AmigaOS3.5 (241/968)

From:Xavier Messersmith
Date:9 Jan 2000 at 22:59:51
Subject:Re: MUI, having nothing to do with OS3.5

From: Xavier Messersmith <xcaliber@xav.to>

On 09-Jan-00, Uffe Holst wrote:
> In a message of 09-Jan-00 Xavier Messersmith wrote:
>> Kinda rude to not release revisions of something that a few people have paid
>> for. (even if some people hate it)
>
> Most programmers release betas to a closed group of people and not to the
> general public. This is the general approach and I can't see why it is
> rude.

I'm aware of the beta approach, however, after a few years of testing the next
step in the cycle is to release the product. And from what I read it
apparently skipped one release and jumped straight into the next beta. This
would be so annoying if MUI wasn't using the keyfile/continual upgrade
approach to distribution.

>> Its a shame that every internet program out there requires this program.
>> Especially since a custom GUI would be better sutied to alot of these
>> applications. (and that custom GUI probably wouldn't be so unstable too)
>
> I very much disagree with this. The more applications that uses MUI the
> better.

*SHUDDER*

> MUI is very powerful and offers me configurability to an extend
> that most probably wouldn't be reached by any custom GUI.

Is not MUI a custom GUI itsself? So how can a custom GUI not surpass MUI?

> Likewise it is
> a benefit to the users that all MUI applications uses the same interface
> for configuring the GUI - custom GUI's would have to be configured in
> different ways.

But would they need to be configured as often? I don't like the generic
super-GUI approach MUI has.

> Personally I find MUI to be one of the most important items on our
> platform.

As I find it the buggiest.
(next to the new icon.library, but I'll spare you the details. ;-)

> And a side note: I have absolutely no problems with instability and MUI.
> The only regular crashes that I experience is in my opinion contributed to
> Voyager and not in any way to MUI.

Look again.



__ /\ /\__ /\ : xav2@xav.to
__ //// /\ /\/\ / / _\ / /\ | http://www.xav.to
\\\/// __ \/ \/ / \/ __ \ | A-2000 39M 030/882/50
\\/ \/ \/\/\/\/\/ \__/\/ \/ : A-3000 10M 030/882/25

--------------------------- ONElist Sponsor ----------------------------

Hey Freelancers: Find your next project through JobSwarm!
You can even make money in your sleep by referring friends.
<a href=" http://clickme.onelist.com/ad/jobswarm1 ">Click Here</a>

------------------------------------------------------------------------