home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- ***********************************************************************
- ╘HIS ARTICLE IS BEING PRESENTED THROUGH THE *╙TAR┬OARD* ╩OURNAL OF THE
- ╞LAG╙HIP/╙TAR╙HIP ╙╔╟S (╙PECIAL ╔NTEREST ╟ROUPS) ON ─ELPHI AND ╟┼NIE
- TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORKS. ╨ERMISSION IS HEREBY GRANTED TO NON-PROFIT
- ORGANIZATIONS ONLY TO REPRINT THIS ARTICLE OR PASS IT ALONG ELECTRONIC-
- ALLY AS LONG AS PROPER CREDIT IS GIVEN TO BOTH THE AUTHOR AND THE
- *╙TAR┬OARD* ╩OURNAL.
- ***********************************************************************
-
- ╘╥┴╬╙╠┴╘╔╧╬╙
- BY ═ICHAEL ┼RSKINE
-
- ╬╧╘┼:
- ┴ DIALOGUE BETWEEN ╚UMAN AND ├OMPUTER ON THE ISSUE OF TRANSLATING FROM ONE
- HUMAN LANGUAGE TO ANOTHER. ╫RITTEN BY ═ICHAEL ┼RSKINE, AUTHOR OF A POWERFUL
- EXPERT SYSTEM IN ├╧═┴╠, THIS IS NOT A ├╧═┴╠-SPECIFIC ARTICLE. ╔T DEALS
- WITH SOME OF THE DIFFICULTIES AND POSSIBILITIES IN THE FIELD. ┴N ATTACHED
- NOTE TELLS ABOUT THE AVAILABILITY OF THE EXPERT SYSTEM. ╞ROM ├╧═┴╠ ╘╧─┴┘ 13.
-
- ┘OU ARE WELCOME TO USE THIS ARTICLE IN YOUR NEWSLETTER OR ON
- YOUR BULLETIN BOARD SYSTEM. ╨LEASE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT IT IS TAKEN
- FROM:
- ├╧═┴╠ ╘╧─┴┘
- 6041 ═ONONA ─R
- ═ADISON, ╫╔ 53716
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
- ╘╥┴╬╙╠┴╘╔╧╬╙
- BY ═ICHAEL ┼RSKINE
-
- ═AN: ├OMPUTER.
- ═ACHINE:╥EADY.
- ═AN : ╘RANSLATE, ┼NGLISH TO ╦OREAN,"╘HE QUICK RED FOX JUMPED OVER
- THE LAZY BROWN DOG'S BACK."
- ═ACHINE:╫ORD "THE": THERE ARE 24 MAIN USES, 7,800 CHARACTERS OF
- DATA.
- ═ACHINE:╫ORD "QUICK": THERE ARE 11 MAIN USES, 6 ADJECTIVES AND 5
- NOUNS, 1340 CHARACTERS OF DATA.
- ═ACHINE:╫ORD "RED": THERE ARE 10 MAIN USES; 1 NOUN, 1 ADJECTIVE, 2
- INTRANSITIVE VERBS, AND 2 TRANSITIVE VERBS, 600 CHARACTERS OF
- DATA.
- ═AN: ╙TOP.
- ═ACHINE:╥EADY.
- ═AN : ╟ET TO THE POINT.
- ═ACHINE:╘HERE IS A 1 IN 6.3 TIMES 10 TO THE ELEVENTH POWER CHANCE
- OF PRODUCING A CORRECT ╦OREAN TRANSLATION OF THE ┼NGLISH SENTENCE
- "╘HE QUICK RED FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY BROWN DOG'S BACK," ON THE
- FIRST ATTEMPT. ┼VEN AFTER THE FIRST ATTEMPT, THERE IS NO WAY TO
- KNOW WHICH CHOICES MADE WERE CORRECT. ╘HE FIRST ATTEMPT WILL
- REQUIRE READING 26,360 CHARACTERS OF DATA.
- ═AN: ╫HAT IS NECESSARY?
- ═ACHINE:╔ NEED TO KNOW THE GRAMMATICAL STRUCTURE OF ANY LANGUAGE ╔
- SHALL BE REQUIRED TO TRANSLATE.
- ═AN: ╘HAT'S A PRETTY TALL ORDER. ┘OU MUST KNOW THERE ARE
- SUBSTANTIAL DIFFERENCES BETWEEN EVEN CLOSELY RELATED LANGUAGES
- LIKE ┼NGLISH AND ╙PANISH.
- ═ACHINE: ╘HE DATA IS REQUIRED TO HELP ESTABLISH THE FUNCTIONS OF
- THE WORDS TO BE TRANSLATED.
- ═AN: ┼XPLAIN.
- ═ACHINE: ╔F ╔ DON'T KNOW THAT A VERB IN ╦OREAN IS ALWAYS
- PREDICATED, ╔ WILL TRANSLATE VERBS AS ADVERBS AND ADVERBS AS VERBS
- OR GERUNDS.
- ═AN: ╧╦, WE'LL GIVE YOU THE GRAMMAR.
- ═ACHINE: ╘HAT IS A FINE START. ╔'LL ALSO NEED CONSTANT UPDATING OF
- MY STORE OF DEFINITIONS (INCLUDING SLANG, SURNAMES, AND ANY
- UNTRANSLATABLE CONCEPTS), A METHOD OF CORRECTING THE GRAMMAR AND
- SPELLING ERRORS OF THE INPUT DATA, AND A WAY TO IDENTIFY AND
- IGNORE OR TRANSLATE THOSE NONSENSICAL NOISES YOU HUMANS MAKE (SUCH
- AS ZZZ FOR SNORING OR @#%& FOR PROFANITY).
- ═AN: ╫HY DO YOU WANT CONSTANT UPDATING? ┴ DICTIONARY IS A
- DICTIONARY!
- ═ACHINE: ╔ NEED UPDATING FOR THE SAME REASON AS YOUR DICTIONARY
- NEEDS UPDATING, LANGUAGES EVOLVE WITH THE SOCIETY IN WHICH THEY
- ARE USED. ┴ DICTIONARY FOR ┴MERICAN ┼NGLISH FREQUENTLY SHOWS
- DIFFERENT SPELLING AND USAGE FROM A DICTIONARY FOR ┬RITISH
- ┼NGLISH.
- ═AN: ╧╦, ╫E'LL GET DATA ENTRY RIGHT ON IT.
- ═ACHINE: ╫AIT, THERE'S MORE. ╔'LL BE NEEDING THE ABILITY TO
- COMPARE THE WORD ╔'M CURRENTLY TRANSLATING WITH THE SURROUNDING
- CONTEXT AND TO FURTHER COMPARE THE SENTENCE UNDER PROCESSING WITH
- THE DOCUMENT CONTEXT TO ENSURE CONSISTENCY OF THE LOGICAL FLOW OF
- MEANING IN THE WHOLE TRANSLATION....
- ═AN: ╙TOP.
- ═ACHINE: ╥EADY.
- ═AN: ╫ON'T THIS TAKE A LOT OF MEMORY?
- ═ACHINE:├ERTAINLY, BUT YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR.
- ═AN: ╫ELL, ╔ SUPPOSE IF HUMANS CAN MAKE THESE TRANSLATIONS, A
- SUPER MACHINE LIKE A ├RAY CAN ALSO. ╚OW MUCH STORAGE DOES A MAN
- HAVE?
- ═ACHINE: ╓ARIOUS ESTIMATES FROM MEDICAL RESEARCHERS SUGGEST ABOUT
- 1.2 BILLION LOCATIONS OF DIRECT ACCESS ╥┴═. ╧F COURSE, THERE IS
- ALSO THE OFF LINE STORAGE OF LIBRARIES, DATA BASES, AND OTHER
- PEOPLE.
- ═AN: ─EFINE LOCATIONS?
- ═ACHINE: ╘HAT CANNOT BE DEFINED. ╘HERE ARE THOSE WHO SUGGEST ONE
- LOCATION CAN HOLD ALL THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN A PAINTING FOR
- EXAMPLE. ╔T IS REALLY AN UNMEASURED QUANTITY, BUT CERTAINLY MUCH
- MORE THAN 8 BITS.
- ═AN: ╚UMANS HAVE UNMEASURABLE STORAGE.
- ═ACHINE: ╫HAT IS MORE, IT TAKES YEARS TO TEACH A HUMAN TO BE A
- COMPETENT TRANSLATOR, EVEN IF HE IS IMMERSED IN THE LEARNING OF
- THE LANGUAGE. ╫HICH, BY THE WAY, MEANS LEARNING THE CUSTOMS AND
- IDEOLOGY OF THE PEOPLE WHO USE THE TARGET LANGUAGE.
- ═AN: ╧╦. ╨URCHASE MORE MEMORY, 30 BILLION BYTES WOULD BE
- SUFFICIENT. ┬UILD THE DATA BASE. ╫RITE RULES OF WORD USAGE. ╫RITE
- RULES OF GRAMMAR. ═AKE THE DECISIONS NECESSARY TO TRANSLATE.
- ├OMPARE AND RETRANSLATE AS REQUIRED. ╞INALLY PRODUCE THE FINAL
- DOCUMENT...
- ═ACHINE: ╙TOP.
- ═AN: ╥EADY.
- ═ACHINE: ╘HERE'S JUST ONE MORE THING, AND IT'S MOST IMPORTANT.
- ╫HEN A TRANSLATOR IS WORKING, IT ALWAYS IS NECESSARY TO ARRANGE
- THE OUTPUT IN A MANNER WHICH IS ESTHETICALLY PLEASING, HUMANLY
- LOGICAL, AND SYNTACTICALLY SATISFYING. ╚E MUST CARRY OVER FROM ONE
- LANGUAGE TO ANOTHER NUANCES OF RESPECT (BOTH IMPLIED AND
- EXPRESSED) AND OTHER EMOTIONAL IMPLICATIONS CONTAINED IN THE
- ORIGINAL LANGUAGE. ┴ TRANSLATOR MUST BE CREATIVE.
- ═AN: ╫ORD "CREATIVE": THERE IS 1 MAIN USE, ADJECTIVE, ADVERB OR
- NOUN, 120 CHARACTERS OF DATA. ├REATIVE EQUALS ORIGINATIVE.
- ═AN: ╫ORD "ORIGINATE": THERE ARE 2 MAIN USES, 2 VERBS, 160
- CHARACTERS OF DATA...
- ═ACHINE:╙TOP.
- ═AN: ╥EADY.
- ═ACHINE: ╠IST "ORIGINATE."
- ═AN: ╔NPUT ╦OREAN OR ┼NGLISH?.
- ═ACHINE: ╦OREAN.
- ═AN: ╧RIGINATE:TO BEGIN, TO ARISE FROM.
- ═ACHINE: ┘OU NEED AN UPDATE. ┴DD TO THE EXISTING FILES FOR
- ORIGINATE, ORIGINATIVE, CREATE, AND CREATIVE, A NEW ENTRY IN EACH
- FILE.
- ═AN: ╥EADY.
-
-
- ┴ YEAR AGO ═ICHAEL TOLD US THAT ├╧═┴╠ NEEDED A POWERFUL PROGRAM SO
- GOOD THAT PEOPLE WOULD GET ├╧═┴╠ JUST SO THEY COULD RUN IT. ╙O HE
- WROTE AN EXPERT SYSTEM, ╨╥╧╘╧-─. ╙YSTEMS LIKE THIS USUALLY SELL
- FOR HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS. ┴LL ═ICHAEL WANTS IS A DONATION FROM
- THOSE WHO USE IT--A START OF ├╧═┴╠ ╙HARE╫ARE. ╘HE SET OF PROGRAMS
- (┼DITOR, ╥EADER, AND ╫RITER) WILL BE ON ╙HARE╫ARE ─ISK #1 (DUE
- ╩ULY 1986). ╔F YOU APPRECIATE HIS EFFORTS, PLEASE SEND HIM A
- CONTRIBUTION (CURRENTLY HE'S DELIVERING PIZZA AND MOWING LAWNS -
- CONVINCE HIM TO DO MORE PROGRAMS!)
-