home
***
CD-ROM
|
disk
|
FTP
|
other
***
search
/
Internet Info 1997 December
/
Internet_Info_CD-ROM_Walnut_Creek_December_1997.iso
/
ietf
/
oim
/
oim-minutes-90july.txt
< prev
Wrap
Text File
|
1993-02-17
|
4KB
|
151 lines
CURRENT_MEETING_REPORT_
Reported by Brian Handspicker/Digital
OIM Minutes
Agenda
o OIM-MIB-II
o Security Association Policy (CMOT/CMIP)
o MIB/Interoperability Issues
o CMOT Revision/Interoperability Test Presentation
OIM-MIB-II
System Title:
Sysname should be GET-REPLACE but should have a strong health warning
about the inadvisability of changing sysname.
Note, there was some discussion of the ISO/ANSI position that the system
title should be a Distinguished Name (DN). We agreed that once the
Internet defines a containment tree root for Director Services, the OIM
group will define a new attribute for the system object called System ID
(?), which will be a DN. This DN may include as one of its components,
sysname.
One member of the AT&T Bell Labs group raised the concern that NMF uses
OID for system title. This did not get much support.
CREATION/DELETION for Objects Defining Containment Hierarchy:
All okay except TCPConn Entry and UDP Entry need DELETE, but do not need
CREATE.
Progression of OIM-MIB-II to RFC: Questions but no objections.
Proposing OIM-MIB-II as Proposed Standard: No objections.
Add in statement in status: ``This RFC obsoletes MIB definitions
included in RFC 1095 (CMOT)''.
Security:
Need to restrict Masquerade, Modification, Disclosure ANSI X3T5.7---ISO
SC21/WG1---(NIST)OIWNMSIG/SECURITY SIG---O
X.500 Hash Function, Public Key Encryption
1
v---- ROS/CMIP -----------v
+--------------------------------------+
| hash | | | |
+--------------------------------------+
Need coordination in future with NMF. Looking for proposed
solutions/implementations for experimentation.
Association Policy:
Proposed replace existing CMOT/CMIP ACN's with ACN's defined in ISO DIS
10040 (SMO). This means the RFC1095 ACN is no longer defined in the CMOT
revision (though still defined in RFC1095). Also the original new 4 ACN
has been reduced to 3 ACN's: agent, manager and agent-manager. NIST
OIW Association Policy likely to move to Stable Agreement in January
1991.
ACTION: BDH to revise Association Policy
MIB/Interoperability Issues:
MSI requires MIBS to be defined such that OSI SMI and IETF mappings,
attributes and objects (?) are defined. This places a requirement
either on all the MIB definition groups or on OIM for these mappings.
Fiction: BDH, Lee, etc., to provide the How To Write A MIB document by
the next meeting.
ACTION: Lee to define appendices to FDDI MIB, etc., with OSI SMI
Mappings for MIBS.
CMOT Revision Interoperability Testing Presentation
Repeated presentation of the plenary presentation. Announced intent to
hold another round of Interoperability testing. U.C. London suggested
as another potential participant. Four of the participants supporting
RFC1095 Revision replacement as Draft Standard. No one objected to its
replacement as Draft Standard. CMOT/CMIP 1095 Revision based on NIST
OIW IA's.
GDMO Templates
Need tools for converting IETF SMI MO definitions to ISO SMI and vice
versa. Jeff Case suggested that his research project may be able to
provide public domain tools for this.
System Management Functions
2
Lee to distribute NIST OIW proposed implementors agreements for System
Management Functions. Proposed OIM based SMF IA's on these OIW IA's.
Attendees
Jonathan Biggar jon@netlabs.com
Yvonne Biggar yvonne@cam.unisys.com
Theodore Brunner tob@thumper.bellcore.com
Jeffrey Buffum jbuffum@apollo.hp.com
Jeffrey Case case@utkux1.utk.edu
Asheem Chandna ac0@mtuxo.att.com
Mike Erlinger mike@mti.com
Chris Gunner gunner@osicwg.enet.dec.com
Brian Handspicker bd@vines.enet.dec.com
Alex Koifman akoifman@bbn.com
Lee LaBarre cel@mbunix.mitre.org
Don McWilliam
Alan Menezes afm@cup.portal.com
Lynn Monsanto
Oscar Newkerk newkerk@decwet.dec.com
Jim Reinstedler jimr@ub.com
Harvey Shapiro shapira@wnyosi2.arpa
Jim Sheridan jsherida@ibm.com
Mark Sleeper mws@sparta.com
Sudhanshu Verma verma@hpindbu.cup.hp.com
Justin Walker justin@apple.com
Denis Yaro DYARO@SUN.COM
3