
- for the crime of dressing weirdly; the MBTA, for trying to reject public
- service messages by the AIDS Action Committee, and for removing AIDS
- awareness posters by artist Jay Critchley; New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani,
- for pushing a draconian porn-zoning ordinance; Time magazine, for
- disseminating shoddy, sensational pro-censorship propaganda in the wake of
- Congressional attacks on Time Warner; Disney/Miramax, for butchering the
- works of film artists in order to perk them up for American attention spans
- and tone them down to avoid the dreaded NC17; the Haverhill Gazette, for its
- rabidly homophobic efforts to stop Leslie Feinberg's appearance at Bradford
- College; the administration of Bradford College, for almost giving the
- Haverhill Gazette its wish; Principal Gregory Scotten of Martha's Vineyard
- Regional High School, for censoring the commencement speech of Class of '95
- Salutatorian Megan Cryer, refusing to allow her to refer to her rape by a
- fellow student; Orleans Town Executive Nancymarie Schwinn, for her mercifully
- short-lived directive against nude representations in the Orleans Cultural
- Council's gallery; Lotus Corporation, for erasing identifiably gay and
- lesbian material from an art exhibit intended to celebrate Gay Pride Month;
- the busy book banners of New Hampshire; Gary Bauer's Family Research Council;
- Senator Ernest "Fritz" Hollings (D.-South Carolina); Donald Wildmon's
- American Family Association; Congressman Robert Dornan (R.-California);
- Congressman Phil Crane (R.-Illinois); Congressman Dick Armey (R.-Texas);
- Congressman Richard Neal (R.-Mass.); the Clinton Administration; and others
- too depressingly numerous to mention.
-
- Heroes
-
- Lifetime Achievement Awards
-
- Leanne Katz, Executive Director of the National Coalition Against
- Censorship. When we gave our 1994 institutional Lifetime
- Achievement Award for Heroism to the National Coalition Against
- Censorship, we said that Leanne Katz's "drive, determination,
- integrity of purpose and clarity of vision make her one of the
- finest role models free expression activists could hope for." In
- the past year, she has more than justified that description. Her
- courageous leadership on a succession of difficult issues has been
- indispensable at a time of burnout and demoralization. We are
- especially grateful for her swift response to the harassment
- campaign directed at the Pink Pyramid, Cincinnati's only gay and
- lesbian bookstore, whose video rental copy of Pasolini's Salo
- served as the basis for "pandering obscenity" charges. Grasping
- the importance of this case more readily than some free expression
- advocates who ought to have known better, Leanne Katz initiated an
- amicus brief supporting attempts to dismiss charges against the
- bookstore owner and two employees. This brought the righteous
- wrath of Donald Wildmon's American Family Association down on her
- organization. With typical grace and tact, she turned the
- resulting crisis into a moral victory. We are pleased to honor
- this passionately sane defender of freedom for her tireless
- efforts on behalf of all of us. For information about the National
- Coalition Against Censorship, write to: NCAC, 275 7th Avenue, New
- York, NY 10001.
-
-
- Rock Out Censorship. This Ohio-based organization, rooted in the music
- scene but broadly attentive to First Amendment issues, was founded
- by activist John Woods, who understands that any movement worthy
- of the name must have strong grassroots participation. With the
- help of its newsletter, an information-packed tabloid that puts
- slicker publications to shame, Rock Out Censorship informs music
- fans and musicians while mobilizing them across the country. A
- strong supporter of the Right to Rock Network campaign against
- Parental Advisory labels, ROC is in the forefront of fights
- against music censorship in many states, most notably in
- Pennsylvania. Knowing this group exists helps keep members of the
- BCFE from flinging themselves into Boston Harbor; ROC has our
- strongest endorsement. For information, contact Rock Out
- Censorship, POB 147, Jewett, OH 43986.
-
- Top Ten for 1994-1995
- (in no particular order)
-
- Senators Patrick Leahy (D.-Vermont) and Jim Jeffords (R-Vermont). In
- the Green Mountain State, something in the air, the water or the
- maple syrup seems to help produce a higher class of legislator.
- Both Leahy and Jeffords have long supported funding without
- content restriction for the National Endowment for the Arts, the
- National Endowment for the Humanities, and the Corporation for
- Public Broadcasting. This year, Leahy emerged as the Senate leader
- in the fight against censorship in cyberspace, a fight supported
- by Jeffords. Among Republicans, Jeffords has established a First
- Amendment record rivaled only by Rhode Island's John Chafee.
- Recently Jeffords has not only stood firm against the prevailing
- anti-cultural currents of his own party, he has been among the few
- Senators from either side of the aisle who have marshaled cultural
- literacy, insight and commitment into efforts to save government
- support for the arts and humanities.
-
-
- Congressman Newt Gingrich. We are willing to choke back our revulsion
- long enough to give Gingrich credit for his opposition to Senator
- Exon's Communications Decency Act (CDA) and other attempts to
- censor the Internet. On June 20, on the National Empowerment
- Television program Progress Report, Newt said of the CDA, "It is
- clearly a violation of the right of adults to communicate with
- each other. I don't agree with it.... [It is] a very badly thought
- out and not productive amendment...." Civil libertarians were at
- first skeptical, but Newt evidently meant what he said and has
- used his considerable power to thwart all cyber-censorship
- initiatives reaching the House.
-
-
- Music industry activist Nina Crowley. When a petition seeking to ban
- sales of records with Parental Advisory labels to minors was
- presented to the City Council in her home community, Leominster
- (MA), Nina Crowley played a key role in defeating the measure by
- circulating a counterpetition and seeking support from the
- Recording Industry of America, the National Association of
- Recording Merchandisers, and the ACLU. Out of this effort grew
- Mass. MIC (the Massachusetts Music Industry Coalition), an
- organization that brings together musicians, promoters, d.j.s and
- fans in an effort to uphold freedom of expression in music and all
- other media. As Mass. MIC's Executive Director, Ms. Crowley has
- worked tirelessly and effectively to make her organization a major
- rallying point in the fight to stop censorship in Massachusetts.
-
-
- Artist Hans Evers. Contrary to legend, few artists leap at the chance
- to gain the kind of notoriety censorship incidents confer on them.
- Hans Evers certainly had nothing of that nature in mind when he
- installed his city-sponsored exhibit at Gallery 57 in Cambridge,
- Mass. But when Cambridge City Councilor William Walsh intervened,
- damaging one piece in the process of trying to censor it, Evers
- fought back. Where many artists would have let the matter drop,
- this one sought justice - and affirmation of the fact that the
- First Amendment forbids public officials to act as freelance art
- vigilantes. Evers got no such satisfaction, and received a welter
- of ridicule from right-wing columnists and talk-show hosts. But
- his handling of the situation set a fine example for artists
- everywhere, and we salute him for it.
-
-
- Bradford College Class of '95. Graduating seniors at Bradford College,
- a small but reputable 4-year liberal arts institution in
- Haverhill, Mass., traditionally pick their own commencement
- speaker. Normally, the only issue is availability. This year,
- Bradford seniors chose author/labor activist Leslie Feinberg,
- whose novel Stone Butch Blues had been required reading in the
- Senior Humanities Seminar that half the class was obligated to
- take. Bradford President Joseph Short refused their request,
- saying that to invite Feinberg, a self-described transgendered
- lesbian, would be inconsistent with the dignity of commencement.
- As one student put it, "We cannot graduate without reading her
- book, but we cannot hear her speak at graduation." Demanding that
- Short rescind his decision, students occupied the administration
- building, alerted the media, and contacted gay rights, labor, and
- free expression advocates across the state and around the country.
- Short eventually relented. In her eloquent commencement address,
- Leslie Feinberg paid tribute to the integrity and determination of
- the Class of '95; we're happy to echo her sentiments.
-
-
- Andover High School student Yvonne Nicoletti. When Nicoletti, an
- 18-year-old honor student, arrived at school clad in a T-shirt
- promoting the band White Zombie, Assistant Principal Ellen Parker
- ordered her to go home and change. Parker found the design
- emblazoned on the shirt, a caricature of large-breasted women,
- offensive. Nicoletti left the school, but then, with her parents'
- consent, returned to the school grounds wearing her bra outside
- the offending shirt to cover some of the graphics. When she began
- a silent vigil standing on a boulder opposite the school,
- principal Timothy Thomas ordered her to leave. When she refused,
- he had her arrested and charged with "disturbing a school," then
- suspended her indefinitely. With the aid of the Massachusetts
- Civil Liberties Union, Nicoletti was reinstated at Andover High a
- few days later. In July, Judge Elizabeth Flatley of Lawrence
- District Court formally filed the case, insuring that it would
- slip into oblivion without coming to trial, and leaving the
- question of Nicoletti's First Amendment rights - and that of other
- Massachusetts high school students - unresolved. Nicoletti's
- spirited, courageous, principled stand against censorship serves
- nevertheless as an example to students in increasingly repressive
- public schools across Massachusetts.
-
-
- The anti-censorship activists at Carnegie Mellon University,
- especially (1) former Student Body President Declan McCullagh; (2)
- the students, faculty, staff and alumni who make up the Coalition
- for Academic Freedom of Expression (CAFE); and (3) the pro-sex
- feminist direct-action group known as the Clitoral Hoods. Serving
- as an example to academic communities everywhere, they had the
- guts to stand up to the heavy-handed tactics of an intellectually
- dishonest authoritarian administration. (If he had done nothing
- else, McCullagh would still deserve thanks for discovering that
- Martin Rimm is the author of the most execrably written novel in
- the English language, An American Playground.)
-
-
- Mike Godwin, staff counsel for the Electronic Frontier Foundation
- (EFF). A leader in the fight against government censorship of
- computer networks, Mike Godwin is an able communicator who
- explains in clear and eloquent terms the nature of electronic
- communication and the indispensability of free expression to a
- working democracy. Mike has served us well by preparing EFF's
- powerful Congressional testimony, by going one-on-one with the
- Christian Coalition's Ralph Reed on Nightline, and by doing a lot
- of the legwork necessary to expose the Martin Rimm "study" for the
- academic fraud that it is.
-
-
- Former Surgeon General Joycelyn Elders. A wise, intelligent, truthful
- voice in a presidential administration notably lacking in wisdom,
- intelligence, and truthfulness, Dr. Elders was an isolated voice
- of reason on the subjects of sex, AIDS, contraception, and drugs.
- This made her the object of one of the most vicious and persistent
- hate campaigns ever mounted by the theocratic right. Many would
- have answered such smears in kind; Elders responded with dignity,
- humor, and a firm resolve never to be to be silenced. Someday,
- when American culture reaches adulthood, it will be ready for a
- Joycelyn Elders, but then the need for her will be less acute.
-
-
- Nadine Strossen, President of the American Civil Liberties Union.
- Noted for her well-articulated and authoritative stands on a range
- of constitutional issues, Nadine Strossen is the youngest person
- ever to rise to the presidency of the ACLU. Her book Defending
- Pornography: Free Speech, Sex, and the Fight for Women's Rights,
- published in 1995 by Scribner, presents solid arguments, from a
- feminist perspective, against censorship of sexually explicit
- material. One of the best features of this excellent, necessary
- work is that it clearly and compellingly demonstrates the
- anti-feminist nature of such censorship. The author of an
- important essay, "Regulating Racist Speech on Campus," reprinted
- in the anthology Speaking of Race, Speaking of Sex (NYU Press,
- 1995), Strossen has lectured eloquently on the problems of free
- speech in recent public appearances around the country. She
- teaches at New York Law School; we envy her students.
-
-
-
- Honorable Mentions
-
- Music promoter Richard White and Nirvana guitarist Krist Novoselic, for
- founding the advocacy organization JAMPAC and lending critical support to
- Mass. MIC; students Jeffrey and Jonathan Pyle and their father, law professor
- Christopher Pyle, for challenging the dress code at South Hadley (Mass.)
- High; students Casie and John Northrup, for pursuing a similar challenge at
- Carver (Mass.) High; Congressman Peter Torkildsen (R.-Mass.), for breaking
- with his party in ways that show a civilized sensibility at work, and for
- risking obloquy by defending the National Endowment for the Humanities;
- journalist/critic Bill Marx, for a Boston Magazine piece that at least
- approached a truthful perspective on the strange world of the Massachusetts
- Cultural Council; banned novelist Nancy Garden, for the integrity of her work
- and the eloquence of her statements on censorship at the 1995 OutWrite
- Conference; Lani Guinier, for continuing to defend the rights of minority
- voices to be heard; theater historian Gail Cohen, for dedicating herself to
- the preservation of an almost lost heritage in regional theater; banned
- novelist Robert Cormier, for his stands against the censorship of his own
- work and everyone else's; theater owner Garen Daly, for resisting heavyhanded
- attempts to keep the film Priest out of Dedham, Mass.; Boston printmaker
- Jerry Harold Hooten, for refusing to acquiesce to censorship by
- representatives of Lotus Corporation; Martha's Vineyard Regional High School
- Salutatorian Megan Cryer, for responding to censorship of her graduation
- speech with an eloquent silence; Feminists for Free Expression, for existing.
- In a cultural war of attrition, we are relieved to note that many of those
- we've honored in the past five years are still in the trenches. These include
- artist Kurt Reynolds; playwright Vera Gold; musician David Herlihy; Boston
- Center for the Arts Director Susan Hartnett; ICA Director Milena Kalinovska;
- attorney/journalist Harvey Silverglate, attorney/author Wendy Kaminer;
- artist/educator Edward Strickland; Edmund Barry Gaither of the Center for
- Afro American Studies; Skipp Porteous of the Institute for First Amendment
- Studies; ACLU attorney Marjorie Heins; journalist Nan Levinson; free
- expression activist Peggy Charren; scholars Henry Louis Gates, Jr. and
- Anthony Appiah; Boston Cultural Commissioner Bruce Rossley; and many others.
-
- Finally, we confer posthumous Lifetime Achievement Awards on Bill Reeves,
- Chairperson of the Boston Coalition for Freedom of Expression for over two
- years until his sudden accidental death on April 2, 1995, whose unwavering
- dedication to the cause of free expression was an inspiration to everyone who
- had the privilege of working with him; and on Arthur Kropp, the fiercely
- dedicated President of People for the American Way from 1987 until his death
- from complications of AIDS on June 12, 1995. The loss of these irreplaceable
- people will be acutely felt for many years to come.
-
- ------------------------------
-
- Date: Sun, 19 Apr 1995 22:51:01 CDT
- From: CuD Moderators <cudigest@sun.soci.niu.edu>
- File 2--Cu Digest Header Info (unchanged since 19 Apr, 1995)
-
- Cu-Digest is a weekly electronic journal/newsletter. Subscriptions are
- available at no cost electronically.
-
- CuD is available as a Usenet newsgroup: comp.society.cu-digest
-
- Or, to subscribe, send a one-line message: SUB CUDIGEST your name
- Send it to LISTSERV@VMD.CSO.UIUC.EDU
- The editors may be contacted by voice (815-753-0303), fax (815-753-6302)
- or U.S. mail at: Jim Thomas, Department of Sociology, NIU, DeKalb, IL
- 60115, USA.
-
- To UNSUB, send a one-line message: UNSUB CUDIGEST
- Send it to LISTSERV@VMD.CSO.UIUC.EDU
- (NOTE: The address you unsub must correspond to your From: line)
-
- Issues of CuD can also be found in the Usenet comp.society.cu-digest
- news group; on CompuServe in DL0 and DL4 of the IBMBBS SIG, DL1 of
- LAWSIG, and DL1 of TELECOM; on GEnie in the PF*NPC RT
- libraries and in the VIRUS/SECURITY library; from America Online in
- the PC Telecom forum under "computing newsletters;"
- On Delphi in the General Discussion database of the Internet SIG;
- on RIPCO BBS (312) 528-5020 (and via Ripco on internet);
- and on Rune Stone BBS (IIRGWHQ) (203) 832-8441.
- CuD is also available via Fidonet File Request from
- 1:11/70; unlisted nodes and points welcome.
-
- EUROPE: In BELGIUM: Virtual Access BBS: +32-69-844-019 (ringdown)
- Brussels: STRATOMIC BBS +32-2-5383119 2:291/759@fidonet.org
- In ITALY: Bits against the Empire BBS: +39-464-435189
- In LUXEMBOURG: ComNet BBS: +352-466893
-
- UNITED STATES: etext.archive.umich.edu (192.131.22.8) in /pub/CuD/
- ftp.eff.org (192.88.144.4) in /pub/Publications/CuD/
- aql.gatech.edu (128.61.10.53) in /pub/eff/cud/
- world.std.com in /src/wuarchive/doc/EFF/Publications/CuD/
- wuarchive.wustl.edu in /doc/EFF/Publications/CuD/
- EUROPE: nic.funet.fi in pub/doc/cud/ (Finland)
- ftp.warwick.ac.uk in pub/cud/ (United Kingdom)
-
- JAPAN: ftp://www.rcac.tdi.co.jp/pub/mirror/CuD
-
- The most recent issues of CuD can be obtained from the
- Cu Digest WWW site at:
- URL: http://www.soci.niu.edu:80/~cudigest/
-
- COMPUTER UNDERGROUND DIGEST is an open forum dedicated to sharing
- information among computerists and to the presentation and debate of
- diverse views. CuD material may be reprinted for non-profit as long
- as the source is cited. Authors hold a presumptive copyright, and
- they should be contacted for reprint permission. It is assumed that
- non-personal mail to the moderators may be reprinted unless otherwise
- specified. Readers are encouraged to submit reasoned articles
- relating to computer culture and communication. Articles are
- preferred to short responses. Please avoid quoting previous posts
- unless absolutely necessary.
-
- DISCLAIMER: The views represented herein do not necessarily represent
- the views of the moderators. Digest contributors assume all
- responsibility for ensuring that articles submitted do not
- violate copyright protections.
-
- ------------------------------
-
- End of Computer Underground Digest #7.02
- ************************************
-
-