GenderArticles #37
COMMUNITY AND INTERPERSONAL DIFFERENCES
By Gianna E. Israel
©1999 Gianna E. Israel
GENDERARTICLES is a syndicated column featured monthly in TG-FORUM,
the Internet's most respected weekly transgender magazine.
American-Online's Transgender Community Forum (Keyword "TCF") posts this
column and other gender resources for our community. An entire
compilation of GenderArticles and other features by the author can be
found at the Gianna E. Israel Gender Library hosted by Ms. Diane Wilson.
Link to that site at http://www.counselsuite.com.
What is it about people's differences that make it difficult for
crossdressers, transsexuals and even gays to understand each other? I put
some thought into this question and laughed. Why? I did so because over
the years I have noticed the preceding question about differences has
repeatedly arisen in so many different ways.
One of the most common things I have heard when people wrestle with
understanding differences goes as follows. Transsexuals will say that
crossdressers just aren't seriously committed about having a transgender
identity or being part of the community. On the other hand, crossdressers
will say transsexuals are too serious and push the gender envelope too
far. After all, who in their right mind would abandon all their security
to change gender? And both groups, especially transsexuals, will
sometimes say that for all their love and support that some gays just
don't "get it." In other words, some gays just can't seem to see beyond
labeling us as drag queens, which can be very distressing to a transsexual
woman.
When observing differences in people and their reactions, do you sometimes
find the subject confusing? After 11 years of practice I still find these
dynamics mystifying and intriguing. What I found helped me understand
this subject better was to learn about the word "perception."
Perception comes from the word "perceive," which means "to attain
awareness or understanding." This primarily comes through one's personal
senses. As a result, a person's perception of others' differences comes
from his or her own observations, feelings, even intuitions, and
particularly experiences. No wonder the world is such a complex place.
What all this means is that typically when a crossdresser sees a
transsexual, or vice versus, the observing party is drawing conclusions
about the other person based on his or her own perceptions. These
perceptions most commonly consist of personal experiences. Over the years
I've noticed some people are able to move beyond their perceptions while
others don't seem capable of doing so.
If you want a person, particularly a friend, to understand you better, it
can help tremendously to talk about differences. This means asking
questions and sharing with each other about what makes you and your friend
alike but also different. However, in the course of doing so, don't be
surprised if even sometimes the most loving friend won't be able to
understand you entirely.
It certainly is a beautiful thing when two people connect and come to
understand each other's differences. However, it is also okay when two
people don't understand each other on some points. After all, if people
understood everything about each other they certainly would be less
interesting. When people don't understand each other, nothing prevents
them from keeping a friendship. After all, over the years I've developed
really loving, close friendships with others who are very different than
myself. I have found that it is those differences between us which add
different perspectives, ideas and even dreams.
The most common concern people have when they are misunderstood is that
they also are not being entirely accepted. Understandably, this is a
valid concern. My suggestion, look for simplicity in answers pertaining
to being accepted by others. Otherwise, you will end up creating
unnecessary complications within your friendships and ultimately end up
feeling less accepted by others. Acceptance is also a bizarre game we
play in human relationships. I have often found that where a friend may
not understand one particular facet of my life, he or she may prove to be
my biggest supporter in other areas.
When pondering the subject of acceptance, be mindful that life can go
pretty smoothly if you allow it. This is particularly so if you aren't
being discriminated against or abuse, or if you can avoid discriminating
against others who are different than you. Differences are, after all,
what make us all the same because no one or very few people are exactly
identical. Maybe you can accept big differences in character or identity,
or maybe you can't. Perhaps others can in you, or maybe they are
unwilling to learn what makes you special. I have found that people each
have their own ability of trying to understand others and get along. I
believe the preceding trait is what makes us most unique.
Notably, no essay on differences would be complete without mentioning the
isolation that goes with feeling different from everybody else. Imagine
being the only transgender person in a classroom filled with
non-transgender persons. Or, imagine being the only transgender person in
your neighborhood. That certainly could feel very lonely. However, this
is a reality that we all must deal with, particularly if we hope to create
a place for ourselves in the world. This is one primary reason I strongly
suggest transgender persons socialize with other transgender individuals.
Doing so provides an opportunity to hear about how others similar to you
deal with these issues.
Gianna E. Israel has provided nationwide telephone consultation, individual and relationship counseling, and gender specialized evaluations and recommendations since 1988. She is a principal author of the book, Transgender Care with Donald Tarver, M.D., (Temple University Press/1997). She also writes Transgender Tapestry's "Ask Gianna" column; and is a HBIGDA member.
She can be contacted at (415) 558-8058, at P.O. Box 424447 San Francisco, CA 94142, via e-mail at gianna@counselsuite.com or visit her Web Site
|