Some of the following comments are from German publications. We have tried to translate those press comments as exactly as possible from the German originals.

PC publications

Macintosh publications

General publications

Television

  • SAT 1 - 22/11/96 ..."quick, easy to use and features the latest technology". Rating: "very good"

 

PC Answers 6/97

"CINEMA 4D is a must-have package ... will definitely give you the feeling that you are using a high-end workstation. Impressive."


DOS 2/97

Test winner
Issue 2/97, pp. 88-89

"Cinema 4D is so powerful; semi-professionals at least could not wish for more"


CHIP 12/96

CHIP Product of the Month

"Chip opinion:
The ease of use, the many functions as well as the extremely quick and robust raytracer make CINEMA 4D a top product"

"very user-friendly"


 

DOS international - DIP

Cinema 4D: Breakneck-speed raytracer

"Until now, to generate these types of animations you needed either very expensive hardware and software, or you had to accept render times taking hours. The 3D modelling, raytracing and animation program that is Cinema 4D also offers deliver speed at a favourable price. The software does require 32-bit architecture, but is modest in terms of performance or RAM requirements: 32MB RAM is sufficient, even for scenes with far in excess of 100,000 surfaces."

On a 486, Cinema 4D took merely 17 minutes to render an animated chess game comprising 76 individual frames. (Other programs take several hours for this calculation.)"

"Summary: Cinema 4D is the ideal software for multimedia product catalogues, animated scenes, films, computer games and 3D visualisations of technical devices or buildings."


PC professionell 12/96

Into the fourth dimension

"Modelling, raytracing and animation software of exceptional quality"

"Summary: The modelling, animation and raytracing software is enormously powerful, even on a modest configuration."


DOS international - DIP-News

"... The program impresses through short render times. Further strengths are outstanding export and import functions (including three DFX formats), very good anti-aliasing (edge smoothing) and realistic lighting effects ..."


 

Mac Format, issue 50

"The final output from CINEMA is the most impressive we've seen from a Mac ... the work environment is clean, concise and configurable ... Offers power, speed and superb results and is as stable as a healthy elephant. 3D functions that match any of its rivals plus excellent animation features. Brilliant."


 

Mac User 4/97

"...the program has a lot of well-thought-out and extremely powerful features ... CINEMA 4D's Object Manager is one of the best designed systems available ... its rendering is very fast and able to produce very high-quality images."


 

Mac Magazin & Mac easy 2/97

Render-Racer

"Cinema 4D, the newcomer from Germany, redefines the 3D scene."

"...the program belts along even on a moderately equipped PowerPC Performa, leaving you speechless."

"Cinema 4D should satisfy even the user with high expectations."


MacWEEK 16.12.97

(Quotation following the announcement of the English Cinema 4D version:)

"Apple QuickDraw 3D The renderer smokes", said Sean Safreed, product manager, who has seen the German version. "I was able to get full-screen ray-traced images in seconds"


MacWelt 1/97

"Modern Concept
The programmers have given CINEMA 4D everything that is good and progressive: a modular design, a super quick raytracer, every animation refinement, multiprocessing and multithreading support, previews in real-time, as well as Quickdraw-3D and Quicktime VR functions ... There are abundant modelling functions."

"Summary:
CINEMA 4D is a new, recommendable product, whose accessibility soon leads to a feeling of achievement. And there is a lot in reserve for the professionals, particularly with regards to animations and rendering."

Rating: very good/outstanding (4.5/5 mice)


 

Mac Magazin 1/97

Front-runner

"CINEMA 4D is truly impressive, and its enormous range of functions and high speed are captivating. Till now, one dared not even dream of such speed."

"One of CINEMA 4D's strengths is the physically precise and extremely realistic calculation of every light phenomenon in record time. Those with multiprocessor machines no longer have a chance to get to the coffee machine. Rendering animations at these speeds is great fun."

"CINEMA 4D naturally offers all that the competition can ... what set's the program apart from its competitors are completely different things.
... diverse optical effects ... lens reflections ... visible light or fog without incurring expense ... blurring for realistic looks ... the object manager makes for considerable simplification when working with complicated scenes ..."

"You can work fluently in the object editor using real-time shading, even on a moderately equipped Power Mac.

The true power of CINEMA 4D is most apparent with raytracing proper. In this mode, the program attains speeds that, until now, you dared not even dream of. An enormous advantage, which becomes very noticeable with animations - there is nothing that you couldn't animate in CINEMA 4D."


Rating:

Use: 4/5
Manual: 4/5
Functions: 5/5
Price: 3/5
Overall: 4/5

MacWelt 12/96

TeamWork - Multiprocessing - the next leap in performance.
(Report on multiprocessor applications)

"On the software side, Adobe Photoshop 3.0.5 and the CINEMA 4D render engine profit the most."

  Single-CPU 2-CPU 4-CPU
Photoshop 100% 162% 238%
CINEMA 4D 100% 177% 346%
After Effects 100% 131% 156%


"In general, one can expect an average speed increase of about 160% on two-processor systems and about 200% on four-processor systems."

"...we witnessed the most extreme acceleration when rendering an animation with the multiprocessing beta-version of CINEMA 4D. The nigh-on 500% increase (Daystar Genesis in comparison to Mac 9500) astonishes us.

"The developer of xxxxxxx (other 3D program), for example, cut out the MP acceleration for Phong shading in the beta 3 of the MP version. According to an employee, there were "too many difficulties"".


MacWorld Swiss 12/96

"Quick, complete range of functions, photo-realistic render effects, fully-realised animation features."

"....mass of functions, unique in this price range ... no wishes are left open. Not only have 3D modelling, rendering and animation been mastered, there are also possibilities which provide for truly photo-realistic results and natural movement. For raytracing the final picture, you will find options one hoped in vain would appear in other products, such as soft shading or blurring ..."

"In addition to this, all operations, from modelling up to the calculation of animations, execute at astonishing speeds, a significant factor with time and processing-intensive tasks. The direct comparison is not easy due to the differing qualities, but CINEMA 4D seems a long way in front of the competition, both in terms of picture calculations within the editor and when raytracing."

"...fascinating possibilities await you after a short training period"

"Its features, in terms of modelling as well as rendering and animation, are clearly greater than the competition in its price class. And on top of that is the speed, which itself can be described as breath-taking. Those who really know what three dimensional graphics is all about can scarcely avoid CINEMA 4D."



Rating: 5/6


MacOPEN 12/96

CINEMA 4D
Render speed not down to sorcery!


"There are already plenty of three-dimensional modellers available. But space soon appears when the users tire of waiting minutes, hours or even days for a single rendered picture, yet alone animations. CINEMA 4D, a classy 3D modelling, raytracing and animation program currently available for the Power Macintosh and Windows NT/95, proving that things can after all go much faster."

"Render results of absolutely professional quality"

"The finished animation sequence can be observed at any time in the editor."

"It is easy to find your way about the program within a short time - this is not least of all thanks to the excellent accompanying manual."

Positive:

  • high speed
  • full range of functions
  • many special effects built into the program
  • comprehensive import and export support


Rating: "very good"


MacForum ARCHITEKTUR und Gestaltung 4/96

"In general one is inclined to assume that the cards have been dealt so far as 3D rendering and animation programs are concerned. It is a joy to learn that one was perhaps wrong. CINEMA 4D, from the German firm MAXON Computer based in Eschborn, turns out to be a real discovery."
"impressive speed ... modelling in real-time ... The adaptive raytracer convinced us with its speed and render picture quality ..."


Media Worldwide

(Reviewing the beta of CINEMA 4D XL shown on Siggraph 97)

Homepage: http://www.wwug.com
Direct Link to article

WWUG Award: Best Animation Tool SIGGRAPH '97

"... the pro end of the Mac market is heating up."

"I found out that these engineers have done something that few have attempted and only they seem to have done it successfully"

"It's an awesome idea and watching it work is quite impressive. It FLIES!!!"

"CINEMA 4D is a radical idea and it works."

"To say that it is unbelievably fast is an understatement. Its competition is itself, nothing else even comes close."

"A real mind-blowing program to watch in action -- and I do mean action!"


 

Computer Shopper 07/97

"CINEMA 4D is a really good modelling, rendering and animation package ... stands out as being easy to use and powerful."


 

Creative Technology 06/97

"CINEMA 4D could well appeal to many more different sections of the design community than 3D has attracted in the past---architects, interior and graphic designers ... an exceptional all-rounder, good value for money."


 

Computer Arts, issue 7

"As the fastest raytracer currently available ... the rendering speed alone makes it an obvious choice for animators as results can be seen in hours instead of days. We recommend it."


 

CGI vol. 2 / issue 8

"CINEMA 4D is one of the fastest and most stable (programs) on the market"

"epic performance"

"The actual texture creation facilities are superb"

"The animation ... include features not normally found at this price level"

"The manuals are superb so the learning curve is not at all daunting."

"CINEMA 4D definitively flies... with afterburners."

"I'll be happy playing with a German Alpha (meaning beta version of CINEMA 4D XL) which is more stable than the initial releases of both xxx 2 and yyyyyyyyy 5!"


invers 11/96

Rendering in the fast lane

"... The render results are of an absolutely professional quality."

"Summary:
Under testing, CINEMA 4D proved itself well up to the task. Not only did the comprehensive speed astound us, but also its enormous functionality and the robustness of the code.

Whether CINEMA 4D goes on to stake its claim in technical illustration; in film studios; in product design; in architecture or in game designing, it is an exceedingly worthwhile investment for all applications, especially in view of the fantastically short production times. Bull's eye!"


PC-VIDEO 2/96

"Rating:
Powerful 3D program
Versions for PC, Apple, Amiga
comfortable interface
quick render times"

VIDEO recommendation
Highest rating (5/5 stars)


SAT 1

22.11.96
"Test Rating: CINEMA 4D offers features which are only known in the 5000 DM price range. In addition, the software is quick, easy to use and features the latest technology. This powerful program is suitable for both professionals and beginners. All along the line CINEMA 4D impresses throughout.

Rating: "very good"