What should I do with the candle? How do I get out of here?

Hint 1 of 14:

Have you noticed that the candle doesn't have a wick?  It needs one.

Hint 2 of 14:

So put the bookmark in the candle (F).

Hint 3 of 14:

You might want to try to get that eye now.

Hint 4 of 14:

You'll need something to pry it out.

Hint 5 of 14:

Use the match on the eye (W).

Hint 6 of 14:

Try seeing what happens when you use the eye.

Hint 7 of 14:

In specific, have the Buffoon kick it, and a shard of glass will appear.