- Capitalism and the Alternatives -

Communism is NOT idiotic, stalinism is!!

Posted by: 2 punks ( The Netherlands ) on December 11, 1996 at 13:32:18:

In Reply to: Communism is idiotic posted by Katy Aderholdt on November 30, 1996 at 19:09:32:

First, everyone who has read a bit of Marx, Lenin, Trotsky, knows
that 'communism' in Russia started as a mass-revolution, but ended
in a stalinist, totalitarian and repressive regime. Marx's
definition of communism is a 'state' without classes and without
government. People manage their own lives and decide all together.

If you have a bit of brain, you can see that the soviet union was
totally opposite to all of this.

The question should be: where did it go wrong?

Was it because of the 'whites' invasion, the atrocities done by
them, the hunger, the 'war-communism' , the party or the very
weak working class in a half colonial country??

Is it that every form of power corrupts, and so, it had to go
wrong? Or was it the circumstances?

I think the truth lies in between, but i also think that every
attempt to create a society without destruction, oppression,
exploitation (and that is capitalism) is worth a try. Every failed
revolution is a lesson for the future, and one day we will
succeed!!!!

Revolutionary greetings,

2 punks.



Follow Ups:

None.

The Debating Room Post a Followup