How do I get everything I need for the recipe

Hint 1 of 12:

Substitutions are allowed.

Hint 2 of 12:

See any PRESSED skulls?

Hint 3 of 12:

On some sort of cloth?

Hint 4 of 12:

Check the ship's mast.

Hint 5 of 12:

Get the pirate flag.

Hint 6 of 12:

Use the flag,

Hint 7 of 12:

rubber chicken,

Hint 8 of 12:

breath mints,

Hint 9 of 12:

gunpowder,

Hint 10 of 12:

cereal,

Hint 11 of 12:

cinnamon sticks,