Closeted Crossdresser Dilemmas #29
By Gianna E. Israel
©1998 Gianna E. Israel
GENDERARTICLES is a syndicated column featured monthly in TG-FORUM,
the Internet's most respected weekly transgender magazine.
American-Online's Transgender Community Forum (Keyword "TCF") posts this
column and other gender resources for our community. An entire
compilation of GenderArticles and other features by the author can be
found at the Gianna E. Israel Gender Library hosted by Ms. Diane Wilson.
Link to that site at http://www.counselsuite.com.
Have you noticed how many people have come out of the closet these days? Has someone
attempted to make you feel bad because you only have an online existence? As a gender
specializing therapist, I regularly hear complaints from closeted crossdressers who
have been told they are flawed because they haven't come out. Comments such as these
can cut very deeply, sometimes so bad that they can push a person even deeper into
the closet. This article is designed to help people who are closeted, who know they
simply cannot
come out.
What is it that keeps a person in the closet? Are a person's reasons for not coming
out simply some nebulous excuse to prevent others from having a good time? Or, are
the reasons for remaining closeted so valid that they make those who come out look
foolish? In all likelihood a person's reasons for coming out can be just as valid as
those reasons a person may have for staying in the closet. Closeted or not, it is
important to recognize that each individual has placed particular importance on getting
their needs fulfilled, and typically one's choice is not better than another's.
The most commonly written about reasons for staying closeted include social, family,
and financial factors. A person who is closeted frequently sees that coming out
would substantially interrupt life as they know it. What therapists, authors and
the transgender community less frequently explore is the fact that in many situations there
exist deep emotionally needs for an individual to remain closeted. The one need
people dislike talking about most is the crossdresser's need to maintain a strong
sense of masculine identity when not crossdressed. It is possible that in some subconscious
manner coming out may interrupt the preceding dynamic.
People need to be very careful with their judgments when discussing and exploring
gender boundaries and roles. Just as there is nothing wrong with a crossdressing
male having a healthy en femme persona, there is also nothing wrong with having a
healthy sense of masculinity. The preceding theme is true primarily for transgenderists and
crossdressers, although even transsexuals need to maintain some sense of masculinity
in order to be a whole person. All humans need to find a successful balance between
their feminine and masculine identities and needs. This is particularly so for transgendered
persons, because we are always mindful of how our gender appears to others. However,
it is also true that non-transgendered individuals explore similiar themes. This may explain why gender studies are so popular at universities and gender role play
games are enjoyed by a wide variety of people.
In the pursuit of coming to terms with having a need to crossdress it is very important
to feel good about yourself. Having people discount your needs doesn't feel very
good. I suggest if someone criticizes your choices, take some time to think about
what the person has said. Decide if their criticism offers any useful suggestions on
how to improve your situation. The very best advise typically comes from a person
talking about their own experiences. If you hear about positive coping strategies
that other people used successfully, try to consider how such strategies might work for you.
However, always remember that free advise is just that, free to take or leave at
your discretion.
As I mentioned earlier, crossdressers frequently are interested in hearing about how
others deal with the fear of being exposed or discovered as a crossdresser. During
counseling we make a point of discussing how the person might feel if they should
be found out. Most feel as if being so would utterly destroy their entire world. Fortunately,
most crossdressers simply pick up the pieces and continue on with their lives after
being discovered. I like to encourage crossdressers to overcome the fear of being found out, even if they do not come out of the closet. This helps reduce stigmatization
of what they are doing in private. After all, private is nobody's business except
your own, particularly if no one is getting hurt.
Another issue common to closeted crossdressers is purging. As a result of guilt,
after crossdressing some individuals throw away their wardrobes, and stuff their
feelings deep inside. I encourage people to stop using such unhealthy coping mechanisms.
Instead, find storage places to keep your clothing until you are ready to use them again,
and learn to feel positive about having a transgender identity. People have been
crossdressing for a long, long time. You have nothing to feel guilty about. After
safeguarding your responsibilities, try to keep in mind that the most important issue
for all transgender persons, is having some reasonable quality of life.
When you crossdress does doing so increase your quality of life? Would living with
less guilt and fear of being found out help your overall state of mind? Is it possible
to feel satisfied with crossdressing privately? If you can answer "yes" to the preceding questions, then in all likelihood it may be possible to come out when you feel
ready. Until then, be kind to yourself and enjoy crossdressing for what you get
out of it. Do not allow others to dictate how you should feel about yourself or
your needs.
Gianna E. Israel has provided nationwide telephone
consultation, individual and relationship counseling, and gender
specialized evaluations and recommendations since 1988. She is a principal
author of the book, Transgender Care with Donald Tarver, M.D., (Temple
University Press/1997). She also writes Transgender Tapestry's "Ask
Gianna" column; and is a HBIGDA member.
She can be contacted at (415) 558-8058, at P.O. Box 424447 San Francisco,
CA 94142, via e-mail at gianna@counselsuite.com or
visit her Web Site
|