home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- January 4, 1988Man of the YearThe Education of Mikhail Sergeyevich Gorbachev
-
-
-
- An intimate biography of the private man
-
-
- Officials of the Zavorovo state farm near Moscow had prepared
- carefully for the big day last August. They had even built a
- special staircase to spare their distinguished visitor the
- indignity of climbing down a hill to the potato fields below the
- main road. Mikhail Gorbachev would have none of it. Stepping
- out of his ZIL limousine, he gave the staircase a dismissive
- wave and scrambled down the steep incline in his neatly pressed
- gray business suit, leaving his surprised entourage to run after
- him in full view of television cameras.
-
- At the bottom of the hill, Gorbachev asked the farmers, lined
- up beside their equipment like soldiers on parade, about the
- mood on the farm. "Good. Businesslike," came the replies.
- Gorbachev was not satisfied. "I always hear the same answer,"
- he said. "[But] there are always problems." For example, he
- asked, was everything available "except for vodka," a teasing
- reference to his antialcoholism campaign. Well, no, one farmer
- mumbled. It was the season for making jams and jellies, and
- sugar was scarce. Gorbachev shot back: Do you know why?
- Moonshiners are buying up all the sugar to make home brew.
- "Let's talk straight with one another," said the leader. "Isn't
- it time to bring the making of moonshine to an end? That sort
- of people belong back in the times when the dinosaurs lived."
-
- That exchange was typical of the Gorbachev style, a remarkably
- Western mix of charm and sermonizing. The effect was apparent
- during the December summit with Ronald Reagan. Alternately
- jovial and argumentative, combining sharp intelligence with a
- homey touch and playing to the camera in the most effective
- way--by seeming to ignore it--he came across as a Kremlin
- version of the Great Communicator. Add an attractive,
- strong-willed wife, and the picture of an American-style
- politician is complete.
-
- Also misleading. In most of his views, Gorbachev is a
- thoroughly Soviet, obdurately Communist figure. When he speaks
- of "democracy," as he incessantly does, he does not mean
- anything Thomas Jefferson would have recognized; he promotes
- freer discussion within the Communist Party only as a substitute
- for the political opposition he makes clear he will not
- tolerate. If he voices criticism of Soviet society, it is
- because that system has in his view strayed from the ideals of
- Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, the founder of the Soviet state and
- Gorbachev's idol. And although he argues frequently for a new
- relationship with the U.S., he seems to have an odd conception
- of America as a Dickensian hell ruled by the
- military-industrial complex.
-
- The contradictions in his personality are enough to raise a
- question: Who exactly is Mikhail Sergeyevich Gorbachev? It is
- not an easy question to answer: unhappily, glasnost does not
- yet extend to the life of its author. One reason, no doubt, is
- his wariness about encouraging a "cult of personality"--the
- euphemism for glorification of an all-powerful leader, which
- reached sickening heights under Joseph Stalin in Gorbachev's
- student days and is thus associated in Soviet minds with
- Stalin's terror. Gorbachev has reacted to incipient hagiography
- in the Soviet press by being tight-lipped about his private
- life. Subordinates take their cue from the boss. A high
- official mentioned to a group of foreigners recently that he
- had known the General Secretary as a university student. "What
- was Gorbachev like in those days?" the man asked. He paused
- reflectively, smiled and said, "I don't remember."
-
- Gorbachev's official biography is little more than a bare-bones
- list of Communist Party offices held, and it lacks some of the
- most elementary information. For example, it is not known for
- certain whether he has any siblings. Some Soviets say he has
- a brother who works in agriculture, but no one seems to know the
- man's name or age. Reports of a sister cannot be confirmed.
-
- From a variety of sources, however, TIME has pieced together a
- detailed, though still incomplete, picture of Gorbachev's early
- days and his rise to command. The story begins in Privolnoye,
- a farming village (pop. 3,000) in the south of the Russian
- republic, 124 miles from the city of Stavropol. A one-story
- brick cottage with a small kitchen, three rooms and a pleasant
- garden plot still stands there: Gorbachev was born in that house
- on March 2, 1931.
-
- It was a time of bloodshed and terror. Stalin's drive to force
- Soviet peasants into collective farms was at its height. Those
- who resisted were deported or shot. Peasants destroyed animals
- rather than let them be confiscated by the collectives. That
- slaughter, along with the Soviet government's oppressive
- requisitions of grain from the newly formed collective farms,
- created a man-made famine that was raging when Gorbachev was
- born. Millions eventually died.
-
- The Gorbachev family probably avoided the worst of the
- suffering: it was on the winning side. Mikhail's grandfather
- Andrei helped organize the Khleborob (bread producer) collective
- farm in the year of Gorbachev's birth. Andrei's son Sergei
- drove a combine for a nearby government machine-tractor station.
- But Mikhail could hardly have helped hearing tales of the
- disruption that continued during his infancy. As General
- Secretary, Gorbachev has defended the collectivization and even
- the repression of the kulaks (well-off peasants), who were
- deported or executed as class enemies. But perhaps because of
- boyhood memories, he has criticized the brutality shown to a
- less prosperous group, the so-called middle peasants. A
- classmate remembers that as a college student after Stalin's
- death, Gorbachev spoke of a middle-peasant relative who had been
- arrested and, the classmate assumes, shot.
-
- Not long after the turmoil over collectivization died down in
- the mid-1930s, the Soviet Union was hit by the second trauma of
- Gorbachev's boyhood: the Nazi invasion. Mikhail was eleven
- years old when German tanks rumbled into nearby Stavropol at the
- start of what became the Stalingrad campaign. Hitler's troops
- stayed in the area for almost six months before being driven out
- by the Red Army. In all probability, though, the Nazis would not
- have bothered to occupy a village as small as Privolnoye, so
- Gorbachev seems to have escaped the worst rigors of the war.
- Only in 1950, when he traveled north to university in Moscow,
- did he apparently become fully aware of the destruction visited
- on his homeland. He has said that on that 800-mile train ride,
- he saw "the ruined Stalingrad, Rostov, Kharkov and Voronezh.
- And how many such ruined cities there were...Everything lay in
- ruins: hundreds and thousands of cities, towns and villages,
- factories and mills."
-
- Even earlier, though, the war touched young Mikhail. In
- Privolnoye, as in thousands of other villages and towns in the
- U.S.S.R., there is an eternal flame and a monument to those who
- lost their lives in what Soviets call the Great Patriotic War.
- The name Gorbachev appears on the memorial seven times, though
- it is not certain which of his relatives are meant. His father
- Sergei was conscripted and fought a the front for four years,
- during which "Misha" (the common Russian nickname for Mikhail)
- must have spent much time alone with his mother Maria
- Panteleyevna Gorbachev. In a recent interview on Soviet TV, she
- recalled that at one period during the war Gorbachev could not
- go to school for several months because he had no shoes. Sergei
- wrote home urging Maria Panteleyevna to sell anything she could
- and buy shoes because "Misha must go to school." Maria
- Panteleyevna, now well into her 70s and a widow (Sergei died in
- 1976), continues to live in Privolnoye.
-
- Growing up in a farming village, Gorbachev was introduced early
- to hard work. As a young boy, he probably accompanied his
- combine- driver father into the fields. At 14 he was driving
- a combine himself after school and during the summers. It was
- a hot and sweaty job in that part of the Soviet Union, where
- summer temperatures reach well into the 90s, and the combines
- had no cabins. After a few minutes the driver would be
- surrounded by a cloud of grain chaff and dust that made
- breathing difficult. In winter it was so cold that Gorbachev
- had to wrap himself in straw to keep from freezing. He stood
- it well enough to be awarded the Order of the Red Banner of
- Labor in 1949, a rare honor for an 18-year-old. The award, his
- impeccable political credentials--peasant background, gather
- and grandfather Communist Party members--and the silver medal
- he received upon graduation from high school as second in his
- class all helped him win a place at Moscow State University in
- the fall of 1950.
-
- Gorbachev was already showing wide-ranging intellectual
- curiosity. "I cannot even say for which subjects I felt a
- special interest in school," he told an Italian interviewer much
- later. "At the outset I wanted to enter the physics faculty [of
- Moscow State University]. I liked mathematics a lot, but I also
- liked history and literature. To this day I can recite by heart
- poetry that I learned at school." He lacked the entrance
- requirements to pursue science courses, so he decided to study
- law.
-
- The choice was unconventional. Law in those Stalinist days had
- no prestige; it was even despised by many Soviets. The task of
- a lawyer was to find rationalizations for the state to crush its
- opponents. Nonetheless, Gorbachev's classes did expose him to
- a wider range of ideas than he would have encountered pursuing
- a science curriculum. Like all other Soviet students, Gorbachev
- was drilled in Marxism- Leninism, and learned minute details
- about the life of Stalin. But as a law student he took classes
- in the history of political ideas and studied the works of
- Thomas Aquinas, Hobbes, Locke and Machiavelli. Gorbachev also
- studied Latin. Several classes were taught by professors who
- had somehow managed to survive from prerevolutionary days.
-
- When he began his studies, the adulation of Stalin, "the
- greatest genius of all times and peoples," was at its height,
- and the earnest young provincial was not immune to it. "He,
- like everyone else at the time, was a Stalinist," says Zdenek
- Mlynar, a Czech who studied law at Moscow State University and
- later became a top party official in his homeland. But
- Gorbachev displayed a streak of hardheaded realism about Soviet
- life. He and Mlynar once watched a propaganda movie, Cossacks
- of the Kuban, picturing happy peasants at tables groaning with
- food. "It's not like that at all," grumbled Gorbachev, who
- remembered hunger in his home region. Mlynar adds that "when
- we were studying collective-farm law, Gorbachev explained to me
- how insignificant collective-farm legislation was in day-to-day
- life and how important, on the other had, was brute force, which
- alone secured working discipline on the collective farms."
-
- Fridrikh Neznansky, another fellow law student and now a Soviet
- emigre, recalls that Gorbachev even then displayed a veneration
- for Lenin going well beyond what was demanded of Soviet
- students. He was especially impressed, Neznansky says, by
- Lenin's doctrine of "one step forward, two steps back"--in other
- words, the ability to maneuver and to retreat if necessary while
- pursuing a goal. Tactical flexibility has been a hallmark of
- Gorbachev's career ever since. "In politics and ideology, we are
- seeking to revive the spirit of Leninism," Gorbachev writes in
- his recently published book, Perestroika. "Many decades of
- being mesmerized by dogma, by a rule- book approach, have had
- their effect. Today we want to introduce a genuinely creative
- spirit into our theoretical work." The first faint glimmerings
- of glasnost might also be discerned in Gorbachev's law-school
- attitudes. Mlynar remembers that students were taught to regard
- anyone who dissented from the Stalinist line as a criminal.
- Gorbachev, however, remarked to his Czech classmate: "But Lenin
- did not order the arrest of Martov [leader of the Mensheviks,
- a socialist splinter group]. He allowed him to leave the
- country."
-
- Outside class, students led a grim existence. Gorbachev spent
- the first three of his student years in the shabby Stromynka
- student hostel, an 18th century former barracks that housed
- 10,000 young people packed eight or more to a room. There was
- a kitchen and a washroom on each floor, but no proper bathing
- facilities. Gorbachev and his roommates would head to a public
- bathhouse twice a month. They stored their personal belongings
- in suitcases under the beds. Many of the youths could not even
- afford tea. Instead, they drank "student tea," a concoction of
- hot water and sugar. THe favorite diversion was foreign movies,
- most of them captured by the Red Army from German forces and
- shown in the "culture club" on the main floor. Johnny
- Weissmuller's Tarzan movies were most popular. After one such
- epic show, the Stromynka hostel would resound with jungle whoops
- by the students.
-
- In this maelstrom, Gorbachev somehow found time and privacy for
- romance. Male and female students lived on the same floors,
- though they had separate sleeping and bathroom facilities.
- Gorbachev and his roommates drew up a complicated schedule
- guaranteeing each of them one hour alone in the room every week
- to entertain a female guest. On the hall bulletin board, the
- periods of privacy were discreetly designated "cleaning hours."
-
- One of the women down the hall from Gorbachev was Raisa
- Maximovna Titorenko, a bright, popular philosophy student a year
- younger than he. Mlynar recalls that Mikhail initially had a
- good deal of competition for her attention, but the two
- eventually began seeing each other regularly. The were married
- early in 1954. The couple celebrated the occasion modestly with
- 30 or so other students at a party in the corner of the
- dormitory eating hall, then went to Gorbachev's room for their
- weeding night. Gorbachev's roommates had arranged to stay away.
- The following day, however, they drifted back, and Raisa
- returned to her room. The couple did not live together until
- several months later, when they obtained married- student
- accommodations in the newly completed 34-story main building of
- Moscow State University.
-
- Though Gorbachev was trained as a lawyer, he has never
- practices; his main interest from his earliest days at Moscow
- State University was politics. Even before leaving Privolnoye,
- he had joined the Komsomol, the youth league that people ages
- 14 to 28 pass through in preparation for joining the Communist
- Party. Armed with a glowing recommendation from the Stavropol
- committee, he became a Komsomol organizer at the Moscow State
- University law school in 1952 and simultaneously, at 21, a
- member of the party proper. He was assigned to a working-class
- area of Moscow for propaganda activity and the handling of
- constituents' complaints, while continuing his Komsomol work at
- the university.
-
- Those who knew Gorbachev as a young party activist agree that
- he was a true believer among cynical careerists. He had some
- reservations about particular policies, but when he spouted the
- Stalinist line of the moment, he did so with evident conviction.
- Lev Yudovich, who graduated two years ahead of Gorbachev,
- recalls having the young ideologue pointed out to him as someone
- to fear. There was reason to be wary of him: Neznansky asserts
- that when Gorbachev discovered that some fellow students had
- parents who were in political disgrace, he called for their
- expulsion from the Komsomol and perhaps from the university as
- well. Michel Tatu, a prominent French Kremlinologist and author
- of a forthcoming biography of Gorbachev, is convinced that he
- joined in the vicious anti-Semitic rhetoric of Stalin's last
- purge, launched just before the dictator's death in early 1953.
- Mlynar does not deny that, but he insists that Gorbachev
- steered clear of any individual persecutions.
-
- By 1955, the year of Gorbachev's graduation, the Stalinist ice
- had broken in the Soviet Union, Nikita Khrushchev had taken over
- and was winding down the terror. Ghostly figures began drifting
- back into Moscow from the labor camps. But at the start of this
- period of ferment and change, Gorbachev removed himself and
- Raisa from the relative sophistication of Moscow and returned
- to the Stavropol area, where he was to stay for the next 23
- years. According to Neznansky, the young graduate tried for a
- position with the Moscow Komsomol apparatus but lost out to a
- classmate and had little choice but to return to the provinces
- if he wanted to continue a career in party politics. It may be
- too that Gorbachev felt an obligation to the Stavropol Krai
- (territory) authorities, who had apparently paid part of his
- university expenses, or that he was simply homesick.
-
- In any event, the Stavropol period remains the most obscure of
- Gorbachev's life. It is known that he rose fast, from a minor
- job in the local Komsomol to its first secretary after less than
- a year, then through a variety of Komsomol and, later, party
- jobs. By 1962, when he was only 31, he was choosing party
- members for promotion throughout Stavropol Krai. Finally in
- 1970, at the age of 39, he became first secretary of the
- territory, a job equivalent to governor of an area roughly the
- size of South Carolina, with about 2.4 million people. Along
- the way, he became a specialist in farming, the main activity
- of the area. He took correspondence courses from Stavropol
- Agricultural Institute, and in 1967 added a degree in
- agriculture to his Moscow law degree. Soviet emigres and
- Stavropol residents provide some intriguing glimpses of
- Gorbachev on his way up the party apparat.
-
- Gorbachev showed an avid interest in the press. Vladimir
- Maximov, a writer now living in Paris who worked for a Stavropol
- Komsomol newspaper in the 1950s, recalls that the young official
- often visited the paper's offices for a chat. "He would sit
- down with us in a casual manner," says Maximov. "We would
- uncork a bottle of wine [for all his antialcoholism campaigning,
- Gorbachev still enjoys an occasional drink] and usually talk
- politics. Khrushchev's report on the crimes of the Stalinist
- era had recently appeared. The entire country was still reeling
- from shock." Maximov and others of Gorbachev's generation,
- however, remember the late 1950s as an exciting time.
- Khrushchev's secret speech denouncing Stalin at the 20th
- Communist Party Congress in 1956 briefly opened the way to a
- much freer atmosphere. It was false dawn. Repression resumed
- a few years later. To this day, however, educated SOviets of
- Gorbachev's generation, whose political attitudes were formed
- then and who are now moving into positions of power, sometimes
- refer to themselves as "children of the 20th Congress."
-
- Gorbachev's interest in the press continued throughout the
- Stavropol period. As party boss of the area, he often met with
- regional journalists for talks similar to those he now holds in
- Moscow with the national press. Unlike other party officials,
- he would stress that it was not enough for the journalists to
- write articles that were ideologically correct; they also had
- to be interesting. "Is anyone reading what you write?" he would
- ask.
-
- Gorbachev remained open and accessible to his constituents. He
- usually set out on foot for his job each morning.
- Stavropolitans quickly learned that they could avoid having to
- make a formal appointment at Gorbachev's office on Lenin Square
- by buttonholing him on his walk up Dzerzhinsky Street and
- discussing their problems then. He also began in Stavropol Krai
- the walkabouts that were later to cause a national sensation
- when he continued the practice as General Secretary. On a visit
- to a village in the Izobilnynsky district, he heard from an
- indignant mother of six children how the manager of a state
- store had treated her rudely. The storekeeper was fired.
- Gorbachev showed some independence from Moscow when he was
- Stavropol party boss. Turned down for state financing of a
- permanent circus building, he solicited funds from local
- organizations and institutions and got the building put up
- anyway.
-
- The Gorbachevs relieved the monotony of provincial life with
- several trips to Western Europe, Mikhail traveling as a member
- of party delegations visiting foreign Communists and Raisa once
- or twice accompanying him. On the first trip, in 1966,
- Gorbachev later recalled, the couple rented a Renault and spent
- several weeks driving 3,400 miles through the length and breadth
- of France, with a side trip to Italy.
-
- Was Gorbachev getting restless with provincial posts? Perhaps.
- Mlynar, who was rising toward the top level of the Czech
- Communist Party, visited his old classmate in 1967 and recalls
- that Gorbachev complained about excessive interference by Moscow
- in local affairs. Mlynar described the sweeping reforms that
- Alexander Dubcek was then beginning in Czechoslovakia. He
- remembers Gorbachev saying, with a sign, "Perhaps there are
- possibilities in Czechoslovakia because conditions are
- different." The Czech reforms, however, were crushed by Soviet
- tanks the following year, and Mlynar went into exile; he now
- lives in Austria. The two old friends talked and drank through
- that afternoon and deep into the night. When they finally
- returned to Gorbachev's apartment, much the worse for wear,
- Raisa was furious.
-
- Just how Gorbachev rose out of provincial obscurity is still
- somewhat mysterious. As late as 1978, few outside Stavropol
- Krai had ever heard of him. The best answer seems to be that
- he attracted a number of powerful patrons. The first was Fyodor
- Kulakov, who as party boss in Stavropol first spotted Gorbachev
- as having great promise. After Kulakov became Agriculture
- Secretary for the entire Soviet Union, Gorbachev eventually
- succeeded him in Stavropol--and Kulakov apparently made sure his
- protege became known in Moscow. In 1977 the "Ipatovsky method,"
- a new technique of harvesting grain quickly by using flying
- squads of combines, was judged a smashing success. The idea was
- probably Kulakov's, but it was first tried in the district of
- Ipatovsky, in Stavropol Krai, under Gorbachev's supervision.
- The young regional politician was accorded the honor of an
- interview on the front page of Pravda, his first taste of
- national publicity.
-
- Geography gave Gorbachev a mighty assist too. Christian
- Schmidt- Hauer, a West German journalist and biographer,
- observes that if Gorbachev had been party chief in, say,
- Murmansk in the far north, he would never have become General
- Secretary. But in Stavropol Krai, he was on hand to welcome top
- Moscow officials who came to the local spas at Mineralnye Vody
- and Kislovodsk for vacations and medical treatment. They found
- their host unusual in several respects. Says Soviet Historian
- Roy Medvedev: "A regional party first secretary who was
- intelligent and congenial would have been considered untypical.
- If Gorbachev had yelled, sworn, been a heavy drinker or a high
- liver with a rest house outside of town where officials could
- be entertained by pretty waitresses, that would have been
- considered normal behavior."
-
- Gorbachev was not like that at all. He was a quiet and pleasant
- host with a reputation throughout the district for
- incorruptibility. Writer Maximov relates a story about a mutual
- friend, a poet, who asked Gorbachev as a young Komsomol official
- to help him buy a Volga sedan. Gorbachev obligingly used his
- influence to speed delivery. The poet promptly sold the car on
- the black market and returned to ask Gorbachev for help in
- buying another. Says Maximov: "Gorbachev did not usually lose
- his temper, but on that occasion he started shouting and threw
- the poet out of his office, ordering him never to show his face
- there again."
-
- The young party chief's reputation pleased two important spa
- guests: Mikhail Suslov, then the chief Soviet ideologist, and
- KGB Chief Yuri Andropov, both austere figures disgusted by the
- corruption of the Brezhnev era. When Kulakov died in 1978, he
- left vacant the position of Communist Party Central Committee
- Secretary in charge of agriculture. To fill it, General
- Secretary Leonid Brezhnev, presumably acting on the advice of
- Suslov and Andropov, chose a man he had evidently met only
- recently: Gorbachev. That meeting occurred on Sept. 19, 1978,
- at the tiny railroad station in Mineralnye Vody, where
- Brezhnev's train stopped for a brief time. In one of the more
- remarkable moments in Soviet history, four men who were all to
- serve as General Secretary found themselves on the same narrow
- station platform: Brezhnev; Andropov, who had come over from
- the nearby spa and in 1982 would succeed Brezhnev; Konstantin
- Chernenko, then Brezhnev's chief aide and in 1984 Andropov's
- successor; and Gorbachev, who would take over from Chernenko as
- General Secretary the following year. Less than a month after
- that gathering, Gorbachev was plucked out of Stavropol to
- become, at 47, a member of the national hierarchy, ranking 20th
- among all Soviet leaders.
-
- How he leaped from there to No. 1 in only seven more years is
- another question still not fully answered. Certainly his rise
- was not attributable to any glittering success in agriculture.
- Quite the opposite: the grain harvest fell from a record 230
- million tons in 1978, when Gorbachev was taking over the
- agriculture portfolio, to a calamitous total of perhaps only 155
- million tons in 1981. Bad weather played a role. So did
- Brezhnev, who announced a grandiose reorganization of
- agriculture that seemed to create more problems than it solved.
- Still, it is remarkable that Gorbachev managed not only to
- escape blame but to advance his career amid the farming fiasco.
- Only a year after returning to Moscow, he became a candidate
- member of the Politburo. The following year, at 49, he was made
- a full member. Gorbachev was eight years younger than the next
- youngest Politburo member and 21 years younger than the average
- age of his colleagues.
-
- One reason Gorbachev's agriculture record was not held against
- him was imply that the Kremlin leadership found itself in
- desperate need of new blood. Brezhnev's health was faltering,
- and his 18-year regime was sinking into a twilight of stagnation
- and corruption. When Brezhnev died in 1982 and Andropov came
- into office with plans for reform, he immediately began grooming
- Gorbachev to become a key lieutenant in his clean-up campaign.
-
- Gorbachev was already preparing himself for national
- leadership. While still in charge of farming, he gathered Soviet
- academic experts for a series f seminars held sometimes in the
- Central Committee offices, sometimes in a dacha outside Moscow.
- The sessions started with problems of agriculture but quickly
- developed into freewheeling discussions of what was wrong with
- the economy in general and how it might be fixed. Among the
- participants were Economists Abel Aganbegyan, who had been
- urging decentralization and a wider role for market incentives
- since the mid-1960s, and Tatyana Zaslavskaya, a leading
- sociologist. Zaslavskaya recalls one encounter with Gorbachev:
- "I sat next to him. It is incredible what power and drive
- emanate from him. One feels as if it were a strong field of
- energy. His vitality is extraordinary, and yet, although you
- feel this tension, he is a good listener and waits for you to
- finish."
-
- The rising Kremlin star got a firsthand look at how far the
- Soviet economy had fallen behind the West's. When Gorbachev
- joined the national hierarchy, he was already well traveled by
- comparison with such other Soviet leaders at Andropov. who never
- set foot outside the Communist world, and Suslov, who reportedly
- once told a visa applicant that he saw no reason why anyone
- would want to journey beyond he U.S.S.R.
-
- As a Politburo member Gorbachev in 1983 headed a Soviet
- agricultural delegation on a visit to Canada and spent ten days
- poking around farms, processing plants and supermarkets. At one
- cattle ranch, he asked to see "some of the workers." The
- rancher replied that there were none; he ran the spread of
- several hundred acres with only his family and handful of day
- laborers. A Canadian host who speaks Russian heard Gorbachev
- mutter under his breath, "We are not going to see this [in the
- Soviet Union] for another 50 years." Eugene Whelan, then
- Minister of Agriculture and Gorbachev's official host, was
- surprised on another occasion to hear the Soviet leader comment
- about the invasion of Afghanistan: "It was a mistake." (He was
- later to call Afghanistan a "bleeding wound," but in public he
- still justifies the invasion.) In the same year, however,
- Gorbachev served on a Politburo crisis-management subgroup that
- sought to justify the Soviet downing of a Korean Air Lines
- passenger jet by asserting that the plane had been on a spying
- mission for the U.S.
-
- By the time a fatal kidney ailment cut short Andropov's tenure
- in early 1984, Gorbachev was already a candidate to succeed his
- former mentor. At Andropov's funeral, Gorbachev made a telling
- gesture of his closeness to the late General Secretary: he was
- the only Politburo member publicly to console Andropov's
- bereaved widow Tatyana. But the Old Guard made a final stand,
- choosing Chernenko instead. Gorbachev went along, and even
- agreed to make the nominating speech. He probably knew his turn
- would come soon enough. Ailing and 72, Chernenko was not going
- to last long. In fact, through much of his year in power
- Chernenko was so ill that Gorbachev, his principal deputy, in
- effect ran the country.
-
- Even so, he had opposition. Grigori Romanov, the hard-line
- former Leningrad party boss who was once thought be Gorbachev's
- chief rival, had apparently given up on winning the top job for
- himself. But at the Politburo session called immediately after
- Chernenko's death, Romanov reportedly tried a stop-Gorbachev
- maneuver, nominating Moscow Party Boss Viktor Grishin for
- General Secretary. By some accounts, however, KGB Chief Viktor
- Chebrikov hinted that his agency had compiled dossiers on the
- corruption in the moscow party apparatus that could be highly
- embarrassing to Grishin. (Chebrikov was then a candidate member
- of the Politburo; he has since moved up to full membership.)
- Andrei Gromyko, then Foreign Minister, carried the day with a
- nominating speech for Gorbachev during which he coined the now
- celebrated remark, "This man has a nice smile, but he has iron
- teeth." Gromyko's speech was surprising in two respects: it
- appears to have been improvised, and it contained none of the
- lengthy recitation of the hero's accomplishments traditional on
- such occasions. Gromyko appeared to be saying: this man has
- not really done all that much yet, but he is still the best we
- have.
-
- Gorbachev had been in power only a month when he roamed around
- the industrial Proletarsky district of Moscow, visiting
- supermarkets, chatting with workers at the Likhachyov truck
- factory, discussing computer training with teachers at School
- No. 514 and nurses' pay with the staff of City Hospital No. 53.
- He even dropped into a young couple's apartment for tea. That
- was the first of the walkabouts that have taken him, sometimes
- accompanied by Raisa, from Murmansk in the north to Kamchatka
- on the shores of the Pacific. On several of his tours he has
- displayed an easy informality and an almost impish distaste for
- ceremonial oratory. Entering the hall of the Starnikovsky Farm
- near Moscow to talk to livestock breeders last summer, he veered
- away from the row of seats on the tribunal and perched on the
- edge of the table so that he could be closer to the crowd. In
- October, at the Baltic Shipyards in Leningrad, a spokesman for
- the workers began a monotone welcoming speech expressing a wish
- that perestroika would develop even faster. Gorbachev
- interrupted with playful cries of "Davai! Davai!" (Let's go
- to it!), drawing a big laugh from the crowd.
-
- Gorbachev has an apartment in central Moscow, but lives most of
- the time in a closed and guarded area of single-family mansions
- on the western outskirts of the city. From there he is driven
- downtown daily at 9 a.m. in a four-ZIL motorcade: one car for
- himself; two for aides and bodyguards, and a heavily curtained
- vehicle bristling with antennas that is assumed to carry the
- coding equipment for launching nuclear weapons. His main office
- is on the fifth floor of the Central committee headquarters, a
- quarter of a mile from the Kremlin; he also maintains an office
- in a building just behind the Lenin Mausoleum and the Kremlin
- wall, but he uses it mostly to receive visitors. He usually
- returns home at about 6 p.m. in another motorcade. Extra
- traffic police are stationed along Kutuzovsky Prospekt to clear
- the central lanes for the four limousines. He stays downtown
- late only when there is some special ceremonial function or
- when, as often happens, the regular Thursday Politburo meeting
- runs into the evening.
-
- While Gorbachev's working schedule does not seem to be overly
- taxing, he recently answered an Italian interviewer's question
- as to how he spends his free time by saying simply, "I have
- none." He is, however, an avid theatergoer. In Stavropol he
- and Raisa attended not only every play that opened but also many
- dress rehearsals. In Moscow, while preparing for the Washington
- summit, they found time to take in The Peace of Brest, a
- historical drama about Lenin's early years in power that opened
- Nov. 30.
-
- The Gorbachevs have a daughter Irina, 28, who is a physician
- and married to another doctor, and two known grandchildren. The
- extent to which the Gorbachevs guard their family privacy can
- be gauged by some of the things that are not know for sure:
- Irina's married name (only the first name of her husband,
- Anatoli, has been disclosed); the granddaughter's name (it has
- been reported as both Oksana and Xenia); her age (probably
- seven); and the sex and name of a second grandchild (Gorbachev
- proudly told former U.S. President Jimmy Carter, who visited
- Moscow last summer, that one had just been born, but would
- disclose no more than that).
-
- Gorbachev retains his ties to Privolnoye, going to see his
- mother there at least once a year. On one trip to Stavropol in
- 1982, Gorbachev, by then a member of the Politburo, talked with
- aged collective farmers, who complained about their low pensions
- of 36 rubles ($49.30) a month. "I know my mother also receives
- 36 rubles, but she keeps chickens and a cow; why don't you?"
- Gorbachev replied. (Nonetheless, back in Moscow, he saw to it
- that pensions were increased.) Maria Panteleyevna regularly
- attends Russian Orthodox Church services, and there are reports
- that she had Gorbachev baptized. Gorbachev has said that his
- grandparents kept icons in their home, hiding them behind
- pictures of Lenin and Stalin, and once took him to church. He
- added, though, that he had no desire to go back. Officially,
- at least, he is an atheist whose occasional references to God
- are probably no more than an unconscious repetition of phrases
- common in the rural Russia of his boyhood.
-
- As a law student, Gorbachev received some practical training in
- oratory. That, plus a natural flair for speaking, has produced
- a man who is considered the finest orator of any Soviet leader
- since Lenin (who was also trained as a lawyer). Gorbachev's
- phraseology is not remarkable, or at least does not read well
- in translation. The English version of Perestroika, published
- in the U.S. just before the December summit, is blandly general.
- But in a Gorbachev speech, as TV viewers around the world have
- discovered, phrases that seem flat on the printed page suddenly
- come to life.
-
- Russian is a language spoken with the hands, the eyebrows, and
- occasional shake of the head from side to side or a shrug of
- the shoulders. Gorbachev has mastered those gestures, and more.
- He may slice the air with a modified karate chop or spin his
- hands one over the other like a pinwheel, then extend them palms
- up in a gesture of vulnerability, only to clench them into fists
- a moment later. All the time his intense eyes lock onto a
- listener's. The eyes, he once told an audience in Prague, never
- lie. Much of his animation comes through even in translation.
- In a TV interview, for example, he may pause reflectively after
- a question, start an answer with a few slow phrases, then burst
- into a torrent of words that an interpreter can barely keep up
- with.
-
- Such skills have served Gorbachev well in his 33 months in
- office. Though he grumbles about opposition to his policies from
- a bureaucracy that "does not want change and does not want to
- lose some rights associated with privileges," he has
- consolidated his power rapidly. He had thoroughly purged the
- ranks of the Politburo, the Central Committee and government
- ministries of leaders judged to be incompetent or dragging their
- feet on reform. More than half of all government ministers and
- 44% of party Central Committee members have been replaced since
- he took over.
-
- Gorbachev's idea of glasnost stops well short of Western-style
- artistic and journalistic freedom. Nonetheless, the policy has
- gone further than anyone would have predicted even a few years
- ago, winning Gorbachev the enthusiastic approval of
- intellectuals. Says Vitali Korotich, editor of Ogonyok, an
- illustrated weekly that has published hard-hitting articles
- about social problems as well as anthologies of long-suppressed
- poetry: "This is an evening of dancing in a society that has
- never danced."
-
- Perestroika, however, is still more platitude than policy.
- Gorbachev confessed in June that "despite tremendous efforts,
- the restructuring drive has in actual fact not reached many
- localities." In particular, agricultural reforms designed to
- give farmers more incentive, which Gorbachev began experimenting
- with back in Stavropol and for which he supposedly won Politburo
- approval as long ago as 1983, have yet to be put into effect
- nationwide. Meanwhile, the economy continues to fall behind
- those of the West. As recently as 1975, the Soviet economy was
- about 58% as large as its U.S. counterpart. But by 1984 that
- figure had fallen to 54%, and the gap is probably still growing.
- WIth his usual hard-boiled realism, Gorbachev told the Central
- Committee shortly before becoming General Secretary, "We cannot
- remain a major power in world affairs unless we put our domestic
- house in order."
-
- At best, it will take years before Gorbachev's program of
- freeing industry from Moscow's stifling central control results
- in any significant increase in the quantity and quality of gods
- reaching Soviet consumers. Gorbachev complains that "Soviet
- rockets can find Halley's comet and fly to Venus with amazing
- accuracy, but...many household appliances are of poor quality."
- The Soviet leader may be hard put to maintain the popular
- support he is counting on to overcome bureaucratic lethargy and
- opposition. Gauging public opinion in the U.S.S.R. is a highly
- uncertain art, but letters to the Soviet press often approve the
- idea of perestroika while simultaneously complaining that the
- writers have not seen much of it yet. Some polls disclose
- considerable grumbling that perestroika has so far meant only
- harder work for little measurable reward. Consumers may soon
- have to pay more for some of the necessities of life if
- Gorbachev follows through on his plan to trim or eliminate many
- state subsidies. The Kremlin boss rightly complains that the
- subsidies on bread, for example, make is so cheap that children
- sometimes use loaves as footballs. But a higher price for
- bread, while it might be fully justified by production costs,
- is likely to cause strong discontent.
-
- Gorbachev acknowledges that his antialcohol campaign is highly
- unpopular. He once told a group of writers that he was aware
- of "threats" as well as grumbling from the long lines of people
- queueing up to buy scarce and expensive vodka. One gag has a
- man at the end of one of the liquor-store lines announcing that
- he is so furious he is going over to the Kremlin to shoot
- Gorbachev. He returns in a few minutes, however, and resumes
- his place in the queue. "Well, did you do it?" asks a comrade.
- "You must be joking," the would-be assassin replies. "The line
- over there is even longer."
-
- In foreign policy too, Gorbachev's approach is a mixture of
- much touted "new thinking" and dismayingly old reflexes.
- Despite his flexibility in the realm of superpower relations,
- he maintains some strange attitudes about the U.S. By his own
- account, he began reading American history as a law student, and
- he has kept himself remarkably well informed. In recent
- interviews he has referred offhandedly to matters, such as
- Ronald Reagan's "economic bill of rights," that are not widely
- known even to U.S. citizens.
-
- Nonetheless, he seems to have a streak of what can only be
- described as anti-Americanism. Perhaps the first American to
- have an extended conversation with him was John Chrystal,
- chairman of Bankers Trust of Des Moines and a frequent traveler
- to the Soviet Union, who called on Gorbachev in 1981. Says
- Chrystal: "He does not believe, never having been here, that
- the U.S. has abject poverty and quite a lot of it. My
- impression is that he thinks there are whole towns that are just
- sort of destitute." Eugene Whelan, the former Canadian
- Agriculture Minister who was later Gorbachev's host in North
- America, also visited him in 1981 and got into an argument about
- armaments. Says Whelan: "He was going on about how the U.S. was
- the aggressor, how it was making weapons. He said the U.S. was
- returning to the conditions of the 1950s." When Whelan
- remonstrated that in the American view it was the Soviet Union
- that had piled up weapons far beyond any legitimate defense
- needs, Gorbachev brusquely responded, "That is erroneous."
-
- At Chernenko's funeral in 1985, Gorbachev encountered Armand
- Hammer, the American businessman who has been trading with the
- Soviets since Lenin's day, and denounced Ronald Reagan to him
- as a man who wanted war. He mellowed after meeting the U.S.
- President later that year at their first summit in Geneva, and
- today speaks respectfully of Reagan. Still, when Hammer called
- at the Kremlin in 1986, Gorbachev told him, "Your President
- couldn't make peace if he wanted to. He's a prisoner of the
- military-industrial complex," which in Gorbachev's mind seems
- to be both all powerful and moved by an implacable hostility to
- the Soviets. Hammer tried to dissuade him but got nowhere,
- largely, he suspects, because Gorbachev had been put in a
- defensive mood by U.S. and other foreign criticism of his
- handling of the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear-plant accident. Says
- Hammer: "Gorbachev's weakness is that he has a temper, and that
- he flares up, and that he had a lot of pride, of course, and
- self-confidence." The Soviet leader has generally managed to
- keep his temper under control in public. Indeed, friends and
- opponents agree that he is almost invariably polite. But he
- does blow up now and then-- especially, as foreign TV viewers
- have discovered, when he is questioned sharply about the Soviet
- Union's human-rights record.
-
- Gorbachev, however, need not admire Americans in order to live
- peaceably with them. Nor is it necessary for the U.S. to enroll
- in a Gorbachev personality cult in order to recognize the Soviet
- leader as being a figure of hope, for all his contradictions.
- His upbringing, schooling and rise to power have produced a man
- of immense incongruities, stubborn and flexible, a faithful
- ideologue and a radical experimenter.
-
- He could be the most dangerous adversary the U.S. and its allies
- have faced in decades--or the most constructive. Molded by
- famine and war, promised a measure of hope after Stalin's demise
- and then abruptly disillusioned, Gorbachev is not the sort of
- man who would willingly drag his country back into the dark days
- of repression, economic hardship and international obloquy. If
- there is a lesson in the 56-year education of Mikhail
- Sergeyevich Gorbachev, it is that a new unfamiliar kind of
- leader has risen in the Soviet Union, and that the old rules of
- dealing with that long-suffering land are suddenly outdated.
- For the West, the education is just beginning.
-
- --By George J. Church. Reported by David Aikman/Washington,
- James O. Jackson/Moscow and John Kohan/Stavropol
-
-
-