|
The Question
(Submitted April 08, 1997)
What are some substances not found on earth but are found on
other planets, or comets?
The Answer
There are two basic answers to your question:
I.
If you are asking about Elements or Isotopes that are found in space,
but not found naturally on Earth, there are many: In the center of
stars and after supernova explosions many isotopes and elements are
created. Some of these are radioactive, which means that they are
unstable and will turn into other elements over time. Now, all the
material that made the Earth and solar system (except hydrogen and
helium) was created in stars and supernovae. However, that was a long
time ago, so the radioactive elements have mostly already turned into
stable elements.
When we observe supernovae, we see the signature of these elements
decaying. So, we know they exist out there -- but not here.
II.
Now, if you are asking about chemical compounds in our solar system
that are found on other planets but not here, that is another
question. Some substances are abundant on some planets but scarce on
others. For example, water is abundant on Earth, but scarce on most
other planets.
Your question, on the other hand, is about stuff that does not exist
naturally here at all, but does exist naturally off of earth. To
answer this, I asked a colleague here at NASA/Goddard Space Flight
Center who is a chemist (Dr. Susan Hallenbeck).
She writes:
"Some gases exist in the hydrogen rich environments of the gas
giants (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune) such as silane (SiH4),
arsine (AsH3), and phosphine (PH3) which do not occur naturally on
Earth but can be easily produced in the laboratory."
"Also, there are some highly oxidized compounds in the top layers of
the Martian soil, which again do not occur naturally on Earth but can
be easily produced in the laboratory."
Thank you for your interest.
Jonathan Keohane
-- for Imagine the Universe!
Questions on this topic are no longer responded to by the "Ask a
High-Energy Astronomer" service. See http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/ask_an_astronomer.html
for help on other astronomy Q&A services.
| 
