$Unique_ID{COW02106} $Pretitle{385B} $Title{Kuwait Chapter 1C. Labor Force} $Subtitle{} $Author{Darrel R. Eglin, Donald M. Seekins} $Affiliation{HQ, Department of the Army} $Subject{percent government oil foreign kuwait industrial workers kuwait's products early} $Date{1984} $Log{} Country: Kuwait Book: Persian Gulf States, An Area Study: Kuwait Author: Darrel R. Eglin, Donald M. Seekins Affiliation: HQ, Department of the Army Date: 1984 Chapter 1C. Labor Force Kuwait's economic development was achieved in part by importing foreign workers. By 1980 non-Kuwaitis made up 79 percent of the employed labor force (see table 8, Appendix A). During the decade of the 1970s, Kuwaitis in the work force increased by the high average rate of 5.7 percent a year, but the non-Kuwaiti segment grew even faster-an average 8.1 percent a year. The critical importance of foreign workers to the economy was difficult to overstress. Non-Kuwaitis appeared prominently throughout the employment spectrum, filling professional, technical managerial, and clerical posts-for which there were not enough qualified Kuwaitis-and industrial and menial jobs that Kuwaitis would not accept. In 1980 non-Kuwaitis held 84 percent of the 27,400 professional, technical, and managerial jobs in the country and had about a five-to-one advantage over nationals in terms of having university degrees. At the other end of the spectrum, construction, which employed large numbers of unskilled laborers, was made up of nearly 99 percent expatriates. A major factor contributing to the reliance on foreign workers was the low educational level of Kuwaitis, reflecting the gradual development of an educational system. In 1975 illiterate Kuwaitis in the labor force amounted to 36 percent, and another 23 percent claimed ability to read and write but lacked an elementary education, leading one observer to conclude that over half of working Kuwaitis should be considered illiterate. Expansion of the educational system after the 1950s started to remedy the situation, but it was a slow and ongoing process (see Education, this ch.) The low participation of females in the work force was another important factor contributing to the reliance on foreign workers. Although Kuwaiti women were clearly more emancipated than others in the Gulf and many had taken advantage of the opportunities for education, their entrance into the labor force was slow. In 1980 Kuwaiti women constituted only 13 percent of all employed Kuwaitis. The bulk of Kuwaitis were employed in service industries-88 percent in 1980. The government was the largest employer in the country and employed most of the Kuwaitis in the labor force (about 47,000 in 1983). The Constitution essentially guarantees jobs to citizens, and the government implemented this through its liberal employment policy. Many Kuwaitis preferred government employment to other positions even when it meant routine tasks that often under-utilized their skills and time. Observers usually noted the country's excessive bureaucracy and over-staffing of many positions, to the extent that several people were often assigned to what should have been a single job. In 1983 there were 4.5 citizens for every civil servant. Observers and experts have long advocated reform of the civil service to reduce the inefficiency and underuse of available manpower. In 1980 some 60 percent of the foreign workers in Kuwait were Arabs, and another 28 percent were Asians, particularly from Iran, Pakistan, and India. Americans and West Europeans accounted for about 1.5 percent, and a few hundred Africans constituted the remainder. Palestinians and Egyptians were especially prominent in professional, technical, and government work. Pakistanis and Indians tended to be skilled workers in technical jobs. Iranians and Iraqis often had menial positions in production or service activities. An influx of East Asian construction workers accompanied the construction boom of the late 1970s and early 1980s. A 1983 government survey found a substantial slowing of the increase in Kuwait's expatriate community since the 1980 census, presumably reflecting a similar reduction in the rate of growth of foreign workers in the labor force. The reduction was probably attributable to diminished development expenditures as well as completion of some of the large construction projects, which resulted in the return home of the imported construction force. In spite of the country's heavy reliance on imported workers since the 1950s, government policy sharply discriminated against them. Most non-Kuwaitis were paid less than their Kuwaiti counterparts and often less than a Kuwaiti with few qualifications in a less responsible job. The country's social security system, including a 1976 revision, and most retirement benefits were limited to Kuwaitis. Foreigners could not own real property and usually rented in the poorer neighborhoods or sought shelter in shanties constructed of scrap materials. Modern suburban housing developments with many amenities were exclusively for citizens. Foreign workers could not form their own unions, but they could join Kuwaiti unions, although they were prohibited from running for union offices or voting. Acquiring Kuwaiti citizenship was difficult and very limited, even for highly educated expatriates who had worked for 20 years or more in Kuwait and raised families there. The large number of expatriates created social tensions between the foreigners and the native population. Foreign workers-particularly those who had worked many years in Kuwait-resented the discrimination against them. Natives often viewed the foreign workers with suspicion, if not hostility. In order to enhance the foreign workers' stake in the country's development and to reduce departures of highly trained personnel for jobs elsewhere in the Middle East (where there was less discrimination), some observers suggested granting naturalization or permanent residency on a larger scale to foreign workers who had much needed skills. But the political climate in early 1984 was not conducive to liberalization. Seven car bombings in December 1983, involving some long-term, legal, Iraqi residents, increased the apprehension of Kuwaiti authorities over foreign workers and led to more stringent policies toward applications for work permits. The authorities faced a serious dilemma, however, in choosing between security considerations and the dependence of the economy on foreign workers. Agriculture Scant rainfall, little irrigation water, and poor soils have always limited farming in Kuwait. Before the discovery of oil, nomads moving livestock to the limited forage in the desert and pearling and fishing contributed much of agricultural income, but none of these occupations provided much more than subsistence. Growth of the economy and welfare measures since World War II drew workers away from traditional pursuits and lessened the role of agriculture. By 1984 agriculture, including some fishing, contributed only a small fraction of 1 percent to GDP and employed less than 2 percent of the labor force. Kuwait's total area amounted to 1,781,800 hectares. In 1980 official data indicated 44,041 hectares were uncultivable; the bulk of the land, 1,717,910 hectares, was listed as pasture, which obviously meant primarily the scant forage available in the desert. Some 16,229 hectares were listed as fallow but not part of farm holdings; it appeared doubtful that much of the fallow land could be cultivated. Areas with trees amounted to 2,269 hectares, but this appeared too large for commercial tree crops such as date palms and presumably included substantial areas of desert scrub growth. In 1980 the area under crops amounted to 1,351 hectares, less than 0.1 percent of the country's total area. Nonetheless, the cropped area had increased by 85 percent between 1975 and 1980. In 1980 the 1,351 hectares that were cropped belonged to 501 agricultural holdings, essentially farms. Three hundred eighteen of the holdings specialized in raising vegetables, 58 in raising poultry, and 42 in raising milk cows; the remaining 83 engaged in various farm activities. Vegetable production totaled 36,782 tons; fruits 745 tons; a form of clover for animal feed, 36,585 tons. The country's farmers supplied about half of the fresh vegetables consumed, 40 percent of the milk, over a third of the poultry, and 18 percent of the eggs. Thus, imports supplied the bulk of the population's food. The major crops were tomatoes, radishes, melons, and cucumbers, plus the clover grown for fodder. Cultivation of grains was quite limited. All cultivation depended on irrigation. Deep wells supplied most irrigation water, which had a salt content that ranged from 0.3 to 1.1 percent. Experiments were under way to use drip irrigation and hydroponics on a broader scale as well as to find salt-tolerant plants better suited to the country's brackish irrigation water. The gross value of animal products far exceeded that of crops-by about threefold in the latter half of the 1970s. In terms of value, production of milk, eggs, and poultry meat were the most important activities. Commercial chicken raising, using prepared feed for growth, had grown rapidly since the 1960s, and poultry meat substantially exceeded the meat from sheep, goats, and cattle supplied by local producers by the early 1980s. Many dairy farms were modern and commercial, although in the early 1980s goats still provided over 40 percent of the milk produced. Nomads continued to raise sheep on coarse desert vegetation, but observers reported that such activity was declining, partly in response to government settlement programs. Fishing was a minor but important contribution to the value added by the agricultural sector. Much of the fishing for the local market was from small boats, including many native dhows. During the 1970s, overfishing by many nations in the Gulf considerably reduced catches of fish and shrimp. Large-scale commercial fishing was mostly confined to the United Fisheries Company, which operated a fleet of more than 150 vessels (including factory ships) as far afield as the Indian Ocean, the Red Sea, and the Atlantic Ocean. United Fisheries was a large, international firm that processed and exported part of its catch, particularly frozen shrimp. The fish catch was about 4,500 tons in 1982. Industry Industrial development in Kuwait has always faced formidable obstacles. The lack of resources other than oil restricted the manufacturing that could be established. No metallic minerals and few suitable nonmetallic minerals had been found. For example, most of the raw materials for cement had to be imported, largely from Iraq. The limited supply of fresh water was another constraint. The small size of the domestic market restricted production for local consumption to small-scale operations. Moreover, the open economy, which was maintained before and after the discovery of oil, provided little protection from foreign competition. Industrialists interested in large-scale production had to think in terms of foreign markets and established competitors. The small Kuwaiti labor force, possessing limited skills and a distaste for industrial work, forced the importation of foreign workers for industrial development. After the discovery of oil, labor costs escalated, and in a few years wages in Kuwait were higher than those in almost any other area of the Middle East. Wages remained high in the early 1980s. The commercial tradition in the country predisposed most entrepreneurs to invest in trade rather than manufacturing. As a result of the obstacles, industry (excluding oil refining but including electricity and water desalination) expanded slowly and contributed only 4 percent of GDP in the early 1980s, little more than it had a decade earlier. The discovery of oil created a demand for new industries, initially satisfied by the oil company itself. Oil operations particularly needed water, electricity, and refined petroleum products, and these were the first modern industries built in the country. The government soon took over production of electricity and water, expanding the systems. Installed electric generating capacity increased from 30 megawatts in 1956 to nearly 3,000 megawatts by mid-1982. Generators were added so that installed capacity was to be 5,086 megawatts by late 1984. Production of electricity rose from 87 million kilowatt-hours in 1956 to 10 billion kilowatt-hours in 1981. Industrial use of electricity was relatively small; air-conditioning was the largest user of electricity, so that peak summer loads were over five times minimum winter loads, creating substantial idle capacity for about half the year. By 1983 charges for electricity had not been changed for over 20 years, and subsidy costs reportedly amounted to nearly US $800 million in FY 1983, probably the most expensive of the government's subsidies. Users paid about 6 percent of actual generating and distribution costs. Generators usually used gas as fuel but could switch to fuel oil or crude oil, which became necessary because of the shortage of associated gases in the early 1980s (see The Oil Industry, this ch.). Several of the power plants were associated with the desalination of seawater. In a country without streams and few underground sources, provision of water was crucial to both inhabitants and industrial development. Before the discovery of oil and the consequent high population growth, native sailing boats had carried water from Iraq. The need for larger and regular supplies of water-no matter how costly-compelled the Kuwait Oil Company (KOC) to install the first desalination plant. In 1953 the government installed its first unit of 3.8 million liters per day. Subsequently, the government claimed that it had developed the most advanced continuously operating desalination facility in the world-one that had a capacity of 258 million liters per day in 1981. Additional capacity of 418 million liters per day was to be installed between 1982 and 1986, reflecting the rapid population increase and accelerating per capita consumption. In 1981 average per capita consumption was 197 liters of desalinated water and 76 liters of brackish water from underground sources that were added to purified water. In the same year total production was 261 million liters per day of fresh water (almost all desalinated) and 126 million liters per day of brackish water; most of the latter was used in agriculture and industry. Seawater was also supplied to industrial areas for cooling. The petrochemical industry offered fewer obstacles to industrial development than most others for Kuwait. The industry needed relatively few workers, large capital investments, and substantial oil and gas sources-requirements that fit the country's circumstances. Despite the apparent advantages, the government moved slowly, perhaps for good reason. In 1963 the Petrochemicals Industries Company (PIC) was formed, having 80 percent state ownership. It began with modest facilities but acquired additional plants over the years through purchase of other companies and construction of new facilities. In 1976 the government bought out the private investors, and PIC became wholly government owned. In 1980 PIC became a wholly owned subsidiary of the Kuwait Petroleum Company (KPC) (see The Oil Industry, this ch.). PIC's chemical complexes were the country's largest manufacturing plants. In 1983 PIC's three ammonia plants had a total capacity of 660,000 tons a year, and a fourth unit was to begin operating in 1984, raising capacity to about 900,000 tons a year. An ammonium sulfate plant had a capacity of 165,000 tons a year; three urea plants, 792,000 tons a year; and a sulfuric acid plant, 132,000 tons a year. (A salt and chlorine complex produced a variety of products but on a smaller scale.) A substantial part of PIC's production was ordinarily exported, and Kuwait had become an important exporter of fertilizer. In 1982 and 1983 depressed world markets for chemical products and a domestic shortage of natural gas to provide fuel and feedstock greatly restricted petrochemical production. In 1983 the ammonium sulfate units remained closed for a third year, the urea and sulfuric plants operated only for short periods, and the ammonia units produced at little more than half of capacity. In 1984 the country was to import liquefied natural gas to reduce the domestic shortage. For about a decade the government considered the development of a complex to produce ethylene and other basic petrochemical products for further processing by smaller privately owned plants into propylene and other products, but it was postponed or canceled in 1983 because of the gas shortage and poor sales prospects abroad. PIC plants obtained gas at concessionary rates from the government's KPC. A small group of relatively large-scale businesses merged in the 1960s and 1970s; the government owned shares in some of them. The Kuwait Cement Company, for example, with an annual production capacity of 2.1 million tons in 1983, was only partially privately owned. Its production was primarily for the domestic market. The National Industries Company, 51 percent government owned, produced a variety of products, such as asbestos pipes and sheets, lime bricks, lead acid batteries, and detergents. A metal pipe company produced a variety of pipes for oil, gas, and water installations and was the largest in the Middle East, supplying domestic and foreign markets. A privately owned company produced pre-engineered steel buildings for a variety of purposes for erection at home and abroad. In the early 1980s several companies were established to produce insulation materials because the government substantially raised insulation requirements in new buildings in order to reduce electrical use for airconditioning. A large number of companies, usually operating on a small scale, produced paints, furniture, textiles, metal products, and processed food and beverages for the domestic market. Most of the larger industrial facilities were located in the Ash Shuaybah Industrial Estate, established in 1964 and operated by a government agency supported largely by budget funds. The agency had partially developed its 11 square kilometers at Ash Shuaybah and an additional estate area of 13 square kilometers at Mina Abdallah. The government and its agency provided such necessary facilities as roads, gas, electricity, water, sewerage, port facilities, and communications, and rented or leased industrial sites at nominal rates. Some small manufacturing establishments were located throughout the populated parts of the country. The government provided various incentives to private manufacturers, although 51-percent Kuwaiti ownership was required. Financial aid included equity capital and loans. The Investment Bank of Kuwait was created in 1974, with 49-percent government ownership, to provide medium- and long-term industrial financing. Long-term loans were at 5 percent interest. Between 1974 and 1983 the bank provided about US $800 million to 288 projects and was an influential force in the pace and direction of industrial development. The government also provided local industry preference in government purchases (amounting to about 10 percent of price), protection from imports in selected cases, and exemption of customs duties and taxes, although foreign investors were taxed for their share of profits. Kuwaiti businessmen argued that the government lacked an industrial strategy and that the private industrial development that had occurred resulted from the ingenuity and perseverence of local entrepreneurs. The government and private investors agreed that future industrial expansion should be in capital-intensive, advanced technology industries that limited requirements of imported labor. But economists questioned how far the country should and could go in attempting to industrialize. The returns might be larger on investments made in foreign countries that had an established industrial base. By 1984 the government and private investors already had invested substantial sums in manufacturing plants and energy facilities abroad. Finance Before independence in 1961, foreign monies, largely the Indian rupee in the 1930-60 period, circulated in Kuwait. At independence the Kuwaiti dinar was introduced and a currency board established to issue dinar notes and maintain reserves. In 1959 the Central Bank of Kuwait was created and took over the functions of the currency board and the regulation of the banking system. The first bank in Kuwait was established in 1941 by British investors. Subsequent laws prohibited foreign banks from conducting business in the country. When the British bank's concession ended in 1971, the government bought 51-percent ownership. In 1952 the National Bank of Kuwait, the largest commercial bank, was founded. By 1984 there were six regular commercial banks and the Kuwait Finance House (KFH-formed in 1977), all with at least majority Kuwaiti ownership. The KFH accepted deposits and invested funds but operated under sharia (Islamic law); it could neither pay nor receive interest but shared profits from investments with its depositors. Commercial banks often had more deposits than local borrowers and conducted an important part of their business overseas. Local lending was often to reputable persons who posted little collateral and frequently did not make interest payments until they settled their loan accounts in full. Lending by name was common in Kuwait's tight-knit, family-oriented business community. The early focus of commercial banks on foreign-trade financing led to formation of some specialized financial institutions. The government established the Credit and Savings Bank in 1965 to channel funds into domestic projects in industry, agriculture, and housing. The Industrial Bank of Kuwait-49 percent government owned-was created in 1974 to fill the gap in medium- and long-term industrial financing. Private investors formed the Real Estate Bank of Kuwait in 1973. Three large investment companies, in two of which the government held 51 percent or more of the shares, invested public and private funds at home and abroad. In Kuwait's high-income economy a number of persons had funds from which they wanted to earn more than the usual return, and many became wealthy through luck. Real estate has been a frequent means of speculation and became so again in the early 1980s. In the 1970s an informal stock market became another active means of speculation. A crash came in 1977, and the government stepped in and provided a rescue operation for bankrupt investors. Meanwhile, in 1976 an official stock market was formed and by 1984 listed over 40 Kuwaiti firms. Trading was regulated and remained relatively stable. By the later 1970s speculation fever again began to mount. Most attention was focused on the unofficial stock exchange, called Souk al Manakh, which dealt with companies usually registered in Gulf states other than Kuwait. By early 1982 trading was frantic and almost a national pastime. Share dealings using post-dated checks, sometimes a year ahead, created a huge, unregulated expansion of credit. The postdated checks usually included a premium of 100 percent or more to get immediate ownership of the shares. Trust and confidence, or perhaps greed, made the system work. Officials were aware of the activity but possibly not of the magnitude of the speculation. The crash of the unofficial stock market came in August 1982, when a dealer presented a postdated check for payment, which he could do by law, but the issuer of the check lacked funds for payment. A house of cards collapsed. Official investigations revealed that total outstanding checks amounted to the equivalent of US $94 billion (more than three times the GDP), involving about 6,000 investors from all levels of the population. There were ramifications in other areas. In some cases shares from the unofficial market and postdated checks were used in real estate transactions, and bank loans were involved in some speculation; commercial banks claimed they were not seriously affected by the crash. By mid-1984 the complete picture had not been unraveled, the number of bankruptcies clarified, nor the value of many assets and net worth of individuals and firms established. For over a year a substantial part of the population existed in suspended financial animation-conducting business but not sure if they were financially sound or bankrupt. The crash depressed real estate prices, credit demand, and overall business activity in Kuwait; it was a major event that contributed to the country's recession in 1983 and 1984. The largest debtor reportedly owed a gross sum of US $10.5 billion; he was a former passport clerk and not one of the known wealthy. About nine traders accounted for two-thirds of the debt and faced possible criminal prosecution, as did 50 more traders who accounted for much of the remaining debt. At the bottom of the debt pyramid were several thousand small investors, defined as those with liabilities of up to about US $7 million; these were the dealers for groups, such as taxi drivers, hotel clerks, and barbers, who pooled their money to participate. About 300 to 400 persons represented the mid-range of indebtedness. In 1983 government investigators believed that offsetting debts would reduce the balance to be settled to about US $24 billion. If a formula for reducing the premiums included in the postdated checks could be found, the net loss might be around US $7 billion. Meanwhile, the unofficial stock market was closed in September 1982 and use of postdated checks prohibited. (In early 1984, however, journalists reported renewed activity on the unofficial market.) The government established a US $1.8 billion rescue fund to pay cash to holders of checks worth up to US $350,000 and bonds to those holding checks up to about US $7.5 million. The government injected liquidity into the banking system so the bonds could be discounted and, to restore confidence, spent nearly US $2 billion to support shares on the official stock exchange. In addition, loans were made available, to be secured by real property or appropriate collateral, to investors to repay debts arising from postdated checks. By early 1984 the debts from the crash were still not completely clarified, let alone settled. Observers expected bankruptcies and court cases to continue for some years. Apart from the chaos in the unofficial stock market, financial officials have regulated the financial system conservatively. Despite the swings in the country's fortunes, the effects on prices have been moderate. The rate of inflation averaged under 8 percent a year from 1977 to 1982, although this was helped by government subsidies on important goods and services. The consumer price index increased 7.8 percent in 1982, partly because of the increased price of gasoline; it increased 7.3 percent in 1981. Foreign Trade and Balance of Payments Foreign trade always played a key role in the economy of Kuwait. Before the discovery of oil, merchants developed a large transshipment and reexport business, which along with sales of pearls to foreign dealers yielded a substantial part of the population's income. The discovery of large quantities of oil provided a new and increasingly important export, for Kuwait needed only small amounts of petroleum products in its domestic market. Even after the discovery of oil, Kuwait's merchants continued to develop transshipment and reexport business with neighboring countries. The Iran-Iraq War, which broke out in 1980, eroded Kuwait's role as an entrepot. By the early 1980s Kuwait's transshipment and reexport trade with Iraq, an important market, had declined substantially, contributing to Kuwait's recession. Oil dominated Kuwait's exports, accounting in 1980 for 98 percent of the value of exports and 93 percent when reexports were included. The bulk of oil exports were traditionally in the form of crude oil. In the 1970s officials increased refining capacity to gain the value added from exports of refined products. In the early 1980s, as oil exports declined because of the world recession, refined products gained relative to crude oil exports. Officials intended that refined products would be a higher proportion of oil exports in the rest of the 1980s, although the share would depend mostly on the level of total oil exports. Asia was the main market for Kuwait's oil exports, accounting for 55 percent of their value in 1980 (see table 9, Appendix A). Japan purchased the largest amount of Kuwait's oil, followed by Taiwan and the Republic of Korea (South Korea). Countries of the European Economic Community provided the other major market, purchasing 27 percent of Kuwait's oil exports in 1980. Britain, Italy, and the Netherlands were the important customers. Kuwait exported very little oil to the United States. Brazil was the largest importer in the Western Hemisphere. Exports of national products amounted to US $19.3 billion in 1980, and only US $355 million were non-oil commodities. About half of the non-oil commodities were a variety of manufactured goods, such as steel pipe and pre-engineered steel buildings exported largely to nearby countries. The other major non-oil export was chemical products, mainly fertilizer sold to India, China, and other Asian countries. Reexports in 1980 amounted to nearly US $1.2 billion and went primarily to neighboring countries. Reexports were predominantly manufactured goods, of which machinery and transport equipment were by far the most important. Data to determine the extent of the decline of reexports after 1980 were unavailable in mid-1984. Kuwait's large foreign exchange earnings from oil exports and investment income largely removed any constraint on imports. Almost any commodity could be imported, and most import duties were modest. In 1980 imports amounted to US $6.5 billion, continuing the rising trend of the 1970s. Imports grouped in different ways revealed the nature of the economy. Imports for Kuwait's high-income economy were 62 percent finished products in 1980 because of the small manufacturing sector; raw materials accounted for only 9 percent and semifinished products for 29 percent. Imports grouped by intended use in 1980 showed 44 percent for consumption, 17 percent as capital goods, and 39 percent as intermediate commodities requiring further processing or assembly before final use. This latter grouping presented a better insight into the economy than the more commonly used import classification, which lumped many consumer durables, such as cars and appliances, under machinery and equipment (see table 10, Appendix A). Kuwait's imports, which were predominantly finished products, came largely from industrialized countries (see table 11, Appendix A). In 1980 Japan had the largest share of the market (21 percent), followed by the United States (15 percent), the Federal Republic of Germany (West Germany) (9 percent), and Britain (9 percent), which together accounted for more than half of Kuwait's imports. Other West European countries, South Korea, and Taiwan supplied the bulk of the remainder. Kuwait bought mostly live animals, meat, fruits, and vegetables from its Arab neighbors. Modest spending and development policies combined with rising oil revenues, paid in foreign currencies, have largely freed Kuwait from balance of payments worries for more than a decade. The government and individuals accumulated surplus funds in many years, part of whiich was invested abroad. In the early 1980s, as oil revenues fell, earnings from overseas public and private investments supplied foreign currencies so that imports were not restricted other than by slowing government development expenditures. Some economists calculated that by 1982 foreign investment income (public and private) exceeded oil revenues, while others using different accounting procedures calculated that oil revenues still remained higher (see table 12, Appendix A). In any event, investment income had become a very critical supplement to oil revenues to meet the country's balance of payments needs. Income from foreign investments fluctuated, however, depending on foreign interest rates and business activity. Investment income declined in 1982 from the level of the previous year, for example. Between 1980 and 1982 the government stabilized foreign aid, and public and private investors reduced the flow of funds into foreign investments, which also contributed to easing balance of payments pressures from declining oil revenues. Despite sharply changing circumstances, the country maintained a surplus on its balance of payments between 1979 and 1982.