X-15 OPERATIONS FLIGHT REPORT



FLIGHT NO: 1-29-50 DATE OF REPORT: 6-13-62

PILOT: J. A. Walker DATE OF FLIGHT: 6-7-62

CARRIER AIRCRAFT: B-52 #003 LAUNCH LAKE: Hidden Hills

I. Discussion of Problem Areas Prior to and Including Flight 1-29-50.

A. Cockpit Leakage

Most recent conditions on X-15-1 indicate a relatively rapid deterioration in cabin leakage over several flights to approximately 70 CFM with a diminishing rate in the range of 70 to 80 CFM. A summary of cockpit leakage rates is presented below:

Date Event Results

1/10/62 1-25-44 Increase from 58.5 CFM to 72 CFM during flight
     
2/15/62 - 3/28/62 (Extensive resealing) 

Reduced leakage to 53 CFM.

 
     
4/18/62 1-A-45  
     
4/19/62 1-26-46 80-90 CFM post flight.

(Proved to be in error due to GSE.)

     
4/27/62 1-A-47  
     
4/30/62 1-27-48 78.5 CFM post flight.
     
5/7/62 - 5/18/62 (Limited resealing and clamping of large wire bundles reduced leakage to 72 CFM.)  
     
5/22/62 1-28-49 73 CFM post flight.
     
6/7/62 1-29-50 76.6 CFM post flight.
B. Fuel vent valve leakage through the vent port.

During flight 1-28-49 fuel leakage was noted by the Chase One aircraft. Leakage ceased following tank pressurization. Subsequent operation during the flight was normal; extensive checks on the ground following flight failed to produce a valve leakage. The pneumatic control selector valve was eliminated as the cause of the unscheduled vent valve opening in flight.

Three valve replacements (including the original flight valve) were required to obtain an acceptable overboard helium leakage rate through the vent and sense ports. Large inconsistencies among the original bench qualifications at Airesearch, NASA Rocket Room checks, and aircraft functional tests were evident in regard to acceptable helium leaks from valve external ports. For example, one valve leaked 3600 cc/min through the vent port installed in the aircraft and 190 cc/min on the NASA Rocket Room bench. The final valve leakage installed on the aircraft was 200 cc/min.

C. An historical accounting of engine operation with engine S/N 109 follows:

Two flights have been made to date without prior engine ground operations.

4/9/62 Installation  
     
4/11/62 Ground run  
     
4/18/62 1-A-45 Igniter idle operation.
     
4/19/62 1-26-46 Two idle starts; a 10 minute turn accomplished.
  Replaced engine H2O2 safety valve due to seal drain leakage (overboard).  
     
4/27/62 1-A-47 Ground run waived for flight, no engine operation during flight.
     
4/30/62 1-28-48 No discrepancies.
     
  Removed control box for instrumentation harness inspection. Reinstalled the same box.  
     
5/16/62 Ground run Accomplished RMD 15 minute inspection. Noted damp spuds in prime following the run. Post run helium leak check produced no prop valve leakage.
     
5/22/62 1-28-49 Fuel burnout and engine malfunction in overspeed at 77 seconds. Fuel vent valve leak noted prior to pressurization.
     
6/7/62 1-29-50 Ground run waived for flight. Rough engine with chamber pressure decay at 45 seconds (12 second duration.)
     
6/13/62 Post flight inspections complete and preparations for ground run in progress.  
D. The No. 2 APU S/N 18A, installed following flight 1-27-48 exhibited static Oronite leakage through pump shaft seal and overboard. Leakage was not noted during any APU ground load check runs (allowable leakage while running is 3 cc/min Oronite). All leakage discontinued following the load check run prior to flight 1-29-50. Static leakage has been rare in present APU experience. II. Aircraft Configuration Changes A. The screws at station 340.312 which attach fuselage sections at the C. G. Bay were replaced with high shear H-ll alloy 7S36J4A4 and 4A6 screws. TS29 screws of A-286 alloy were replaced. The 7S36J screws do not have full heads, but have a 010-0.020 edge chamfer. The 7S36J screws improve shear load capacity and were specified for use as part of the engineering review of fuselage loads sustained by X-15-2 during the Rosamond Lake landing. It was noted recently that these screws were not incorporated during the rework at NAA in May 1961. III. Instrumentation Configuration Change A. Separation of communications and T/M antenna was accomplished prior to flight 1-28-49. The present configuration uses the previous elevator floor antenna for communications and the newly installed antenna in the LN2 bay cover for T/M. Prior to flight 1-29-50 the upper antenna was removed for use on another X-15, and a plate installed.

B. Impact pressure probes.

All probes were installed prior to flight 1-28-49 and include:

BCS compartment at 20° right of bottom center.

Station 70 at 20° right of bottom center.

Station 70 at 80° right of bottom center.

C. G. compartment at 13° right of bottom center.

R.H. wing leading edge 3 outer pressure pickups.

Upper ventral L.E. - Two on movable and one on fixed ventral.

Lower ventral L.E. - One pitot static probe on fixed ventral.

Preston tube rake - Movable ventral R.H. rear edge.
In order to provide some clearance between X-15 upper ventral probes and the B-52 pylon, the upper fixed ventral probe was shortened to 1-3/8 inches. Clearances on the upper probes, top to bottom positions, were 14-3/8 in., 4-3/8 in., and 1-7/8 in., respectively.

C. A sensitive airspeed meter (O to 1000 knots) was installed in place of the C-6 standby attitude indicator for q profile evaluation. The "dogleg" total source was used.

IV. Preflight Discussion A. Excessive static lube oil leakage from the LOX pump seal port was corrected by motoring the turbine pump with helium. Repositioning the seal reduced leakage within acceptable limits. Maximum leakage accumulation prior to flights on engine S/N 109 in X-15-1 was approximately 50 cc total (200 cc leakage out of 1800 cc total usable capacity has been established as a limit).

B. The LOX topoff probe was inoperative on the fill side following mating to the B-52. The flight was made with partial system operation on the fill end cycle. Following flight the probe was removed and checked on both B-52 #008 and #003 with normal operation.

C. A second repair of a one inch crack in the R.H. side fairing at the wing front spar was accomplished by grinding out the crack to 1/16 inch width and adding a .008 inch thick inconel sheet cover.

D. The R.H. main gear uplock and roller have exhibited an increasing misalignment condition. It is necessary to preload the gear during the securing operation to avoid direct interference. Gear down operation has not been affected and is satisfactory. New parts are in fabrication and will be installed to improve alignment. This problem has occurred sporadically in the past on X-15-1.

E. Leakage from the engine S/N 109 turbine pump gas generator outlet flange has been noted during all post-operation checks with helium in the cold condition. The quantity of leakage produces very fine bubbles and has remained essentially constant (a leak of this quality is designated a foamy leak). Visual checks during pump operation have been made on each of (3) ground runs and indicated no steam leakage at operating temperatures.

V. Flight Events A. The pilot reported "rough" engine operation at approximately 45 seconds following firing. Data indicated a fuel line pressure sag (pump inlet and pump discharge) with related downstream pressure effects starting at 45 seconds following start and lasting for 12 seconds. The timing indicated the fuel level at the time was between the center compartment one-half full and empty condition. Post-flight inspection revealed a jammed open helium check valve in the center compartment feed line complex. This condition would allow pressurization gas to enter the feed line and cause higher O/F ratio engine operation. A temporary fix was accomplished on the helium check valve stop strip to increase stiffness and prevent deflection which allowed the check flapper to jam. A few "routine" items were found in the feed line screen; slip joint seals were in excellent condition.

B. The No. 1 chase pilot reported a delay in prime flow during the engine start sequence. Normal flow was reported prior to the precool select at minus 40 seconds. Data indicates .normal feed line pressure surges at prime select. Post-flight operation was normal. In sufficient time for line shock down is considered to be the cause of the delay between prime select and visual indications of LOX prime.

C. Smoke in the cockpit was reported by the pilot, originating from the forward cockpit area. Inspection of the nose gear compartment indicated extensive heating of the bulkhead heatshield and the area immediately above. Accumulated deterioration of the nose gear door rear seal has occurred allowing an increasing amount of leakage to impinge against the bulkhead heatshield. Repair of the seal was accomplished following flight.

D. The lower ventral recovery system sustained a malfunction, however, ventral recovery was accomplished. The pilot chute drogue did not fire because of a faulty firing pin-initiator cap operation. Evidence indicated only light contact between firing pin and initiator cap. Physical condition of the firing pin indicated a possible interference with a spacer may have absorbed sufficient energy to prevent proper impact on the cap. Repeated firings were made with parts similar to those used in the flight ventral and produced satisfactory results. Based on previous successful operations this malfunction considered to be an isolated case. However, an investigation is being conducted by NAA to determine if significant variations in pin lengths are being produced by the vendor and more rigid control will be exercised.

E. Delamination of the R.H. windshield inner glass occurred during the flight. The affected area covered approximately 4 square inches in the upper rear corner of the windshield and extending to the edge of the glass. Unlike the outer pane which is one piece, the inner pane is constructed of two optically flat plates with a heater core between the plates. The canopy assembly was sent to NAA for windshield replacement and glass analysis.
 
 

Approved by: Prepared by:

Perry V. Row Ronald S. Waite

X-15 Senior Project Engineer X-15 Project Engineer