$Unique_ID{COW00425} $Pretitle{266} $Title{Bolivia Chapter 8A. Cultural Life and Mass Communication} $Subtitle{} $Author{Thomas E. Weil} $Affiliation{HQ, Department of the Army} $Subject{national period colonial de bolivia century first country bolivian literary} $Date{1974} $Log{} Country: Bolivia Book: Bolivia, A Country Study Author: Thomas E. Weil Affiliation: HQ, Department of the Army Date: 1974 Chapter 8A. Cultural Life and Mass Communication Bolivia's physical isolation from the trading posts of culture is reflected in its artistic and intellectual traditions. Most of the important international currents have eventually made their way to La Paz, but only those that have been adaptable to the expression of the Bolivian historical experience or social conditions have been embraced and assimilated. Although the Hispanic cultural elites now take great pride in the archaeological remains of pre-Columbian cultures and manifest a sense of urgency about recording the legends and the music of the Indians that have been passed down orally from generation to generation, the original Spanish colonizers disrupted and repressed indigenous creative efforts and implanted an alien culture. Development in literature and the arts, however, was scanty and halting until the beginning of the twentieth century. Most of the literature of the colonial period consisted of either religious speculation or historical chronicling, and there was no printing press in the whole of Upper Peru (encompassing part of present-day Peru and Bolivia) until the eve of independence in 1825. The graphic arts and music of the period were generally imitative in both style and subject matter. The nineteenth century produced some outstanding historical works, but it was not until the early twentieth century that writers began to take a critical look at the society of which they were a part. What began as a literary revulsion against the status quo developed, after the Chaco War (1932-35), into a glorification of the downtrodden Indian and an impetus for revolutionary change. The Indian, conscripted to fight and die in a war he did not understand in order to preserve the prerogatives of an alien exploitative elite, became the protagonist of innumerable novels and interpretive historical treatises. Whether these writers were highly influential as precursors of the revolution or were merely reflective of a national mood is still being debated by historians, but their importance in the development of a national literary tradition is well established. The focus on the Indian in his natural and societal environment spread in the 1930s and 1940s from literature into painting and sculpture with the assistance of stylistic borrowings from the Mexican muralist school. The figurative approach that prevailed in the earlier nativist or indigenist works had lost ground by the 1960s to abstract expressionism, but the themes remained the same. The country has never developed a strong tradition in classical music, although the incorporation of native music into some compositions has broadened its appeal. Folk expression in music and dance, on the other hand, has flourished; its vitality is particularly manifest in festivals, often unique to a city or region, involving elaborate costumes and imaginative choreography. Postrevolutionary governments, especially in the 1950s and early 1960s, have made some attempts to underwrite the efforts of artists and scholars, to disseminate their works to a broader audience, and to expose the educated classes to the country's rich folkloric tradition. Nevertheless, the cultural gap between the intelligentsia and the masses they choose to depict and seek to influence remains immense. In the early 1970s some observers maintained that creative efforts had been stymied both by lack of interest and by selective limitations on freedom of expression. Seasoned writers and critics have lamented that today's educated young people are more prone to express their passion for social justice and national identity through direct political action than through literature and the arts. Furthermore, since the advent of the government of President Hugo Banzer Suarez, many members of the intelligentsia-who had generally been critical of that government-were imprisoned or went into exile or hiding. Development of mass communication has long been inhibited by geographic, linguistic, and social barriers. Such progress as was made after 1952 in reducing social and linguistic barriers was largely attributable to the government's efforts to integrate the isolated Indian population into the national society and to promote literacy in Spanish. In 1973, however, the proportion of total illiteracy remained high, and many people who were marginally literate were insufficiently educated to read a newspaper (see ch. 6). The limitations on dissemination of information by the written word were illustrated by the fact that in La Paz, a city with a population of more than 500,000, the total circulation of the five daily newspapers was estimated at 90,000. In 1973 radio, which reached the majority of the country's population, was by far the most important mass medium. Nevertheless, in many areas word-of-mouth communication continued to serve as a significant channel for the dissemination of information and the exchange of ideas. In 1973 there was no formal censorship of the press, and some criticism of the government appeared in newspapers. Actions had been taken against selected journalists and periodicals, however, and a number of leftist periodicals that had been circulated during the 1950s and 1960s were no longer published. Artistic and Intellectual Expression The Colonial Heritage The mineral wealth of the colony gave it an economic and political importance that contributed greatly to its artistic and intellectual development. A large colonial administration, the prospect of financial gain, the opportunity for political advancement, and the influx of Spanish priests, to meet the spiritual needs of white and indigenous elements, converted the colony into a thriving population center. With this growth in size came the need for the construction of municipal, domestic, and religious buildings. In turn, the monumental development of colonial cities stimulated the production of the decorative arts-painting and sculpture. The church and its representatives did not limit themselves to educational activities but served alongside the elite as promoters of the arts by supplying commissions for artists and architects. In literary and intellectual activity the church was the important single factor; early musical development also depended upon its efforts. During the conquest, Gregorian chants were introduced by the priests. Musical instruments, initially imported from Spain, were soon produced in the colony. In many cases the missionary program of the Spanish priests resulted in the development of Indian choruses that reached a relatively high degree of technical ability and also incorporated something of their own music into Western modes. In higher social circles musical preference was for pure Spanish styles. Young ladies from the upper classes learned to play the harp, lyre, and guitar in the convent schools. For the general public musical experience was limited to the religious procession, popular street music, and military marches. In contrast to the limited musical activity, the cultivation of the plastic arts was great. Architecture, foremost of the plastic arts, reached its peak in the eighteenth century. Whereas both Potosi and Cochabamba were important colonial centers, Potosi, the heart of mineral wealth, was the site of the grandest architectural achievements. The early Renaissance plateresque style, with its light, intricate, superficial decoration, was adopted first, but in the seventeenth century-the period of Potosi's greatest economic power-the more impressive baroque flourished. Superimposed on the baroque and plateresque structures, the decorative details clearly show the hand of the Indian and mestizo workmen who realized the plans of Spanish and criollo architects. The sculptural work of the period was limited to religious artifacts, architectural decoration, and furniture carving. The artisans, mostly Indians and mestizos, were organized into guilds, following the medieval Spanish example. Silver, wood, and stone were the most commonly used materials. The practice of carving life-sized wooden statues, popular in Spain during the seventeenth century, was also cultivated in the colony. Native ceramics were encouraged by the Spaniards and reached a high degree of quality. A great deal less is known about painting in colonial Bolivia, but significant schools apparently did exist, particularly in Chuquisaca (Sucre); Jusepe Pastorelo, a painter and sculptor who worked on the retable of the Cathedral of Chuquisaca, is one of the few known artists from the first half of the seventeenth century. The blossoming of a truly brilliant school took place in Chuquisaca during the second half of the century, inspired largely by the arrival of Spanish paintings from Seville. The subject matter is predominantly religious, but historical paintings also exist. The outstanding figure in colonial painting, Melchor Perez de Holguin, unknown until recently, comes from this period. In his work there is a definite influence of the Spaniards Bartolome Esteban Murillo, famous for his gentle, luminous virgins and children, and Francisco Zurbaran, painter of mystics and monks. Although Spanish colonial policy always favored the subordination of culture to political needs, the development of the fine arts was unaffected since there was no conflict. Such was not the case with literary and intellectual activity. Initially Protestant ideology was the threat, and the Inquisition, established in Spain to combat it, was instituted in the colony as well. Although the colonial Inquisition tended to be less rigorous, it too restricted the sale and production of books on political and religious matters. The suppression of dangerous political ideas became particularly significant in the late eighteenth century with the rise of the Encyclopedists and the American and French revolutions. Colonial intellectuals and writers laborer under the handicap of enforced isolation from contemporary European currents of thought and the lack of printing facilities, but they did have extensive classical libraries, and locally written manuscripts did circulate. Some manuscripts were also published in Spain. The main literary effort of colonial writers, the majority of whom were monks and priests, was directed toward the production of chronicles and histories. In addition to accounts of postconquest life and events, much of what was written concerned Inca legend and history. From their contact with the Indian, missionary writers developed a great deal of sympathy for him and often defended his way of life. Padre Jose de Acosta, considered by Bolivians the first colonial writer, reveals such an attitude in his Historia Natural y Moral de Las Indias (Natural and Moral History of the Indies). Knowledge of the Indian languages led some Spanish priests to write valuable grammars and dictionaries of Aymara and Quechua. After the revolutionary period interest and concern for the Indian was not revived until the twentieth century (see ch. 4). The important city of Potosi had its chronicler in Nicolas Martinez Arzanz y Vela, who offers a picture of colonial life in Historia de la Villa Imperial de Potosi (History of the Imperial City of Potosi). The first self-taught Upper Peruvian and also the most outstanding writer of the colonial period, Fray Antonio de la Calancha wrote about the work of his own order, the Augustines, in Cronica Moralizada (Moralized Chronicle). A humanist, Calancha, like the other writers of the period, reflects the influence of neoclassicism and scholasticism in colonial letters. In addition to producing the most outstanding writers of the period, the church and its representatives were also responsible for colonial education. The Jesuits, well known for their independence, were the most active in this area and crowned their activities with the establishment of the university in Chuquisaca in 1624. Intellectual life revolved around this university, and its influence extended beyond the confines of the colony. Located in the same city as the powerful Audiencia de Charcas, which held dominion over the area comprehending all Spanish territory south of Lake Titicaca, it became the most important intellectual center in lower South America, attracting students with both political and scholastic ambitions from all over the region. Its studies in philosophy centered on the Aristotelian doctrines of Saint Thomas Aquinas, modified by the interpretation of Francisco Suarez. Suarist contributions included such ideas as royal subordination to law and the justice of regicide in cases where the king transgressed against popular rights. This thinking became useful to revolutionaries at the turn of the nineteenth century as an ideological basis for the justification of their actions (see ch. 2). By the second half of the eighteenth century, the ferment of ideas had reached its peak. During the reign of Charles III a greater freedom was allowed, permitting some of the works of the Encyclopedists to enter the colony. Their ideas, the ideas of empiricists and naturalists against tradition and authority, were quickly associated with and absorbed into earlier doctrines of Suaristic Thomism. Especially popular was Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Social Contract, the most influential work in Bolivia. Although Bolivia was the last South American country to achieve independence, intellectually-through the groups centered in the University of Chuquisaca-it had been a forerunner. The Evolution of a National Culture From the activity of the colonial period, Bolivian artistic and intellectual life lapsed into a period of inertia that lasted until the latter part of the nineteenth century. With the departure of the Spaniards, the country became preoccupied with national consolidation and was more isolated than ever before (see ch. 2). Literary activity was limited in general to the production of pamphlets and small publications concerned with the issues of the day. A few of the early governments tried to stimulate national culture. By official decree Antonio Jose de Sucre had made Destutt de Tracy's Ideology, based on the principles of the French Encyclopedia, required reading in the secondary schools, and Simon Rodriguez, who had spent a considerable length of time in Paris, set up a model school that was to inaugurate the transformation of society by education. Both efforts were of short duration. Jose Ballivian's administration also attempted to give impetus to cultural affairs. At that time the national theater appeared, and performances were well received. In 1833 Andres Santa Cruz had offered large bonuses to any foreign musicians who would come to the country and take on at least two disciples, but it was not until 1845, under Ballavian, that one did arrive, the Italian Benedetto Vincenti. In the same year he wrote the Bolivian national anthem. After these official endeavors came nearly thirty years of rule by the so-called caudillos barbaros (barbarous strong men), who were no more than military adventurers and warlords and showed no concern for cultural affairs. Around midcentury the ideological climate in Bolivia changed greatly. Eclecticism, more a method for the selection of ideas from a wide variety of sources than a philosophy in itself, enjoyed great acceptance and diffusion in Bolivia. This period marks the appearance of the first artistic and literary movement in the country, romanticism. The Spanish influence was not lost, but the French was by far the stronger. Largely imitative, the work produced in this style is significant, with few exceptions, from a historical point of view alone. The movement's first manifestations were in political oratory and poetry. Political oratory in Bolivia, as in other Latin American countries, was a popular and frequently practiced art; Santiago Vaca Guzman's literary history-published in the 1880s-devotes a whole chapter to it. Poetry became the most widely cultivated literary form with the advent of romanticism. Quantity did not mean quality, however, and of the many poets produced during the period, only Ricardo Jose Bustamante is notable. Of far greater significance was the novel, which made its first appearance in national letters with the romantics. In the indigenous literature there had been no form similar to the novel; during the colonial epoch Spanish works were read but not imitated by the criollos. The first novel written by a Bolivian, Sebastian Delanze, did not appear until 1861. Delanze's novel, a superficial copy of the French style, was followed by a number of equally imitative and undistinguished works whose authors, in accordance with the romantic tradition, preferred exotic, faraway settings to the national scene. It is noteworthy that during the long period of romanticism, which encompassed the terms of fifteen presidents, a shift from Conservative to Liberal rule, and two wars, nothing of Bolivian reality was reflected in the fictional literature. The romantic spirit, with its interest in evoking the past, gave rise to the historical novel. Nataniel Aguirre's Juan de la Rosa, set in the independence era, is regarded by many as the first Bolivian novel in the sense that its subject matter was specifically Bolivian. In addition to being a novelist, Aguirre was one of the country's few noteworthy playwrights. During the colonial period dramatic representations had been almost exclusively religious in theme and very simple technically. Although there was some original work, in general, what little was performed had been imported from Spain. There is some confusion as to which was the first play written in Bolivia, but many cite Odio y Amor (Hate and Love) by the sentimental poet, Serapio Reyes Ortiz, which was staged in 1859. Early theatrical development faced many obstacles, and politics-the constant antagonist of intellectual activity-often worked to its detriment. There was also a lack of performers and of an interested public large enough to give support sufficient to maintain those involved. The static conditions of the early republican period were even more obvious in the plastic arts. Painting, the first to emerge after independence, was the most widely cultivated, although it never approached the dimensions that it enjoyed during the colonial era. Early republican works still showed a preference for the old religious themes. Gradually historic scenes and portraits, particularly of national heroes, began to appear. As in most young countries, there was a desire to set down the national past and its protagonists on canvas; these paintings imitated the stiff, sterile styles of European so-called official art. During the second half of the century a kind of romanticism, which differed from the European mode in its patriotic fervor, arose to displace classicism. Although religious themes were still in evidence, portraits were now predominant. Architecture, the crowning achievement of colonial plastic art, fell into a decline from which it has still not recovered. The few major buildings that were completed in the early years of independence had been begun a number of years before and continued the colonial styles. Throughout the century architecture was imitative; it followed the European periods of classicism and French romanticism and showed Italian influence in religious structures and academic effect in civil works. Without the extensive monumental activity that had characterized the colonial era, sculpture deteriorated greatly. Romanticism, which continued well into the twentieth century, lasted longer in Bolivia than in most other Latin American countries. After the country's defeat in the War of the Pacific in 1883, however, new attitudes developed and with them a generation that found romanticism unrelated to its interests. Bolivians were made conscious of their nationality and wanted to explore realistically and systematically the various aspects of their own country. The old traditionalist, eclectic, and spiritualist philosophies, which had so adequately complemented the romantic literary and artistic trend, could not provide a suitable ideological context for these new goals and attitudes. Consequently, they took up the more practical, humanistic positivism, which had already spread to the rest of South America. With its predilection for science and belief in the power of man to shape his future through the application of the scientific method, the philosophy generated a spirit of optimism and practicality that was quickly adapted to politics by the more progressive elements. Politically, the triumph of positivism came after the Liberal revolution of 1899. The ensuing twenty-year period of Liberal government was characterized by mild social reforms (which did not profoundly change national life) and increased commercial activity (which complemented the materialism and practicality of positivism). Positivism remained largely an intellectual concern, however, and it never directly involved the main body of the population (see ch. 2). The inclination of the postwar generation toward national themes marked the real beginning of Bolivian arts and letters. The shift in orientation and consistently increasing activity did not, however, constitute a complete or immediate transformation. The new interests were held only by the same small group that had always controlled the economy and politics. The most notable literary product of the period between the War of the Pacific and the War of Acre in 1899 was the didactic prose of a group of writers who worked in the spheres of journalism, science, and the humanities and whose common goal was to explore Bolivia-past and present. They were loosely united in a school that Fernando Diez de Medina has called the Indagadores, or Searchers. Some chose to deal with the traditions, customs, and way of life of the country in reaction against the romantic poetry and novels that still constituted the great body of fiction; others dealt with national history and jurisprudence, the natural sciences, geography, geology, and archaeology. The first literary history, which was written by Vaca Guzman, appeared in the 1880s. Scientific activity was stimulated by the efforts of Augustin Aspiazu, who wrote on the natural sciences, medicine, jurisprudence, and economics. Aspiazu was also prominent in some of the numerous cultural and scientific societies that began to appear in the last two decades of the century. A few of the societies put out publications, and there were also unaffiliated literary and cultural magazines like Daniel Sanchez Bustamante's La Revista de Bolivia in Sucre. This period also saw the rise of musical organizations like the Haydn Society of La Paz-the first group devoted to the cultivation of classical music-the Philharmonic Society of Sucre, and the Academy of Military Music in La Paz. The historian Gabriel Rene-Moreno is regarded by many Bolivians as the greatest writer of the period. Before the War of the Pacific, Rene-Moreno had attempted negotiation with Chile on behalf of his country and, for failing to settle the differences that ultimately led to the war, he was accused of being a traitor. The bitter, strongly critical attitude that pervades his work had its origin in his unfortunate political involvement. Rene-Moreno dealt with sociological analysis, political criticism, and biographical study, but his most significant contribution was in the field of history. His Los ultimos dias coloniales en el Alto Peru (The Last Days of the Colony in Upper Peru) is the best work done on that period. In addition to a generally critical attitude toward Bolivia, one of the most notable characteristics of Rene-Moreno's work is the strong prejudice against the Indian. He was a native of Santa Cruz, whose homogeneous population was extremely proud of its reputedly pure Spanish heritage. For him the indigenous inhabitants of the country were of no value, and the pre-Hispanic past was completely negligible. Although Bolivians reject Rene-Moreno's negative attitude toward the Indian and his colonial mentality, they respect his great contribution to national letters and have honored him by giving his name to the university in Santa Cruz. The investigative inclination that began with the Indagadores continued in the first decades of the twentieth century, but prose fiction and poetry also reappeared as important literary elements. Two parallel currents tended to work simultaneously during the period. In the novel social realism was dominant, and in poetry the most outstanding work was done by the modernists. Receptive to the realist school of Europe, novelists began to describe city and country life from a social point of view. In 1911 the problem of the miners was first introduced in Jaime Mendoza's En Las Tierras de Potosi (In the Lands of Potosi). A later work, Paginas Barbaras (Savage Pages), dealt with the rubber collectors and life in the northeastern part of the country. One of the best novels to come out of Latin America in the early twentieth century was Armando Chirveche's La Candidatura de Rojas (The Candidacy of Rojas), which concerns rural political life. A theme that was to become paramount in subsequent years, indigenism, was initiated in 1919 in the Bolivian novel with Raza de bronce (Bronze Race) by Alcides Arguedas. One of the few writers known outside the country, Arguedas later turned to historical and sociological themes, as in Vida Criolla (Criollo Life) and Pueblo Enfermo (A Sick People), which were critical studies of city life at the turn of the century. In his own time, Arguedas' novels were well received, but today his criticism is considered too harsh. The continuing Indagador school was also susceptible to sociological and indigenist material. Prehistoric culture was described in Belisario Diaz Romero's Tiahuanaco, and Bautista Saavedra wrote on Indian sociology in El Ayllu. Rigoberto Paredes also took up the question from the cultural viewpoint in Mitos, Supersticiones y Supervivencias Populares de Bolivia (Popular Myths, Superstitions, and Survivals [from ancient customs] of Bolivia). Although inspired by French symbolism, modernism was Latin America's first original contribution to international literature. With its emphasis on physical beauty, exotic settings, sensuous vocabulary, and universalism, modernism represented the antithesis of realism. In Bolivia its outstanding cultivators were Ricardo Jaimes Freyre and Franz Tamayo. Freyre, well known throughout the continent, was one of the earliest modernist poets. He and the Nicaraguan poet Ruben Dario founded the Revista de America in 1894. Three years after Dario published his Prosas Profanas (Profane Prose), considered the first manifestation of the movement, Freyre's Castalia Barbara (Bold Castalia) appeared. Tamayo, although less well known outside the country, holds a more exalted position at present, probably because of his admiration for the Indians. Whereas Arguedas had emphasized their misery, he emphasized their nobility. Like Freyre, who had held diplomatic posts, Tamayo was involved in politics and fulfilled the duties of minister of state, parliamentarian, and diplomat. In addition to poetry, Tamayo occasionally wrote prose works. One of his best known and most important contributions was Creacion de la Pedagogia Nacional (Creation of the National Pedagogy), an analysis of the Indian and mestizo. Although realism never became a popular literature, it stimulated a more widespread interest, whereas modernism remained the possession of a very small cultured minority. After World War I, attention was not so heavily concentrated on social themes and national interests. In Europe and North America the postwar period produced radical new movements in art, literature, and philosophy. This was the period of "isms" with wide divergence in artistic tendencies and ideological orientation. In Bolivia there was something of this spirit, although the intensity and scope were, quite naturally, not nearly so great as in areas where the war had had a direct effect. In the late 1920s and early 1930s, before the Chaco War, Marxism won adherents in intellectual circles, where a logical explanation of Bolivian history was sought in dialectical materialism. Marxism's social concerns also struck an appealing note for those who were interested in the problems that had inspired the realists. The Aprista Party in Peru was another influence; in 1927 one of its writers, Manuel A. Seoane, published a book dealing with the problems of the Indians and the privileged position of the mining oligarchy in Bolivia. Evidence of intense nationalism in literary circles increased in the late 1920s and finally exploded after the Chaco War. Most of the members of literary groups, such as Potosi's Gesta Barbara, soon became absorbed in public affairs; but Carlos Medinacelli, initiator of modern criticism in the country, was the exception. Medinacelli's novel La Chaskanahui (Starry Eyes) and Antonio Diaz Villamil's La Nina de sus Ojos (The Apple of His Eye) were the best cholo (see Glossary) narrations written in Bolivia. Diaz Villamil was the most productive talent of the generation; in addition to novels, he also wrote didactic prose, history, short stories, criticism, and plays. The stimulus for increased theatrical activity came from Youth Athenaeum (Ateneo de la Juventud), a group that appeared in 1922. Organized primarily to protest the lack of organization and effective contribution of the country's intellectuals, the Youth Athenaeum felt that the state of so-called collective culture might be improved by bringing intellectuals together. Its manifesto was followed by the penetration of members into diverse cultural centers of the country. Under the influence of the Youth Athenaeum, groups with more specific interests were formed. One was the Women's Athenaeum (Ateneo Femenino), the first women's organization with intellectual goals. Its activities were politicocultural in nature and concentrated on raising the cultural level of the Bolivian woman and on campaigning for women's suffrage. These groups continued to flourish, and by the 1960s there were approximately forty of them throughout the country. The stimulation that the Youth Athenaeum had given to the theater resulted in the formation of the Bolivian Society of Playwrights (Sociedad Boliviana de Autores Teatrales). It was their wish to promote drama, to improve the economic status of artists, and to create a real national stage art. Many of the numerous productions reached the stage, but few were ever published. In theme they generally tended toward national or local subjects with a popular flavor, but there was still some interest in social problems and in moralizing. Information on developments in music is scant, but it is known that two dance academies were founded in the period. Events in the plastic arts were of much greater significance. There had been a few small private academies that were started in the first decade of the century by artists like Avelino Nogales and Elisa Roche de Ballivian-advocates of the realist school that had succeeded romanticism in painting as well as in literature. In 1926 the National Academy of Fine Arts was founded. Its first professors were Alejandro Guardio, Humberto Beltran de Oliveira, both sculptors trained in the European classical tradition, and the French painter Henri Sene. Although the two sculptors had studied abroad, they were not influenced by the new trends that were revolutionizing the form. By bringing together a group of young people who were eager to revitalize the plastic arts the national academy laid the foundation for a new Bolivian school. Under the tutelage of the painter Cecilio Guzman de Rojas, who acted as its director in 1930, the students found a leader who established the direction the arts would take in subsequent years. Contemporary Trends The young generation of artists was moved by the same spirit that was shaping writers, intellectuals, and musicians-artistic nationalism. Their desire was not just to deal with Bolivian subjects as literature as the Indagadores had done but also to create something distinctly Bolivian in form. Although the scholarly approach was continued, there was an increasing tendency to exploit national themes for their own sake, particularly in the fine arts. Social themes, introduced by the realists of the first twenty years of the century, came into great prominence. They were inspired by the revolutions in Mexico and Russia, the intellectual Marxism of the twenties, and the internal economic state of the period. The Chaco War brought together many elements of the population and contributed to a better defined sense of national identity. The Bolivian defeat was seen as the culmination of the shortcomings of the old order. In an atmosphere of frustration, discontent, and political instability, the postwar generation envisioned a new Bolivia, wrought by social reform, whose particular character would emerge with the spiritual and artistic return to the indigenous. Foreign trends were simply of no consequence, except when related to national interests. In the discovery and exaltation of indigenous folklore and folk art, the appearance of regionalism and indigenism, and the cultivation of social themes in literature and painting, Bolivia has closely paralleled developments in twentieth-century Mexico. The intensity and wide acceptance on all social levels of these movements in Mexico, however, has not been characteristic of Bolivia. Although sentiment was strong, it was still limited generally to the younger generation of the same small group that had always produced the country's artists, intellectuals, and writers.