The Question
(Submitted June 05, 1997)
It is my understanding that observation of x-rays have been
used in the past in the search for black holes. I have been
trying to find out whether there has been any reasonable
evidence found for their existence. Having glanced through
numerous out of date texts on the subject, it seems people
are unwilling to say one way or another.
If there is any generally accepted evidence I would be most
grateful if you could let me know.
The Answer
Here are WWW pages that show some X-ray evidence for black holes:
http://lheawww.gsfc.nasa.gov/users/nandra/pubs/paper2/figure.html
http://lheawww.gsfc.nasa.gov/users/turner/agn_reproc.html
http://lheawww.gsfc.nasa.gov/users/ptak/agn/liner_llagn.html
You may also want to revisit Imagine the Universe! at:
http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov
In addition to the discussions of black holes and x-ray astronomy you will
find there, check out the archive of past 'Ask a High-Energy Astronomer'
questions and answers. Many of those under 'black holes' are relevant to
your question.
There is now a strong consensus that black holes are present in the
Universe, both small ones associated with stars in binary systems (Cygnus X-1
is a convincing candidate, for example) and much larger ones in the centers
of many galaxies (including our own). The best lines of evidence are
currently coming from determinations of the masses of non-stellar perturbing
objects from their effects on the motions of stars (measured from Doppler shiftss in their spectra). In many cases the unseen perturbing object is so
massive that it is hard not to conclude that it is a black hole.
As an indication of how rapidly the evidence is accumulating, only a couple
of hours ago NASA issued a Press Release on recent results from the New
Hubble Instruments. Here's an extract:
BEAM FROM A BLACK HOLE
The imaging spectrograph, which just last month demonstrated
its efficiency as a black hole hunter, now shows the results when
the power of a black hole is unleashed into its surrounding
environment. In a single observation, the spectrograph measured
the velocities of hundreds of gas blobs caught up in a twin-cone
beam of radiation emanating from a supermassive black hole at the
core of galaxy NGC 4151. Follow-up observations reveal hot gas
emanating from deep within the throat of the beam, near the
vicinity of the black hole. These observations also allow
scientists to map the mass outflows near the black hole. The
surprisingly complex motion may offer clues to the galaxy's
stellar population, the orientation of the beam in the past, or
evidence of some kind of backflow of gas into the central cone
regions.
For pictures see:
http://oposite.stsci.edu/pubinfo/Pictures.html
Best wishes,
Paul Butterworth and Andy Ptak
for the 'Ask a High-Energy Astronomer' team
|