X-15 OPERATIONS FLIGHT REPORT



FLIGHT NO: 2-31-52 DATE OF REPORT: November 16, 1962

PILOT: John B. McKay DATE OF FLIGHT: November 9, 1962

CARRIER AIRCRAFT: B-52 #003 LAUNCH LAKE: Mud Lake

ROCKET ENGINE: S/N #103

PURPOSE OF FLIGHT: Ventral Off Stability and Aerodynamic Boundary Layer

Investigation

I. Discussion of Previous Operations

A. Igniter Detonation: It was concluded by the Accident Investigation Committee that the cause of the detonations was mixing of propellants in the 2nd stage LOX injector due to sudden drop in injector pressure during a LOX depletion shutdown. (For complete details see separate accident report).

Pending design and qual testing of a permanent fix, it was agreed that the flight program could continue provided that LOX depletion shutdowns were avoided. To insure against a LOX run out, fuel was off loaded during servicing by jacking the B-52 so as to obtain an X-15 attitude of 4° nose up during fuel servicing. By using this method the total fuel load was reduced by approximately 76 gallons.

II. Aircraft Configuration Changes A. Removed 12~ purge line and check valve from 2nd stage igniter pressure system and capped line to reduce line detonation probability.

B. Relocated following switches in cockpit in accord with agreed upon "Standard X-15" configuration:

1. RAS

2. ASAS

3. Ready to launch

4. Intercom

5. Face mask heat

6. Longitudinal trim

7. Jettison trim

C. Replaced both APU's with units which had been given special 4 hour qualification run and pinion gear inspection.
III. Instrumentation Changes A. Installed boundary layer pressure rakes at Sta 40, and at Sta 70. IV. Preflight Events A. The first flight attempt on November 7, 1962 was canceled after servicing due to a leaking NH3 safety valve. The valve was replaced and the X-15 reserviced for flight on the following day. Cloud cover in the launch area forced cancellation of this second attempt just prior to takeoff. The X-15 was launched on the third try which took place Friday, November 9, 1962. V. Flight Events The pilot was unable to obtain full thrust after launch. Approximately 30% thrust was the maximum obtained. On instruction from ground control, the pilot cut off the engine, jettisoned NH3 and LOX and made an emergency landing at Mud Lake. On final approach, the wing flaps failed to operate and the resulting "hot" landing caused landing gear failure. The LH horizontal stabilizer and wing dug in causing a hard left yaw and the X-15 finally came to rest in the inverted position. Fortunately the pilot had jettisoned the canopy during tile rollout and pilot rescue was achieved without too much difficulty. Pilot injuries were not serious. The X-15 was returned to EAFB by truck on November 12, 1962. A detail investigation of the accident is underway and a final report will be issued by the accident board. Preliminary results of the investigation to date are as follows: 1. The rocket engine governor actuator failed, resulting in a maximum attainable thrust of about 30%.

2. The landing flap motor clutch release torque was checked, after return of the X-15 to Edwards, and found to be considerably below spec. (15-18 in/lbs compared to a spec value of 9O in/lbs). Clutch release at this low torque could have caused the landing flap failure.

Assessment of the damage to the X-15 is underway and a time and cost estimate of the repair is being prepared by NAA.
 
 
 
 
Approve By: Prepared by:

Perry V. Row William P. Albrecht

X-15 Senior Project Engineer X-15 Project Engineer

X-15 OPERATIONS FLIGHT REPORT SUPPLEMENT



FLIGHT NO: 2-31-52 DATE OF REPORT: May 22, 1964

PILOT: John B. McKay DATE OF FLIGHT: November 9, 1962

CARRIER AIRCRAFT: B-52 #003 LAUNCH LAKE: Mud Lake

ROCKET ENGINE: S/N #103

PURPOSE OF FLIGHT: Ventral Off Stability and Aerodynamic Boundary Layer

Investigation

This X-15 Operations Flight Report is a supplement to the last flight report written for X-15-2, dated November 16, 1962, following the crash landing on Mud Lake. It is the purpose of this supplement to fill in the long gap in time between that last report and the first flight of the rebuilt X-15-2 and provide, for the record, a brief resume' of the noteworthy events during this period, and a definition of the rebuilt X-15-2 configuration.
The historical resume' follows with events listed in chronological order:

1. November 12, 1962. Salvaged vehicle was returned to NASA Edwards by flatbed truck.

2. November 15, 1962. Accident Board was officially designated with D. R. Bellman as chairman. Findings of the Accident Board were subsequently released in a detailed report which was distributed during December 1962.

3. November 15, 1962 through December 6, 1962. Survey of reusable hardware from X-15-2 was carried on. Airframe components common to the remaining two X-15 vehicles were returned to NAA for repair under PRR system chargeable against the Call Contract. Separate listing of these components was maintained to assure immediate availability in the event that a decision was made to repair the vehicle.

4. December 7, 1962. Remains of X-15-2 were delivered by truck to the NAA Inglewood Factory for a 5 week examination period, during which NAA was requested to prepare a Time and Cost Proposal for repair, to be submitted at the end of the 5 weeks.

5. January, 1963. NAA submitted a proposal for rebuilding the X-15-2 and providing an increase in maximum speed to Mach 8, along with provisions for future installation of a 30" hydrogen ramjet prototype engine, for testing.

6. May 10, 1963. Official go-ahead was given by the government to NAA to proceed with the rebuilding of X-15-2 in accord with the proposal which called for completion in 39 weeks. A "Task Force" organization of engineers, planners, materials control personnel and manufacturing personnel was already in operation at NAA under the direction of H. A. Evans to accomplish the work.

7. June 5 through June 7, 1963. A meeting was held at NAA to resolve contractual details related to certain NASA requested items to be added on to the contract. Primary items on this list were:
 

(a) Updating of instrumentation systems

(b) E0 incorporation

(c) Startracker installation

(d) Removable right hand wing panel

(e) Several minor design changes originated by NASA
 

The list was approved and subsequently a contract change notice was issued by the government increasing the rebuild time from 39 to 43 weeks to accommodate the additional items. Pertinent details of the progress of rebuilding are contained in a series of informal status reports published throughout the middle and end of 1963.

8. February 15, 1964. X-15-2 was completed in final assembly at NAA and accepted by the AF exactly three weeks ahead of schedule. Delivery was made to NASA, EAFB, on Tuesday, February 18, 1962, and an "official" government acceptance for the press was held on Monday, February 24, 1964.

Since that date X-15-2 has been undergoing rigging, updating and calibration in preparation for the first flight in its new configuration.

This completes the historical resume' that spans the time between the crash of X-15-2 and its redelivery at EAFB.

Following is a list of the configuration changes made during the rebuilding period: 1. Fuselage lengthened by adding 29" cylindrical section in midsection between main Lox & NH3 tanks.

2. Tankage & pressurization system for 90 gallons (80 usable) of liquid hydrogen added to 29" additional fuselage midsection. Tankage consists of 2 equally sized vacuum tanks plumbed in series.

3. Side fairings extended onto tail cone approximately 15 inches to accommodate 2 of 4 auxiliary H2O2 tanks.

4. Tankage & pressurization system for 40 gallons auxiliary H202 added in aft side fairing area. Tankage consists of 4 equal spheres plumbed in series with main (existing) engine H202 tank.

5. Provisions added to accommodate Lox & NH3 drop tanks, slung directly under wing root, Lox tank on LH side and NH3 tank on RH side. Tank ejection system features redundant pyrotechnics to unlatch hooks, and to provide gas pressure for ejector pistons to accelerate tank downward, with negative pitch angle. Ejection system may be operated automatically (by a timer, sensing main chamber pressure) or manually by the pilot. The automatic system may be disarmed by the pilot. The manual system has positive override of the automatic system at any time.

Lox drop tank capacity is 767 gallons (7494 lbs).

NH3 drop tank capacity is 1053 gallons (6006 lbs).

Drop tank propellants feed directly to their respective main propellant tanks and not into the engine feed lines.

6. Lower fixed ventral stub made removable to provide for future installation of pylon for mounting ramjet prototype engines for flight test. (Actual installation of candidate ramjets has not been designed as yet).

7. Main landing gear redesigned and lengthened to provide ground clearance for landing with 30" dia. ramjet in place of lower ventral, and also to increase strength of gear for heavier landing weight.

8. Stroke of nose gear increased 4.0 inches to accommodate greater landing weight.

9. Windshield redesigned to incorporate a third (outer): layer of fused silica glass to provide protection against aerodynamic heating at Mach numbers above 6. Elliptical shape used to decrease stress concentrations.

10. Provisions for Startracker experiment installed. This item consists of equipment installations in the elevator area, pilot controls added to the panel on the LH canopy longeron, and the "flip-top" door system in the elevator bay hatch.

11. RH wing outer panel made removable to provide for special test panel installations. Removable wing skin sections provided in outer panel to permit installation of instruments within wing, for structural research data.

12. Shackles increased in strength to accommodate greater gross weight while hanging on B-52 pylon. B-52 pylon and wing structure was also beefed-up and new heavier hooks incorporated to take the increased weight.

13. Ground servicing provisions for propellant systems relocated to clear drop tank installation hardware and improve crew access.

14. Miscellaneous "updating" items were incorporated. A list of these items follows:
 

(a) Pilot's Instr. Panel updated

(b) Seat Initiator "Hose Cutter" relocated from top of canopy to RH side of fuselage

(c) APU Gearcase Pressurization installed (E)-836964)

(d) Aux Face Mask Heater installed (EO-825962)

(e) Flap Teleflex Line Heaters installed (EO-852860)

(f) Flap Motor rework (EO-852854)

(g) Flap Teleflex degreasing (EO-804566)

(h) SAS Cutoff Switch on Main Gear installed

(i) Flap Circuit moved to Battery Bus

(j) Additional Skin Pressure Orifices installed in RH wing and fuselage for research data

(k) Additional Strain Gages & Thermocouples added for research data.

(1) General updating of NASA instrumentation in accord with current NASA developments was accomplished

(m) Miscellaneous NAA EO's were incorporated. Separate list is maintained by Operations (selected EO's of a general interest are listed above)

Following delivery of X-15-2 to Edwards, additional modifications to the configuration were made by NASA. Since the first several flights will not involve speeds beyond Mach 6, certain of the features listed above have been deleted to save weight, or improve serviceability and reliability. These deletions plus other configuration changes made after delivery to NASA are listed below: 1. The following items have been deleted:
  (a) Drop tanks & certain associated valving & plumbing

(b) LH2 tanks & certain associated valving

(c) Auxiliary H2O2 tanks & feed system
 

2. The lengthened main landing gear has been replaced with a short gear since the added clearance for ramjet installations will not be required for some time. The short gear will give improved structural margins for the landing condition, and will permit safe landing of X-15-2 with flaps up.

3. Engine auxiliary purge system added to permit "Lox Burnout" engine operation.

4. Provisions for two 12 cell manometers installed in place of LH2 tanks, in fuselage mid section.

5. Hycon installation removed from fuselage mid section (reactivation of the Hycon program is expected later this year, at which time that equipment will be reinstalled).

6. SAS emergency pump has been modified to permit greater overspeed tolerance without shutdown, insuring improved reliability at high input pressures.

7. Escape system pip circuit added for T/M recording.

8. Nose and main gear CPT instrumentation added.

As of the date of this report, the X-15-2 has entered preflight status. Rigging and calibration have been completed and post delivery "squawks" have been worked off.

Preflight activities will be covered as part of the next report to be issued following flight 2-32-54.
 

Approve By: Prepared by:

Perry V. Row William P. Albrecht

X-15 Senior Project Engineer X-15 Project Engineer